·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Should 'scandalising the court' remain a ground of criminal contempt in a mature democracy? Discuss in light of recent proceedings against public figures.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Recent proceedings: what they reveal
  2. Case for retaining
  3. Case against
  4. Way forward

Under Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, criminal contempt includes any publication that scandalises or lowers the authority of a court [2]. The Supreme Court's own power comes from Article 129, and no statute can cut it down [1][4]. The SCBA's petition against MP Sanjay Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle over posts about CJI Surya Kant [5] raises a question: does this limb protect justice, or does it punish criticism?

Recent proceedings: what they reveal

  • A show-cause notice was issued, and Raut, a Rajya Sabha MP, was directed to appear in person [5].
  • A Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi said a "seasoned politician" should know restraint [5].
  • The case was moved by the Bar, not taken up by the Court on its own. This shows institutional concern over online attacks. A notice is not a finding of guilt.

Case for retaining

  • Public trust: courts control neither the sword nor the purse. Viral posts by public figures can erode confidence on a large scale.
  • Judges cannot reply: by convention judges stay silent, which leaves them unable to defend themselves.
  • Law Commission review advised no amendment. It cited the constitutional source of the courts' powers and the Act's existing safeguards [3].
  • Constitutional sanction: Article 19(2) lists contempt of court as a reasonable restriction on free speech.

Case against

  • Vagueness: "scandalise" is undefined and subjective. This has a chilling effect on journalists and Opposition voices.
  • Judge in own cause: the court is victim, prosecutor and judge at once.
  • Weak procedural check: the SC's power is not confined to the Act's procedure [4].
  • Accountability: like any institution, the judiciary gains legitimacy from reasoned criticism, not from punishing critics.

Way forward

  • Narrow it, don't abolish it: limit the ground to wilful falsehoods that pose a real threat to the administration of justice.
  • Apply the truth-in-public-interest defence (Section 13) generously [2].
  • Prefer an apology and restraint to punishment.
  • Adopt ethics codes for legislators on how they speak about constitutional offices.

Scandalising the court is a blunt tool, but a judiciary that cannot answer back still needs it. A mature democracy should keep it only as a narrow, rarely used last resort. That way Article 129 protects judicial independence, and Article 19(1)(a)'s promise of free and fearless criticism stays intact.

Sources

  1. 1Supreme Court of India judgment on Article 129 contempt jurisdictionthe SC's Art. 129 contempt power cannot be curtailed by statute
  2. 2Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (Act No. 70 of 1971), India CodeSection 2(c) definition of criminal contempt; truth as a defence in the public interest (Section 13)
  3. 3PRS Legislative Research: Review of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (Law Commission report summary)Law Commission advised no amendment, citing the constitutional source of powers and existing safeguards
  4. 4Supreme Court of India judgment dated 27 April 2020SC's contempt power not limited by, or confined to the procedure of, the 1971 Act
  5. 5The Hindu: "SC pulls up MP Sanjay Raut over remarks on CJI, says 'seasoned politician' should know restraint" (17 Nov 2026)SCBA petition, show-cause notice, physical appearance, Bench composition, "restraint" remark

More from this note