·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

"The power to punish for contempt is necessary to uphold the majesty of law, but its use against criticism risks chilling free speech." Critically examine with reference to Article 129 and the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Contempt power as a guardian of the rule of law
  2. Risk of a chilling effect

Article 129 makes the Supreme Court a court of record with the power to punish contempt of itself. The Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 was enacted to "define and limit" that power [2]. The power is needed to protect judicial authority. Whether it guards justice or stifles dissent depends on how narrowly it is used.

Contempt power as a guardian of the rule of law

  • Constitutional foundation: The SC has held that its power under Art. 129 is inherent and plenary. No statute, including the 1971 Act, can abridge it (In Re: Vijay Kurle, 2020) [1].
  • Enforcing compliance: Civil contempt punishes wilful disobedience of court orders. Without it, judgments would not be obeyed [2].
  • Protecting adjudication: Criminal contempt under Sec. 2(c) covers acts that prejudice judicial proceedings or obstruct justice [2].
  • Built-in safeguards: The Act allows truth as a defence when used in the public interest and in good faith [2]. The Law Commission (2018) found the Act had enough safeguards and needed no amendment [3].

Risk of a chilling effect

  • Vague "scandalising" limb: The Act does not define "scandalising or lowering the authority" of a court. This lets courts punish criticism of judges even when it does not obstruct justice [2].
  • Judge in its own cause: The Court is both the aggrieved party and the adjudicator. It is not bound by the Act's procedure [1], which leaves contemnors less procedural certainty.
  • Digital and press speech: The SCBA's criminal contempt petition against MP Sanjay Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle over social media posts on CJI Surya Kant shows the risk. Even a show-cause notice, which is not a finding of guilt, makes critics bear the cost of litigation [4].
  • Balancing restraint: The Bench rightly told Raut that a "seasoned politician" should exercise restraint [4]. The Court has also held that citizens may criticise judgments, short of scurrilous attacks on judges [1].
  • Comparative trend: The UK abolished "scandalising the court" as an offence in 2013. This raises doubts about whether India's version is a reasonable restriction under Art. 19(2).

So the contempt power is indispensable for enforcing orders and protecting trials, but it becomes harmful when used against criticism. The way forward is to:

  • keep contempt for real obstruction of justice;
  • apply the truth defence generously;
  • refer contempt matters that affect a judge personally to a different Bench;
  • expect higher standards of speech from public representatives.

A judiciary secure in its legitimacy upholds both Art. 129 and Art. 19(1)(a). Its majesty rests on public confidence earned through reasoned judgments, not on fear.

Sources

  1. 1Supreme Court of India, *In Re: Vijay Kurle & Ors.*, judgment dated 27 April 2020: Art. 129 power is inherent and cannot be abridged by statute; not bound by the 1971 Act's procedure; citizens may criticise judgments
  2. 2India Code: Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (Act No. 70 of 1971): long title "define and limit"; civil vs criminal contempt; Sec. 2(c); truth as a defence
  3. 3PRS Legislative Research: Review of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (Law Commission Report Summary): Law Commission (2018) found enough safeguards and recommended no amendment
  4. 4The Hindu: "SC pulls up MP Sanjay Raut over remarks on CJI, says 'seasoned politician' should know restraint" (17 Nov 2026): SCBA petition against Raut and Wagle; show-cause notice; Bench's remark on restraint

More from this note