Compare consumption-based poverty lines with multidimensional measures of poverty. Which is better suited to targeting welfare in India?
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
A consumption-based poverty line counts people whose monthly spending falls below a set amount. India's official line is still the Tendulkar method, which put poverty at 21.9% in 2011-12 [1]. A multidimensional measure counts what people actually lack in health, education and living standards. NITI Aayog's National MPI estimates that this kind of poverty fell from 29.17% to 11.28% between 2013-14 and 2022-23 [4]. Neither measure is enough for targeting on its own, but the multidimensional approach does better at finding the households that need help.
Comparison
| Basis | Consumption line | Multidimensional (MPI) |
|---|---|---|
| Measures | Lack of money | Deprivation in 12 indicators [4] |
| Data | HCES sample survey | NFHS household data |
| Output | One headcount number | Who is deprived, and in what |
Consumption lines: strengths and limits
- They give one number that can be compared over time, which is needed for SDG-1 reporting and for working out budgets.
- The result depends heavily on where the line is drawn. The Rangarajan lines were 19-41% higher than Tendulkar's, gave much higher poverty counts, and were never adopted [2].
- The World Bank's extreme-poverty estimate fell from 16.2% to 2.3% (2011-12 to 2022-23) [3]. A low figure like this can hide many near-poor households who are still insecure.
- A sample survey cannot identify individual households, and household spending is easy to under-report.
Multidimensional measures: strengths and limits
- They use observable, verifiable deprivations such as cooking fuel, sanitation, schooling and nutrition. Each one maps onto a specific scheme, like Ujjwala, the Swachh Bharat Mission or Poshan.
- They show regional patterns, such as Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and Madhya Pradesh having the largest falls in poverty [4], which helps target spending by district.
- They do not capture income shocks from job loss or health costs. They also respond slowly to new data, because some MPI estimates are projections.
Which is better for targeting?
- For identifying who gets help: the MPI is better because its deprivations are concrete and can be checked household by household.
- For deciding how many people a scheme covers: an updated consumption line, with a second, higher line for the vulnerable, is still needed. PMGKAY covers 81.35 crore people [5], far more than any low poverty headcount, which shows how far schemes have drifted from measured poverty.
The two measures do different jobs: consumption lines measure income adequacy, and multidimensional indices measure deprivation. The way forward is a hybrid approach. Rebuild the official poverty line from the HCES 2022-23 data and revise it on a fixed schedule. Use MPI-type deprivation indicators to identify beneficiaries. Link the two through state-level household registries. This would make targeting both inclusive and efficient, in line with SDG-1 and the Constitution's commitment (Article 38) to reducing inequality.
Sources
- 1NITI Aayog: Press Note on Poverty Estimates, 2011-12Tendulkar-method poverty of 21.9% (2011-12)
- 2PIB: Rangarajan Report on PovertyRangarajan lines higher than Tendulkar's, with higher poverty estimates
- 3PIB Factsheet: World Bank Poverty and Equity Brief on India (2025)extreme poverty fell from 16.2% to 2.3% at $2.15/day
- 4PIB/NITI Aayog: Multidimensional Poverty in India since 2005-06 (Jan 2024)MPI fell from 29.17% to 11.28%, 12 indicators, state-wise falls
- 5PIB: Free Foodgrains for 81.35 crore beneficiaries for five years: Cabinet DecisionPMGKAY coverage