·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsGeographyPolityEconomy

Frequent policy reversals by successive governments undermine public trust and investment. Examine in the context of Andhra Pradesh's capital city debate.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Erosion of public trust
  2. Erosion of investment
  3. Correctives under way
  4. Way forward

Policy credibility depends on commitments outliving the government that made them. Section 5 of the AP Reorganisation Act, 2014 promised Andhra Pradesh "a new capital" but did not name it [3]. As a result, the capital changed with each regime for a decade. This shows how policy reversals wear down both trust and investment.

2014–19   Amaravati chosen; farmers pool land
2019–21   Three capitals proposed, later withdrawn
Mar 2022  HC "Amaravati judgment"; SC appeals pending
2026      Parliament names Amaravati sole capital

Fig: A decade of capital-policy flux

Erosion of public trust

  • Broken social contract: farmers pooled their land for a promised capital. They then had to challenge the "three capitals" plan in the High Court [1].
  • Judicialisation of policy: courts, not political consensus, steered the capital question. Appeals against the HC's 2022 judgment are still pending in the Supreme Court [1].
  • Regional polarisation: a planning decision became a contest between Uttarandhra, Rayalaseema and coastal Andhra.

Erosion of investment

  • Stranded assets: half-built works lay idle. The Centre itself pointed to a "long-pending structural uncertainty" that hurt governance, investment and growth [4].
  • Risk premium: investors discount States where earlier commitments can be undone. This raises the cost of capital.

Correctives under way

  • Statutory lock-in: the AP Assembly passed a Resolution on 28 March 2026. Acting on it, Parliament amended Section 5 to name Amaravati [3]. The HC then declared the three-capitals petitions infructuous [1].
  • Delivery signals: 91 major projects worth over ₹56,000 crore are under way [4]. The State has also promised the SC that it will complete them within three years [1].
  • Caveat: a Central law gains stability at the cost of State autonomy. It names a capital but does not fund or build it [2].

Way forward

  • Cross-party consensus for long-gestation projects.
  • Time-bound delivery of developed plots to land-pooling farmers.
  • Balanced regional growth through industrial corridors and support for backward areas, not split capitals.

Andhra Pradesh shows that policy volatility costs far more than one electoral term: it drains citizens' faith, investor confidence and public money. Building continuity through consensus, statute and timely delivery would honour the principle of legitimate expectation and SDG 16's call for accountable institutions. It can turn Amaravati from a symbol of flux into a model of credible governance.

Sources

  1. 1Pleas against '3-capital' plan for A.P. now infructuous: HC, *The Hindu*, 27 September 2026petitions declared infructuous; 2022 HC judgment and pending SC appeals; December 2024 affidavit promising completion in three years; farmers' challenge to the three-capitals plan (exact article page could not be fetched; domain root linked)
  2. 2PRS Legislative Research, Bill Summary: Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill, 2026Bill only states that Amaravati will be the new capital
  3. 3The Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill, 2026 — Bill text with Statement of Objects and Reasons_Bill,_2026.pdf) — original Section 5 left the capital unnamed; Assembly Resolution of 28 March 2026; amendment naming Amaravati
  4. 4PIB, Historic Amendment to Establish Amaravati as Sole Capital; A Defining Step Towards Stability and Growth91 projects worth over ₹56,000 crore; "long-pending structural uncertainty" (exact release page returned HTTP 403; domain root linked)
Practice
12 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Geography