India and Bangladesh should support temporary renewal of Ganga Water Treaty: expert
FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →In this note
- At a Glance
- Why in the News
- Background & Evolution
- Core Static Facts
- Multi-Dimensional Analysis
- Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
- Prelims Hooks
- Why a 'Bad Treaty' Is Still Worth Keeping
- What the 1996 Formula Does Not Fix
- The Case Against a Quick Renewal, and Its Answer
- Why Delhi Cannot Decide Alone
- What a Short Renewal Should Carry With It
- Anchors for Answers
- Mains Relevance
- Related Topics to Study Next
- NCERT Concepts to Revise
- Common Errors / Trap Areas
1. At a Glance
- The India–Bangladesh Ganga (Ganges) Water Treaty is a 30-year agreement for sharing Ganga water at Farakka. It was signed in December 1996 and expires in December 2026 [1].
- An expert from Bangladesh says a fully revised treaty cannot be agreed in the four weeks left. He wants a stop-gap renewal for 3–5 years, which would need approval at the highest political level [1].
- Why it matters for UPSC: it is a test case for managing rivers shared across borders, for India's Neighbourhood First policy, for Centre–State relations in foreign policy (West Bengal and Bihar have stakes), and for water security in the lower delta [1][2].
2. Why in the News
- On 15 Nov 2026, Manjur Ahmed Chowdhury, former Chairman of the National River Conservation Commission of Bangladesh, said a revised treaty was impossible before expiry. He called for a temporary renewal of 3–5 years [1].
- His argument: "having a bad treaty is also better than not having any treaty at all" [1].
- He warned that Bangladesh needs the most Ganga water in the February farming season. Without a treaty, India would have no duty to release water at regular intervals, which would hurt Bangladesh's farming, economy and ecology [1].
- Commentators argue that the Ganga basin is under stress and that the treaty needs more than a simple renewal [2].
3. Background & Evolution
- Before 1996: for eight years (1988–1996) there was no agreement in force, and Bangladesh suffered from unpredictable Ganga flows [1].
- December 1996: the Ganga Water Treaty was signed [1].
- What it achieved: predictable flows, which helped Bangladesh [1].
- December 2026: the treaty expires after 30 years [1].
- Not verified this session (standard reference; check before quoting): the Farakka Barrage was commissioned in 1975. Earlier arrangements were a 1977 agreement and MoUs in 1982 and 1985. The last of these ran out in 1988, which matches the 1988–96 gap above.
4. Core Static Facts
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Parties | India and Bangladesh [1] |
| Signed | December 1996 [1] |
| Duration | 30 years; expires December 2026 [1] |
| Sharing point | Farakka (West Bengal) [1] |
| Bangladesh's peak need | February farming season [1] |
| What it provides | Committed releases at regular intervals, i.e. predictable flows [1] |
| Expert's proposal | Renew for 3–5 years "at the last moment", with top-level political approval [1] |
| Indian ministry in charge | MEA (diplomacy); Ministry of Jal Shakti (technical side) — not verified this session |
Not verified this session (standard reference; check before quoting):
- Lean season: 1 January to 31 May, divided into 10-day periods.
- Sharing formula:
| Flow at Farakka | India | Bangladesh |
|---|---|---|
| ≤ 70,000 cusecs | 50% | 50% |
| 70,000–75,000 cusecs | The rest | 35,000 cusecs |
| ≥ 75,000 cusecs | 40,000 cusecs | The rest |
- Guarantee clause: each country gets a guaranteed 35,000 cusecs in alternate 10-day periods between 11 March and 10 May.
- Reviews: every 5 years, or earlier if either side asks.
- Oversight body: the Joint Rivers Commission (JRC), set up in 1972.
5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
Geopolitical / Strategic
- How the renewal is handled will test India's Neighbourhood First commitment towards a lower-riparian neighbour [1].
- Chowdhury says a deal needs "green signal" from the political leadership of both sides, so it is a matter for top political leaders, not a technical file [1].
- Letting the treaty lapse would bring back the unpredictable flows of 1988–96, which could become a source of tension [1].
Economic
- Bangladesh's farming in February depends on Ganga releases [1].
- Assured flows matter for the wider economy of Bangladesh's south-west [1].
Environmental
- The ecology of the lower basin depends on regular dry-season flows [1].
- The basin is under stress, so a straight renewal may not be enough. A revised treaty may need to address climate change and how much water the river itself needs to stay healthy [2].
Legal / Governance
- The treaty is an executive international agreement made under the Union's foreign-affairs power. Not verified this session: Entry 10 and Entry 14 of the Union List, and Article 253.
- Federal tension: riparian states (West Bengal, Bihar) want a say in a Union subject. Not verified this session.
