·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolity

"Electoral roll integrity is compromised not only by the inclusion of ineligible names but equally by the exclusion of eligible ones." Discuss with reference to the recent Form 7 controversy.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Inclusion of ineligible names
  2. Exclusion of eligible names: equally damaging
  3. The Form 7 controversy as an example
  4. Way forward

Article 326 guarantees adult suffrage, and Article 324 makes the Election Commission of India (ECI) responsible for preparing the electoral rolls through which voters use that right. A roll has integrity only if it is both clean and complete. The Supreme Court's recent directions on allegedly fabricated Form 7s in Delhi's Mustafabad constituency show that wrongly removing voters is as serious as keeping bogus names on the roll [1].

Inclusion of ineligible names

  • Dead, shifted and duplicate entries inflate rolls and make impersonation possible. Form 7 exists to remove such names on four grounds: death, being under age, absence or permanent shifting, and duplicate enrolment [2].
  • These errors are the reason for intensive exercises like the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) [1].

Exclusion of eligible names: equally damaging

  • Certain harm versus possible harm: a ghost entry only creates a risk of misuse. A wrongful deletion is certain to cost a voter their vote.
  • Found out too late: voters often learn of a deletion only at the booth, when nothing can be done for that election.
  • Unequal burden: the person objecting proves nothing at the start. The voter has to prove they are alive and still living at the address.
  • Unequal impact: migrants, the poor and minorities find it hardest to challenge a deletion.

The Form 7 controversy as an example

  • The writ petition alleged "ghost Form 7s". Voters marked as dead or shifted were found alive at their recorded addresses, and the people named as objectors denied signing the forms [1].
  • The plea says authorities examined 37 forms and found 36 false [1]. This shows that checks catch fakes when they are actually done, but they struggle when forms arrive in bulk during a time-bound SIR.
  • The Court ordered verification and remedial measures. If the police refuse to register an FIR, it said the petitioner can approach the jurisdictional magistrate [1]. A criminal case, however, cannot give back a lost vote in time.

Way forward

  • Confirm the objector's identity before any notice goes to the voter, for example through OTP-linked filing on the Voters' Portal [2].
  • Require a BLO field report for every "absent/shifted" claim. No deletion without notice and a hearing.
  • Publish objections booth by booth during the claims and objections period.
  • Prosecute forged filings so that abuse carries a real cost.

A clean roll and a complete roll are two halves of the same promise. The ECI should keep removing ineligible names firmly, while guarding against fake objections through verified filers, field checks and due process. That balance would protect universal adult franchise and the public trust that free and fair elections depend on.

Sources

  1. 1SC asks ECI to verify, take remedial measures over misuse of Form 7s in Delhi, The Hindu, 20 Nov 2026 (news report)Mustafabad petition, "ghost Form 7s", 36 of 37 forms claimed false, SIR context, SC directions and the magistrate route
  2. 2Form 7 (English), ECI Voters' Portalpurpose of Form 7, grounds for deletion, online filing through the Voters' Portal
Practice
5 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity