·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Compare consumption-based poverty lines with multidimensional measures of poverty. Which is better suited to targeting welfare in India?

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Comparison
  2. Consumption lines: strengths and limits
  3. Multidimensional measures: strengths and limits
  4. Which is better for targeting?

A consumption-based poverty line counts people whose monthly spending falls below a set amount. India's official line is still the Tendulkar method, which put poverty at 21.9% in 2011-12 [1]. A multidimensional measure counts what people actually lack in health, education and living standards. NITI Aayog's National MPI estimates that this kind of poverty fell from 29.17% to 11.28% between 2013-14 and 2022-23 [4]. Neither measure is enough for targeting on its own, but the multidimensional approach does better at finding the households that need help.

Comparison

Basis Consumption line Multidimensional (MPI)
Measures Lack of money Deprivation in 12 indicators [4]
Data HCES sample survey NFHS household data
Output One headcount number Who is deprived, and in what

Consumption lines: strengths and limits

  • They give one number that can be compared over time, which is needed for SDG-1 reporting and for working out budgets.
  • The result depends heavily on where the line is drawn. The Rangarajan lines were 19-41% higher than Tendulkar's, gave much higher poverty counts, and were never adopted [2].
  • The World Bank's extreme-poverty estimate fell from 16.2% to 2.3% (2011-12 to 2022-23) [3]. A low figure like this can hide many near-poor households who are still insecure.
  • A sample survey cannot identify individual households, and household spending is easy to under-report.

Multidimensional measures: strengths and limits

  • They use observable, verifiable deprivations such as cooking fuel, sanitation, schooling and nutrition. Each one maps onto a specific scheme, like Ujjwala, the Swachh Bharat Mission or Poshan.
  • They show regional patterns, such as Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and Madhya Pradesh having the largest falls in poverty [4], which helps target spending by district.
  • They do not capture income shocks from job loss or health costs. They also respond slowly to new data, because some MPI estimates are projections.

Which is better for targeting?

  • For identifying who gets help: the MPI is better because its deprivations are concrete and can be checked household by household.
  • For deciding how many people a scheme covers: an updated consumption line, with a second, higher line for the vulnerable, is still needed. PMGKAY covers 81.35 crore people [5], far more than any low poverty headcount, which shows how far schemes have drifted from measured poverty.

The two measures do different jobs: consumption lines measure income adequacy, and multidimensional indices measure deprivation. The way forward is a hybrid approach. Rebuild the official poverty line from the HCES 2022-23 data and revise it on a fixed schedule. Use MPI-type deprivation indicators to identify beneficiaries. Link the two through state-level household registries. This would make targeting both inclusive and efficient, in line with SDG-1 and the Constitution's commitment (Article 38) to reducing inequality.

Sources

  1. 1NITI Aayog: Press Note on Poverty Estimates, 2011-12Tendulkar-method poverty of 21.9% (2011-12)
  2. 2PIB: Rangarajan Report on PovertyRangarajan lines higher than Tendulkar's, with higher poverty estimates
  3. 3PIB Factsheet: World Bank Poverty and Equity Brief on India (2025)extreme poverty fell from 16.2% to 2.3% at $2.15/day
  4. 4PIB/NITI Aayog: Multidimensional Poverty in India since 2005-06 (Jan 2024)MPI fell from 29.17% to 11.28%, 12 indicators, state-wise falls
  5. 5PIB: Free Foodgrains for 81.35 crore beneficiaries for five years: Cabinet DecisionPMGKAY coverage

More from this note