·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

A short-term renewal versus a comprehensive revision: critically evaluate the options before India on the Ganga Water Treaty in light of climate stress on the basin.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Option 1: Short-term renewal (3–5 years)
  2. Option 2: Comprehensive revision
  3. Verdict

The India–Bangladesh Ganga Water Treaty was signed in December 1996 for 30 years and expires in December 2026 [1]. Climate change is shifting Himalayan river flows and raising salinity in the delta [4]. India's real choice is therefore about sequencing: a short renewal first, then a full revision. It is not a choice between two rival options.

Option 1: Short-term renewal (3–5 years)

Merits

  • Avoids a legal vacuum: from 1988 to 1996 there was no agreement and flows were unpredictable. A lapse now would hit Bangladesh's February farming peak [1].
  • Feasible: a revised treaty cannot be agreed in the four weeks left [1].
  • Keeps institutions working: the Joint Committee, led by Joint Rivers Commission members, checks water sharing at Farakka. It had met 83 times by January 2024 [2].
  • Low cost to India: Indian works at Farakka already have to respect the treaty. The 2016 Cabinet approval of a new navigational lock said the work must not affect water sharing [3].

Limits

  • Keeps a weak formula: the treaty splits the lean-season (January–May) flow in 10-day blocks [2]. It has no rule for drought years, when much less water reaches Farakka.
  • Removes deadline pressure: one renewal could lead to another, with no reform.

Option 2: Comprehensive revision

Merits

  • Prepares for climate change: World Bank modelling shows that if Gorai river flow falls from 150 to 15 m³/s, the 2 ppt salinity line moves inland. Dry-season river water at Khulna is already above 12 ppt [4].
  • Ecological flow: a revision could set a minimum flow for the river itself and for the Sundarbans. The present formula has none.
  • Deals with the main complaint: the World Bank found that dry-season shortages still hold back south-west Bangladesh despite the treaty [5].

Limits

  • Time and data: a revision needs shared flow data and climate projections that both sides trust.
  • Federal politics: the riparian states, West Bengal and Bihar, have to agree. The unsigned Teesta deal shows what happens when a state is left out.
  • Risk of lapse: trying to finish a full revision before expiry could leave no treaty at all.

Verdict

  • Renewal alone puts off the climate risk. Revision alone, attempted now, risks a lapse.
  • The best course is a bridge renewal for a fixed term. It should carry a written timetable for revision, a joint study of climate and flow data, and seats for the riparian states in the Indian delegation.

A short renewal secures the present, and a planned revision secures the future. By keeping its word to a downstream neighbour, India strengthens Neighbourhood First. It also gains a stronger case to ask the same of China on the Brahmaputra. The test of the renewal is whether it leads to a treaty built for climate change, in line with SDG 6 (water) and the principle of fair use of shared rivers.

Sources

  1. 1India and Bangladesh should support temporary renewal of Ganga Water Treaty: expert — The Hindu, 16 Nov 2026 (news report)1996 signing and 30-year term; December 2026 expiry; 1988–96 gap; February farming peak; revision not possible in four weeks
  2. 2Year End Review 2024: Department of Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation — PIBJoint Committee had met 83 times by January 2024; lean-season sharing in 10-day blocks
  3. 3Cabinet approves transfer of land from Farakka Barrage Project to IWAI for a new navigational lock at Farakka (2016) — PIBthe lock must not affect sharing under the 1996 treaty
  4. 4River Salinity and Climate Change: Evidence from Coastal Bangladesh, Policy Research Working Paper 6817 — World Bankclimate-driven change in flows; Gorai flow and the 2 ppt line; Khulna above 12 ppt
  5. 5South Asia Water Initiative Final Report 2009–2013 — World Bankdry-season flows still hold back south-west Bangladesh despite the treaty

More from this note