Ghost-writing and endorsements under a public figure's name raise questions of honesty. Examine the ethical issues involved.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →The ethical problem in both practices is the same. A public figure's name tells the reader who is speaking. When someone else writes the words, or the figure has not tested the claims, the name misleads. In 1926, Britain's Lawn Tennis Association proposed barring players from profiting from books or articles they had not written [1]. That shows the honesty question is an old one.
Ethical issues in ghost-writing
- Deceptive authorship: Readers trust a memoir or column because they think the celebrity wrote it. Hiding the real writer misrepresents the work.
- Profiting from a name: The 1926 proposal applied to "any player" and targeted gaining pecuniary advantage from work one had not written [1]. The wrong was the misrepresentation itself, not just the money.
- Accountability gap: If a ghost-written piece contains errors or plagiarism, it is unclear who answers for it.
Ethical issues in endorsements
- Borrowed credibility: An endorsement uses the trust a figure has built up. Promoting an untested product turns that trust against fans.
- Hidden conflict of interest: Undisclosed payment makes an advertisement look like independent advice. Indian guidelines require influencers and celebrities to disclose any material connection with the advertiser [2].
- Harm to vulnerable consumers: Misleading health or financial claims cause real damage. Under the 2022 CCPA Guidelines, endorsers must have a reasonable basis for their claims [3].
Counterpoints
- Many readers know ghost-writing is common, so open collaboration ("with…") is not deceptive.
- Experts sharing knowledge has public value. A 1926 critic, S. N. Doust, warned that a blanket ban would cut readers off from expert insight [1]. The problem is concealment, not commercial speech as such.
Way forward
- Legal accountability: Section 21 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 allows penalties of up to ₹10 lakh and an endorsement ban of up to one year. Endorsers who exercised due diligence are exempt [4].
- Self-regulation: Credit co-authors openly, use only products one endorses, and refuse claims one cannot verify.
Both practices are acceptable when the audience knows what it is getting, and unethical when they hide it. Disclosure, due diligence and personal accountability would align public figures' conduct with the consumer's right to information and the values of integrity and probity in public life.
Sources
- 1The Hindu, "A Hundred Years Ago: Ban on press articles" (17 Nov 2026, archive of 13 Nov 1926 report)LTA ghost-writing proposal covering "any player"; S. N. Doust's objection
- 2PIB, "Centre releases endorsement guidelines for Celebs and Social Media Influencers" (2023)disclosure of material connection by celebrities and influencers
- 3PIB, "Centre issues Guidelines on Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements for Misleading Advertisements, 2022"endorsers must have a reasonable basis for claims
- 4Consumer Protection Act, 2019, Section 21 (India Code)endorser penalty, endorsement ban, due-diligence exemption