Rules separating 'amateur' from 'professional' have shaped the ethics of sport. Discuss with reference to conflicts of interest and transparency in modern sports governance.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
In 1926 Britain's Lawn Tennis Association proposed barring amateurs from writing for the press, or giving interviews, during tournaments they were playing in [1]. The amateur–professional divide was never only about money. It was sport's first code on who may profit from it, and how openly, and both questions still drive sports governance today.
Amateurism as an early ethical code
- Fame, not play, was the target: the 1926 rule banned articles signed with a player's name, initials or a recognisable pseudonym. An unsigned article was allowed, so the real target was cashing in on celebrity [1].
- Integrity of authorship: the rule also barred any player, amateur or not, from profiting from ghost-written work. This was an early demand for honesty with the public [1].
- Costs: critic S. N. Doust argued the ban took expert commentary away from readers who could not watch matches [1]. Strict amateurism also favoured players who could afford to play without income. Sport later admitted professionals, as in tennis's Open Era, so the ethical focus moved from banning earnings to regulating them.
Conflict of interest in modern governance
- Dual roles: in BCCI v. Cricket Association of Bihar (2015), the Supreme Court struck down an amended rule that had allowed BCCI administrators to hold commercial interests in BCCI events such as the IPL. It also set up the Lodha Committee [2].
- Lodha reforms: the Court accepted reforms to curb conflict-of-interest situations and political and commercial interference [2].
- Statutory route: the National Sports Governance Act, 2025 requires every national sports body to have an ethics committee and a code of ethics covering officials, coaches, athletes and sponsors [3].
Transparency
- Public function, public scrutiny: the Court held that bodies like the BCCI perform public functions, so they are open to judicial review [2].
- Disclosure as the modern ghost-writing rule: structured governance through athlete committees and dispute-resolution bodies brings openness into how decisions are made [3].
- Gaps remain: enforcement depends on the rules the government notifies and on federations' willingness to comply.
Sport has moved from "you may not earn" to "you may earn, openly and within rules." The way forward is independent ethics committees, compulsory disclosure of interests and athlete representation, all following the Lodha Committee's vision. That is how to protect the integrity of sport that the 1926 rule-makers were trying to defend.
Sources
- 1The Hindu, "A Hundred Years Ago: Ban on press articles" (17 Nov 2026, Delhi edition, p. 7)1926 LTA proposal; signed-article, interview and ghost-writing bans; Doust's criticism
- 2Supreme Court of India, *BCCI v. Cricket Association of Bihar* (2015) 3 SCC 251 and 2016 judgment on the Lodha CommitteeRule 6.2.4 commercial-interest amendment struck down; public-function holding; Lodha Committee reforms
- 3National Sports Governance Bill, 2025, as passed by Lok Sabha (PRS Legislative Research)ethics committee, code of ethics, athlete and dispute-resolution committees