Should 'scandalising the court' remain a ground of criminal contempt in a mature democracy? Discuss in light of recent proceedings against public figures.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →Under Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, criminal contempt includes any publication that scandalises or lowers the authority of a court [2]. The Supreme Court's own power comes from Article 129, and no statute can cut it down [1][4]. The SCBA's petition against MP Sanjay Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle over posts about CJI Surya Kant [5] raises a question: does this limb protect justice, or does it punish criticism?
Recent proceedings: what they reveal
- A show-cause notice was issued, and Raut, a Rajya Sabha MP, was directed to appear in person [5].
- A Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi said a "seasoned politician" should know restraint [5].
- The case was moved by the Bar, not taken up by the Court on its own. This shows institutional concern over online attacks. A notice is not a finding of guilt.
Case for retaining
- Public trust: courts control neither the sword nor the purse. Viral posts by public figures can erode confidence on a large scale.
- Judges cannot reply: by convention judges stay silent, which leaves them unable to defend themselves.
- Law Commission review advised no amendment. It cited the constitutional source of the courts' powers and the Act's existing safeguards [3].
- Constitutional sanction: Article 19(2) lists contempt of court as a reasonable restriction on free speech.
Case against
- Vagueness: "scandalise" is undefined and subjective. This has a chilling effect on journalists and Opposition voices.
- Judge in own cause: the court is victim, prosecutor and judge at once.
- Weak procedural check: the SC's power is not confined to the Act's procedure [4].
- Accountability: like any institution, the judiciary gains legitimacy from reasoned criticism, not from punishing critics.
Way forward
- Narrow it, don't abolish it: limit the ground to wilful falsehoods that pose a real threat to the administration of justice.
- Apply the truth-in-public-interest defence (Section 13) generously [2].
- Prefer an apology and restraint to punishment.
- Adopt ethics codes for legislators on how they speak about constitutional offices.
Scandalising the court is a blunt tool, but a judiciary that cannot answer back still needs it. A mature democracy should keep it only as a narrow, rarely used last resort. That way Article 129 protects judicial independence, and Article 19(1)(a)'s promise of free and fearless criticism stays intact.
Sources
- 1Supreme Court of India judgment on Article 129 contempt jurisdictionthe SC's Art. 129 contempt power cannot be curtailed by statute
- 2Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (Act No. 70 of 1971), India CodeSection 2(c) definition of criminal contempt; truth as a defence in the public interest (Section 13)
- 3PRS Legislative Research: Review of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (Law Commission report summary)Law Commission advised no amendment, citing the constitutional source of powers and existing safeguards
- 4Supreme Court of India judgment dated 27 April 2020SC's contempt power not limited by, or confined to the procedure of, the 1971 Act
- 5The Hindu: "SC pulls up MP Sanjay Raut over remarks on CJI, says 'seasoned politician' should know restraint" (17 Nov 2026)SCBA petition, show-cause notice, physical appearance, Bench composition, "restraint" remark