Historical
- The 1988–96 gap with no agreement shows what it costs to have no treaty at all [1].
6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
- Dec 2026: the treaty's expiry date [1].
- 15 Nov 2026: the Bangladeshi expert calls for a temporary 3–5 year renewal [1].
- Ongoing: commentators say the treaty "needs more than renewal" because the Ganga is under stress [2].
- Reported only by outlets outside the permitted sources, so not cited here: MEA statements that talks will run through existing bilateral mechanisms, including the JRC; demands from West Bengal and Bihar; Bangladesh reportedly seeking 40,000 cusecs against 35,000; Bangladesh saying in Oct 2026 that India had not responded to its request.
7. Prelims Hooks
- The Ganga Water Treaty was signed in December 1996 [1].
- It runs for 30 years and expires in December 2026 [1].
- Water is shared at Farakka, West Bengal [1].
- From 1988 to 1996 no water-sharing agreement was in force [1].
- Bangladesh's demand for Ganga water peaks in February, during the farming season [1].
- The National River Conservation Commission is a Bangladeshi body, not an Indian one [1].
- The expert proposed a 3–5 year interim renewal [1].
- Not verified this session: the treaty was signed by H.D. Deve Gowda and Sheikh Hasina in New Delhi.
- Not verified this session: the lean season is 1 Jan to 31 May.
- Not verified this session: the guarantee is 35,000 cusecs in alternate 10-day periods from 11 Mar to 10 May.
- Not verified this session: the JRC was set up in 1972.
- Not verified this session: the Farakka Barrage was commissioned in 1975. It diverts water into the Bhagirathi–Hooghly to keep Kolkata Port navigable.
8. Why a 'Bad Treaty' Is Still Worth Keeping
- The treaty gives the two countries a place to talk about the river every year
- Water sharing under the treaty is checked by a Joint Committee. Members of the Joint Rivers Commission (JRC) from both sides lead it [3].
- By January 2024 this committee had met 83 times. The 83rd meeting was in Dhaka [3].
-
If the treaty lapses, this regular forum loses its legal basis. Any dispute would then go straight to the political leaders, with no technical step in between.
-
Indian projects at Farakka are also judged against the treaty
- In 2016 the Union Cabinet approved a new navigational lock (a gate that lets ships pass a barrage) at Farakka. One condition was that the work must not affect water sharing under the 1996 treaty [7].
-
So the treaty also limits India's own works at Farakka. Without it, Bangladesh loses this written promise.
-
Without a treaty, India would owe Bangladesh no release at all
- The Farakka Barrage began sending Ganga water south into India in 1976. Bangladesh said this took away water that its south-west needed [4].
-
The note already records 1988–96, the eight years with no agreement [1]. A short renewal means that does not happen again during the February farming peak.
-
Why this matters for India as well
- India is the upper riparian (the upstream country) on the Ganga. On the Brahmaputra it is the lower one, facing China.
- If India keeps its word to a smaller downstream neighbour, it can fairly ask China to treat India the same way.
9. What the 1996 Formula Does Not Fix
- The treaty divides whatever water reaches Farakka. It does not make sure enough water arrives.
- The formula splits the lean-season (dry-season, January–May) flow in 10-day blocks [3].
- It has no rule for a year when far less water reaches Farakka. Climate studies now point to worse dry-season shortages in some years and sudden high flows in others, as rainfall changes and Himalayan glaciers melt [2].
-
So when the river is weak, both countries just share a smaller amount. Nothing in the treaty acts on the cause.
-
Bangladesh says it often gets less than its share in the driest weeks
- Bangladeshi civil society and policy experts often say Bangladesh has not always got its fair share in the most critical lean-season periods. They blame weak points in the formula [2].
-
The World Bank says that even with the treaty, dry-season flows are still a problem. Growth in the Ganges Dependent Area of south-west Bangladesh is held back by too little water [5].
-
Low flow lets seawater move inland
- The Gorai river carries Ganga water into south-west Bangladesh. This area is one of the poorest in Bangladesh [5].
- The World Bank modelled what happens if Gorai flow falls from 150 to 15 cubic metres per second. The line of 2 ppt salinity (parts per thousand, a measure of how salty water is) moves inland [6].
- In the dry season, river water at Khulna stays above 12 ppt [6]. That is too salty for most crops and for drinking.
-
So the fight over cusecs is also a fight about salt in farms and in the Sundarbans.
-
The river's own needs have no share in the formula
- The formula splits water between India and Bangladesh only. There is no fixed amount for ecological flow (the minimum water a river needs to stay alive).
- This is the main reason commentators say the treaty needs more than a simple renewal [2].
10. The Case Against a Quick Renewal, and Its Answer
- The strongest objection: a renewal keeps a weak formula and removes the pressure to fix it
- The deadline is the one moment both governments must sit down together.
- If the same text is renewed, the climate and salinity problems above go on for another 3–5 years. The next deadline could end with yet another quick renewal.
-
Commentators say the basin needs an ecological reset, not just a new date on the old text [2].
-
What the objection gets right
- Talks have been slow. In 2025 the Government told Parliament that bilateral talks on renewal had not yet started [8].
- This was after PM Modi had said that technical-level talks on renewal would begin [8].
-
So the risk of doing nothing until the last moment is real. It is happening now.
-
Why it still does not win
- The choice in November 2026 is not 'renewal or a better treaty'. It is 'renewal or no treaty'. A new treaty cannot be agreed in four weeks [1].
- A lapse would hit Bangladesh in the February sowing peak, with no rule for releases [1].
- The fair answer: renew, but only for a short, fixed term with a clear plan for revision attached. A short renewal is a way to buy time, not to stop at the old text.
11. Why Delhi Cannot Decide Alone
- The Centre signs the treaty, but West Bengal lives next to the barrage
- In June 2024 the West Bengal Chief Minister and the Centre clashed in public over the treaty's review. The Centre rejected her claim [9].
-
The row shows a state can make a treaty politically costly even when it has no legal power over it.
-
Teesta shows what happens when a state is left out
- The Teesta deal was never signed (see the note's trap areas). West Bengal's objection is widely seen as the reason.
-
If the Ganga revision follows the same route, a short renewal could quietly become the permanent fix.
-
Bangladesh may move the issue to a global stage
- Bangladesh has joined the UN Water Convention, a global treaty on shared rivers. It is a different treaty from the 1997 Watercourses Convention listed in the note [10].
- India has usually preferred to settle river issues bilaterally, without outside parties [10].
- If talks stall, Dhaka can now judge India's conduct against international rules, not just the 1996 text. That raises the cost of delay for India.
12. What a Short Renewal Should Carry With It
- MEA and Bangladesh: renew for a fixed 3–5 years, with deadlines for revision written in
- The interim deal should say when each stage of revision talks must happen.
-
This answers the worry that a short renewal is only a way to delay [2][8].
-
Ministry of Jal Shakti and the JRC: build a shared set of flow data before the formula is rewritten
- The Joint Committee already measures flows at Farakka [3]. Its job can grow to joint study of climate effects on lean-season flow.
- The World Bank's South Asia Water Initiative is a model. It brought basin countries together on shared river knowledge [5].
-
If both sides trust the same numbers, the old 'you gave us less' fight gets smaller [2].
-
Include salinity and ecological flow in the revised treaty
- The revised text should set a minimum flow into the Gorai in the driest weeks. Salinity in the south-west rises when Gorai flow falls [6].
-
Only an agreed minimum flow fixes the salt problem. Dredging the river alone has not worked.
-
The Centre: put West Bengal and Bihar in the talks from the start
- Ask the riparian states to name officials to the Indian delegation, so they are part of the deal and not outsiders.
-
The 2024 row with West Bengal shows what happens when a state feels left out [9].
-
Keep the treaty as the test for Indian works at Farakka
- Keep the 2016 Cabinet condition: new works must not affect the sharing arrangement [7]. Writing it into the renewal shows good faith at low cost to India.
13. Anchors for Answers
- Data: If Gorai river flow drops from 150 to 15 cubic metres per second, the 2 ppt salinity line moves inland. Dry-season river water at Khulna stays above 12 ppt salinity [6]
- Data: The India–Bangladesh Joint Committee that checks treaty sharing had met 83 times by January 2024 [3]
- Report/Committee: World Bank, South Asia Water Initiative Final Report (2009–2013). It found dry-season flows still hold back the Ganges Dependent Area despite the treaty [5]
- Law/Case: 2016 Union Cabinet decision on the Farakka navigational lock. The work must not affect sharing under the Ganga Water Treaty, 1996 [7]
- Comparison: Bangladesh has joined the UN Water Convention. India prefers bilateral settlement of river issues [10]
- Scheme: Namami Gange / NMCG. Whether India keeps enough flow in the Ganga upstream decides how much reaches Farakka to be shared
14. Mains Relevance
- GS-II: India and its neighbourhood; bilateral agreements affecting India's interests.
- GS-I: Physical geography (river systems); distribution of water resources.
- GS-III: Water resource management; environmental flows; conservation.
- Possible question stems: 1. The impending expiry of the Ganga Water Treaty (1996) is both a challenge and an opportunity for India–Bangladesh relations. Discuss. 2. Examine the role of riparian states in India's transboundary river diplomacy, with reference to the Ganga and Teesta. 3. A short-term renewal versus a comprehensive revision: critically evaluate the options before India on the Ganga Water Treaty in light of climate stress on the basin.
15. Related Topics to Study Next
- Teesta water-sharing deadlock: a parallel case where state politics blocked a deal.
- Indus Waters Treaty (1960) and its 2025 abeyance: compare treaty design and dispute mechanisms.
- Joint Rivers Commission and the 54 shared rivers: the institutional framework for India–Bangladesh river ties.
- Farakka Barrage and the Bhagirathi–Hooghly: the infrastructure behind the dispute; navigability of Kolkata Port.
- Mahakali (1996) and Kosi/Gandak treaties with Nepal: other Indian river treaties.
- China's Brahmaputra (Yarlung Tsangpo) dams: India as a lower riparian.
- UN Watercourses Convention (1997): principles of equitable use and of not causing significant harm.
- Namami Gange / NMCG: the state of the Ganga's health and flows within India.
16. NCERT Concepts to Revise
- Transboundary rivers (Geography): The treaty is a case of sharing a river across borders, with the 1996 treaty named.
- Farakka Barrage (Geography): Farakka is the point where India and Bangladesh share the Ganga's dry-season flow.
- Joint Rivers Commission (Geography): The JRC is the bilateral body that handles technical talks and oversight on shared rivers.
- Riparian rights (Geography): Explains why, without a treaty, India as upper riparian has no duty to release water.
- Guarantee clause (Geography): The treaty's guaranteed minimum release is a key point in the renewal and revision debate.
- Neighbourhood First Policy (Polity): How India handles the renewal tests its priority for ties with neighbours.
- Ganga basin (Geography): The basin is under stress, which is why a plain renewal may not be enough.
- Tista river (Geography): The unsigned Teesta deal is the parallel case where West Bengal's politics blocked agreement.
- Centre-state relations (Polity): West Bengal and Bihar want a say in a treaty that the Union negotiates.
- Union List (Polity): Foreign affairs and treaties sit in the Union List, so the Centre signs such agreements.
- UN Watercourses Convention 1997 (Polity): Gives the equitable-use and no-significant-harm principles used to judge shared-river deals.
- Indus Waters Treaty (Polity): Another India river treaty, useful to compare design, disputes and its 2025 abeyance.
- Ganga river (Geography): The river whose water is shared; know its course and where it splits into Bhagirathi-Hugli and Padma.
- Climate change (Geography): Climate stress on river flows is a reason to revise the treaty, not just renew it.
17. Common Errors / Trap Areas
- The treaty has not been renewed automatically. It was signed for 30 years and expires in December 2026. Any renewal needs a new political decision [1].
- The 1988–96 gap: this was a period without any agreement. Do not confuse it with the treaty's own term [1].
- Which body is whose: the National River Conservation Commission belongs to Bangladesh. India's equivalent work falls under the Jal Shakti ministry and the NMCG [1].
- Ganga vs Teesta: the Ganga treaty exists and has been in force. The Teesta agreement has never been signed.
- Cusec figures: 35,000 is the guaranteed release, applied in alternate 10-day periods. 40,000 is India's share when flow is above 75,000 cusecs. Do not swap them. (Not verified this session.)
Sources
- 1India and Bangladesh should support temporary renewal of Ganga Water Treaty: expert — Kallol Bhattacherjee, The Hindu, 16 Nov 2026, p. 4thehindu.com · tier 4
- 2The Ganga is under stress — The treaty needs more than renewal — Down To Earth (only a fragment came back in search results; cited for its main argument only)downtoearth.org.in · tier 4
- 3Year End Review 2024: Department of Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation (PIB)pib.gov.in · tier 1
- 4Farakka Barrage — Britannicabritannica.com · tier 3
- 5South Asia Water Initiative Final Report 2009–2013 — World Bankdocuments1.worldbank.org · tier 2
- 6Policy Research Working Paper 6817: River Salinity and Climate Change — World Bankdocuments1.worldbank.org · tier 2
- 7Cabinet approves transfer of land from Farakka Barrage Project to IWAI for a new navigational lock at Farakka (PIB)pib.gov.in · tier 1
- 8Talks on Ganga Water Treaty renewal with Bangladesh yet to begin: Govt — Business Standardbusiness-standard.com · tier 4
- 9Centre refutes Mamata Banerjee's claim on Ganga Water Treaty review — Business Standardbusiness-standard.com · tier 4
- 10Bangladesh's accession to the UN Water Convention has a ripple effect that could cause problems with India — Down To Earthdowntoearth.org.in · tier 4