·PIB·15 marks·250–350 wordsGeographyS&TIR

Critically evaluate the role of ASEAN-led forums such as the East Asia Summit in shaping a "peaceful, prosperous and resilient" Indo-Pacific.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Strengths: how these forums shape the region
  2. Limitations

In the Prime Minister's departure statement for Manila, ahead of the 23rd ASEAN-India Summit and 21st East Asia Summit (EAS) on 17 November 2026, ASEAN is "at the heart" of the Act East Policy. The stated goal is a "peaceful, prosperous and resilient" Indo-Pacific [1]. ASEAN-led forums are very good at bringing countries together but weak at enforcing outcomes.

Strengths: how these forums shape the region

  • Neutral meeting place for peace: the EAS is a leaders' forum on regional challenges, with a focus on Indo-Pacific peace and stability [1]. Because ASEAN sits at the centre, India can engage the region without joining any bloc.
  • Lasting institutions: the Comprehensive Strategic Partnership is reviewed at every summit and backed by a Plan of Action 2026–2030 [3].
  • Resilience at sea: 2026 is the ASEAN-India Year of Maritime Cooperation [3].
  • Springboard for bilateral ties: Modi and Marcos Jr. met on the sidelines of the Jakarta (2023) and Vientiane (2024) summits. Ties were raised to a Strategic Partnership in August 2025 [2].

Limitations

  • Consensus without enforcement: summit statements are not binding. Tensions in the South China Sea persist, so members look for hard security elsewhere. The Philippines became the first foreign buyer of BrahMos (2024) and held its first exercise with India in the South China Sea (August 2025) [2].
  • Slow progress on prosperity: the AITIGA review was ordered in 2022, and real negotiation began only in February 2024 [4]. It was still unfinished at the 10th Joint Committee meeting in August 2025 [5].
  • Thin economic base: India–Philippines trade was only USD 3.34 bn in 2024-25 [2].
  • Overlapping frameworks: groupings that do not include all ASEAN members, such as the Quad, risk weakening ASEAN's central role.

Verdict These forums are necessary but not sufficient. They provide legitimacy, shared norms and regular dialogue. Deterrence and trade gains, however, still come mostly from bilateral and minilateral tracks.

ASEAN-led forums set the rules and the meeting place, while bilateral partnerships do the heavy lifting. India should conclude the AITIGA review and turn the maritime year into concrete results, such as Philippine membership of IFC-IOR [2]. It should also keep ASEAN at the centre, in line with the MAHASAGAR vision [1] and the cooperative spirit of SDG 17. Done together, these steps would make the "peaceful, prosperous and resilient" goal real.

Sources

  1. 1Prime Minister's Departure Statement ahead of his visit to the Philippines, PIB/PMO (Nov 2026)23rd ASEAN-India Summit and 21st EAS; ASEAN "at the heart" of Act East; "peaceful, prosperous and resilient" Indo-Pacific; MAHASAGAR; EAS focus on peace and stability
  2. 2Brief on India-Philippines Bilateral Relations, Ministry of External Affairssideline meetings at Jakarta and Vientiane; Strategic Partnership (August 2025); BrahMos; South China Sea exercise; trade of USD 3.34 bn; IFC-IOR invitation
  3. 3Visit of Prime Minister to Manila, Philippines, PIBASEAN-India Year of Maritime Cooperation 2026; Plan of Action 2026–2030
  4. 43rd Meeting of AITIGA Joint Committee, 16–19 February 2024, PIBreview timeline; negotiation began February 2024
  5. 5India hosts 10th Meeting of AITIGA Joint Committee, PIB (August 2025)AITIGA review still under way in August 2025
Practice
5 questions on this item
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Geography