"Rewarding design and IPR, not just assembly, is the next frontier of Make in India." Critically analyse.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →Most of Make in India's early gains in electronics came from final assembly, where little value is added in India. On 20 November 2026, MeitY revised the Domestic Value Addition (DVA) method for six IT-hardware products bought by government. The new method credits each manufacturing step and adds weightage for Indian design and IPR [1]. The shift is needed, but it is not yet enough on its own.
Why design and IPR are the next frontier
- Capturing value: most of a device's value lies in its design and intellectual property, not its assembly. Giving weightage to in-house R&D and Indian design/IPR pushes firms up the value chain [1].
- Deeper manufacturing: the Bill of Materials (BoM)-based method credits SMT mainboard assembly, bare PCBs, RAM/SSD testing and packaging, displays and power modules. "Screwdriver" assembly alone no longer earns full credit [1].
- Assured demand: the PPP-MII Order, 2017, issued under Rule 153(iii) of GFR 2017 [2], turns government into a steady first buyer for Indian-designed laptops, servers and panels.
- Supply and demand together: PLI 2.0 (₹17,000 crore) covers laptops, AIO PCs and servers [3]. The procurement preference adds a buyer for what PLI-backed firms make.
- Trade room: India is only an observer to the WTO Government Procurement Agreement, so it is free to prefer local suppliers [4].
Limitations
- Vague weights: design and IPR get only "additional" weightage and R&D gets "adequate" weightage. No percentages are given, so firms cannot plan investment [1].
- Weak checks: firms self-certify their DVA, and it is verified only "where required" [1]. A server's BoM has hundreds of parts across many supplier tiers, so firms can over-claim.
- The chip gap: making the processor chip itself is not credited, and memory gets credit only for assembly and testing [1]. A high DVA score does not mean technological independence.
- Thin base, higher cost: PLI IT hardware produced ₹10,000 crore of output and 3,900 jobs in 18 months, against a projected ₹3.5 lakh crore and 47,000 jobs [3]. A stricter test may shrink the pool of bidders and raise prices.
Way forward
- Publish numeric R&D/IPR weights within the six-month lead time [1].
- Run random BoM audits on GeM instead of relying on complaints from rival bidders.
- Align PLI incentives with DVA depth.
Process-based DVA moves Make in India from "assembled in India" towards "designed in India". With measurable weights, credible verification and a link to semiconductor ambitions, it can build lasting capability in line with Atmanirbhar Bharat and SDG 9 (industry, innovation and infrastructure).
Sources
- 1PIB, Ministry of Electronics & IT: Revised DVA methodology for six IT-hardware products under the PPP-MII Order (20 Nov 2026)process-based BoM method, credited activities, R&D/design/IPR weightage, self-certification, six-month lead time, PPP-MII Order 2017
- 2PIB, Ministry of Commerce & Industry: Public Procurement (Preference to Make in India) OrderOrder issued under Rule 153(iii) of GFR 2017
- 3PIB, Ministry of Electronics & IT: PLI 2.0 for IT Hardware progress (Jan 2025)₹17,000 crore outlay and products covered; ₹10,000 crore output and 3,900 jobs; ₹3.5 lakh crore and 47,000 jobs projected
- 4WTO: Agreement on Government Procurement — parties, observers and accessionsIndia is an observer, not a party