·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

India's poverty estimates range from 5% to over 26% depending on the benchmark used. Critically examine the need for a new official poverty line in India.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Why a new official line is needed
  2. Limits and concerns
  3. Way forward

Using the same 2022-23 data, the World Bank finds 2.6% of Indians poor at $3/day but about 16.1% at $4.20/day [1]. The data stays the same and only the line changes. India's last official poverty estimate (21.9% for 2011-12) used the Tendulkar methodology [2], and nothing has replaced it. A new line is needed, but it must be designed carefully.

Why a new official line is needed

  • Outdated basket: Repricing the 2009 Tendulkar line for inflation keeps 2009's idea of "minimum needs". The share of food in spending fell from 53% to 46% in rural areas and from 43% to 39% in urban areas between 2011-12 and 2022-23 [3]. Spending on health, schooling and travel now counts for more.
  • Welfare targeting: PMGKAY gives free foodgrains to 81.35 crore people for five years [4], far more than any low poverty estimate. Without a measured count, schemes are sized by political judgement.
  • Hidden near-poor: The jump from 2.6% to 16.1% shows how many people live just above the extreme line [1]. One illness or crop failure can push them back into poverty.
  • Credibility and SDG-1: With no benchmark, anyone can quote a figure anywhere from 5% to 26%. This weakens evidence-based policy and makes SDG-1 progress hard to judge.

Limits and concerns

  • Every line is arbitrary: Poverty has many dimensions. NITI Aayog's MPI shows 13.5 crore people left multidimensional poverty between 2015-16 and 2019-21 [5], something a spending line alone misses.
  • Comparability: HCES 2022-23 changed its survey design, so comparing a new line with older rounds needs care.
  • Political cost: A stricter line raises the official count and looks like failure. This is one reason the Rangarajan (2014) line was never adopted.

Way forward

  • A NITI Aayog–MoSPI expert group should rebuild the basket from HCES data rather than reprice the old one.
  • Publish two lines, one for extreme poverty and one for vulnerability, as the World Bank does [1]. Keep separate rural and urban lines.
  • Review the line after every HCES round on a fixed schedule, publish a bridge series linking old and new survey methods, and use the MPI alongside it.

The case for a new line is strong, but it should be a set of measures revised on a fixed timetable, not a single frozen number. A credible benchmark would make targeting better, make SDG-1 tracking more honest, and help secure the inclusive growth that Article 38 asks the State to promote.

Sources

  1. 1World Bank, Poverty & Equity Brief: India (latest edition)2.6% at $3/day vs ~16.1% at $4.20/day (2021 PPP); the World Bank reports several lines
  2. 2Planning Commission (NITI Aayog), Press Note on Poverty Estimates 2011-12last official estimate, 21.9%, Tendulkar methodology
  3. 3MoSPI, Household Consumption Expenditure Survey 2022-23 Factsheetfood share of spending fell, 2011-12 to 2022-23
  4. 4PIB, "Free Foodgrains for 81.35 crore beneficiaries for five years: Cabinet Decision" (Nov 2023)PMGKAY coverage
  5. 5PIB, "13.5 crore Indians escape Multidimensional Poverty in 5 years" (Jul 2023)NITI Aayog National MPI

More from this note