·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolity

Recognising menstrual health as part of Article 21 marks a shift from a supply-centric to a rights-centric approach. Critically examine the challenges in translating this into reliable school-level services.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. The shift: from supply to rights
  2. Challenges in turning the right into services

In Dr. Jaya Thakur v. Union of India (January 2026), the Supreme Court held that menstrual health is part of the right to life under Article 21. It directed States and UTs to provide free sanitary napkins, gender-segregated toilets, usable water and safe disposal in every government and private school [1]. Welfare thus becomes an entitlement, but a right is only real if the service works every month.

The shift: from supply to rights

  • A system, not a product: pads now come with WASH, waste disposal, information and health access [1].
  • Wider reach: private schools are bound too, while the Union Menstrual Hygiene Policy covers only government and government-aided schools [1][4].
  • Enforceability: a girl can go to court. Continuing mandamus keeps States answerable [3].
  • Clear ownership: the MoHFW Secretary has been nodal officer since 2023 [2].

Challenges in turning the right into services

  • Recurring cost vs one-time building cost: toilets are built once, but cleaning, water, supply and bin collection need monthly budgets and staff. These are the first to be dropped.
  • Cheap parts get skipped: worldwide, only 31% of schools have menstrual-waste bins in girls' toilets and 39% teach menstrual health [5].
  • Unfunded mandate: low-fee private schools get no policy funding [4]. They may quietly not comply, or pass costs to parents.
  • Paper compliance: the Court relies on State affidavits [3]. These count packets delivered, not girls actually using the facilities.
  • Waste trade-off: free disposable pads mean more waste, even though the policy seeks environmentally friendly disposal [6]. Small school incinerators pollute the air and landfills take in plastic. Schools have no clear standard under the SWM Rules, 2016.
  • Stigma: beliefs that periods are "impure" stop girls using facilities that exist. Hardware cannot fix this.
  • Separation of powers: courts can set norms but cannot run monthly services or create budget lines.

The rights approach rightly sets a minimum standard, and the States must now design how it is delivered. The way forward:

  • dedicated recurring budget lines under Samagra Shiksha
  • menstrual facilities added to RTE recognition norms for private schools
  • UDISE+ indicators matched to WHO–UNICEF JMP metrics [5]
  • CPCB disposal standards
  • a link to adolescent health work under RKSK

Success should be measured by girls who use the facilities and stay in school. That is how Article 21's promise of dignity, and SDGs 4, 5 and 6, become real.

Sources

  1. 1Supreme Court of India, *Dr. Jaya Thakur v. Union of India*, judgment dated 30 January 2026 (2026 INSC 97)Article 21 recognition; four mandated facilities; all government and private schools; States/UTs to implement
  2. 2Supreme Court of India, Order dated 10 April 2023, Diary No. 35023/2022MoHFW Secretary appointed nodal officer
  3. 3Supreme Court of India, record dated 1 September 2026, Diary No. 35023/2022continuing monitoring of State/UT compliance reports
  4. 4Lok Sabha Unstarred Question No. 3170 (13 December 2024)Union policy covers government and government-aided schools
  5. 5WHO, "Global report reveals major gaps in menstrual health and hygiene in schools" (28 May 2024)31% of schools have bins; 39% teach menstrual health; JMP indicators
  6. 6MoHFW/NHM, Menstrual Hygiene Policy for School Going Girlspolicy aims at environmentally friendly menstrual waste management
Practice
2 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity