·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityEconomyIR

Compare treaty ratification under the U.K.'s parliamentary-sovereignty model with India's executive-led treaty-making. What lessons emerge?

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. U.K.: Parliament as gatekeeper
  2. India: executive primacy
  3. Lessons for India

In both countries the executive negotiates and signs treaties. Both are also dualist: a treaty changes domestic law only when Parliament legislates for it. The real difference is how far the legislature checks the executive before ratification. In the U.K. that check is set out in statute. In India it is left largely to the government's discretion.

U.K.: Parliament as gatekeeper

  • Statutory scrutiny: Under the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act, 2010, a treaty must be laid before Parliament for 21 sitting days. If the Commons passes repeated objecting resolutions, it can block ratification [1].
  • Judicial backing: In Miller (2017), the Supreme Court ruled that the government could not start the process of leaving the EU using executive (prerogative) power alone. An Act of Parliament was needed [2].
  • Current example: PM Burnham will take the U.K.–EU deal to Parliament as a bill. He has left any decision on rejoining the EU to the next Parliament, saying "the British people will be the boss" [3].
  • Limit: Parliament can delay or reject a treaty but cannot amend it.

India: executive primacy

  • Constitutional basis: Article 73 lets the Union's executive power cover treaty-making. Under Article 253, Parliament legislates only to implement a treaty, and that power reaches even subjects on the State List [4].
  • Practice: Piyush Goyal signed the India–U.K. CETA on 24 July 2025 after 14 rounds of talks [5]. The government notified it into force on 15 July 2026, with no mandatory parliamentary vote [6].
  • Merits: The process is fast, keeps negotiations confidential and gives negotiators a free hand.
  • Concerns: Opening about 89.5% of tariff lines [6] was never debated in Parliament beforehand. States carry much of the impact on farming and fisheries but have no formal voice.

Lessons for India

  • Table major treaties for a fixed period: a time-bound tabling rule like the U.K.'s 21-day window [1] adds scrutiny without slowing deals indefinitely.
  • Committee review: the Standing Committee on Commerce could examine FTA impact assessments before ratification.
  • Consult States: because Article 253 reaches State subjects [4], States could be consulted through the Inter-State Council.
  • Avoid a veto: the U.K. model allows rejection only, never amendment. That keeps the executive's negotiating credibility intact.

Overall, the U.K. ties ratification to democratic consent, while India values speed and executive flexibility. India could keep its executive-led model and add a short, statute-based parliamentary review. That would make trade diplomacy more transparent and more federal, in line with the Constitution's ideals of accountable government and cooperative federalism.

Sources

  1. 1Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, Part 2 (legislation.gov.uk): 21-sitting-day laying requirement and the Commons' power to block ratification
  2. 2[R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5, UK Supreme Court](https://supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2016-0196): prerogative alone could not start withdrawal; an Act of Parliament was needed
  3. 3Burnham delays tabling of options for U.K.-EU ties, The Hindu (news report, 17 Nov 2026): U.K.–EU deal to go to Parliament as a bill; rejoin decision left to the next Parliament; "people will be the boss"
  4. 4Constitution of India, Part XI (Ministry of External Affairs): Article 253, Parliament's power to implement international agreements
  5. 5India and UK Sign Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), PIB: signed 24 July 2025 by Piyush Goyal; 14 rounds of negotiation
  6. 6India–UK CETA and Agreement on Social Security Contributions Set to Enter into Force on 15th July 2026, PIB: entry into force on 15 July 2026; about 89.5% of tariff lines opened by India
Practice
7 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity