·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

In an era of great-power rivalry in Southeast Asia, can India's call for "cooperation, not competition" turn into strategic advantage? Discuss.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How the call can yield strategic advantage
  2. Constraints that could reduce it to rhetoric
  3. Converting principle into advantage

At the 23rd ASEAN-India Summit in Manila (November 2026), PM Modi said the region's future depends on cooperation rather than competition and reaffirmed India's commitment to ASEAN unity and centrality [1]. With US-China rivalry sharpening, this position can become a strategic asset, but only if India delivers on it.

How the call can yield strategic advantage

  • Non-hegemonic partner: India does not ask ASEAN states to pick sides. This fits ASEAN's own habit of hedging between powers [1].
  • Centrality as leverage: Backing ASEAN-led forums (EAS, ADMM-Plus) gives India a voice where regional rules are set [1].
  • Rules-based maritime order: India's support for a free, open, inclusive Indo-Pacific and its proposed ASEAN-India Maritime Cooperation Plan suit coastal states facing South China Sea pressure [1].
  • Institutional depth: Ties grew from the Strategic Partnership (2012) to the Act East Policy (Nay Pyi Taw, 2014) [3], and then to a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership that turns five in 2027 [2].
  • Soft power: Offers such as free e-visas for ASEAN tourists build on old civilisational links [1].

Constraints that could reduce it to rhetoric

  • Economic gap: India's trade deficit with ASEAN has widened sharply under AITIGA, and the review has dragged on [4]. As a result, India's economic ties lag behind its political ties.
  • Perceived contradiction: Beijing sees India's Quad membership as containment, and some ASEAN states fear being pulled into the rivalry.
  • Connectivity: Instability in Myanmar complicates overland links such as the India-Myanmar-Thailand Trilateral Highway.
  • Capacity gap: China's spending and market size far exceed what India can offer.

Converting principle into advantage

  • Set a fresh, public end-date for the AITIGA review. Pair tariff talks with export competitiveness: logistics and supply-chain integration.
  • Route security cooperation through ASEAN-led mechanisms, and keep Quad work complementary.
  • Fast-track maritime domain awareness, capacity-building and disaster cooperation, building on the summit's joint statement on disaster management [2].

"Cooperation, not competition" suits both ASEAN's wish for strategic autonomy and India's own tradition of non-alignment. Whether it becomes an advantage depends on results: balanced trade, finished connectivity projects and maritime support. If India's actions match its words, it can become ASEAN's partner of choice. That would advance a rules-based Indo-Pacific in the spirit of Article 51, which calls for promoting international peace and security.

Sources

  1. 1PM's Opening Remarks at the 23rd ASEAN-India Summit, PMIndia (Nov 2026)cooperation over competition; ASEAN unity and centrality; free, open, inclusive Indo-Pacific; Maritime Cooperation Plan; free e-visas
  2. 2PM participates in the 23rd India-ASEAN Summit in Manila, PMIndiaComprehensive Strategic Partnership turning five in 2027; joint statement on disaster management
  3. 3India-ASEAN Relations (August 2018), Ministry of External AffairsStrategic Partnership 2012; Act East announced at Nay Pyi Taw 2014
  4. 4Resetting India-ASEAN Trade in 2025, Observer Research Foundationwidening trade deficit under AITIGA; review delays

More from this note