·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Should the Model Code of Conduct be given statutory backing? Discuss its strengths and limits in curbing pre-poll inducements.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Strengths in curbing inducements
  2. Limits
  3. Should it be statutory?

The Model Code of Conduct (MCC) is a code agreed by political parties. No law backs it. The Election Commission of India (ECI) enforces it through its powers under Article 324 and through moral pressure [2]. How it handles pre-poll inducements shows its value and its gaps. That argues for giving legal force to some parts only, not the whole code.

Strengths in curbing inducements

  • Bar on the ruling party: once polls are announced, it cannot announce fresh financial grants or promise new projects [2][4].
  • Manifesto discipline: after S. Subramaniam Balaji (2013), the ECI added Part VIII. Parties must now explain how they will fund their promises [2].
  • Speed: because the code is not a law, the ECI can act on the spot during a campaign of about 45 days [3].

Limits

  • Late trigger: the code applies only once the schedule is announced. Before that, governments can advertise at public expense [3][5]. For example, Punjab's CM made job-creation claims at 'Lok Milni' meetings months before the 2027 polls [1].
  • Legal gap: promises are not a "corrupt practice" under the RPA, 1951 [2], so breaking the code carries no direct penalty.
  • Welfare exception: advertisements on poverty-alleviation and health schemes are exempt [4][5]. That is where most welfare claims sit.
  • No affordability test: the RBI flagged Punjab's free-utility freebies, such as free power, as a fiscal risk [6].

Should it be statutory?

  • For: the Standing Committee on Law and Justice (2013) recommended making the MCC part of the RPA, which would make it enforceable and deter violations [3].
  • Against: the ECI argues that court cases take longer than elections, so complaints would be decided only after the results [3]. Stricter rules could also worsen the "governance deficit", where governments delay policy decisions during the code period [7].
  • Middle path:
  • give legal force only to violations with lasting effects, such as misuse of public funds, and leave quick campaign enforcement with the ECI;
  • notify the ECI's financial-viability proforma, which asks parties how they will pay for promises [4];
  • restrict government advertisements for up to six months before polls [5].

The MCC's strengths, speed and consensus, are also why it is weak against pre-poll inducements. Selective legal backing, combined with funding disclosure and an earlier limit on advertisements, would keep the ECI's speed while closing the gap before polls are announced. This serves the promise of free and fair elections under Article 324.

Sources

  1. 1"Don't fall for electoral gimmicks, Punjab CM Mann tells public" (PTI), The Hindu, 16 Nov 2026Lok Milni job claims ahead of 2027 polls
  2. 2Election Commission of India, *Leap of Faith* Vol. 2, p. 260MCC has no statutory backing; Subramaniam Balaji; Part VIII; promises not a corrupt practice; bar on new grants
  3. 3PRS Legislative Research, Report Summary: Electoral Reforms – Code of Conduct for Political Parties and Anti-Defection Law (2013)Standing Committee's call for RPA backing; ECI's objection on delay; ~45-day window
  4. 4PRS Legislative Research blog, note on key features of the MCCruling-party bar; poverty and health advertisement exception; financial-viability proforma
  5. 5PRS blog, "Model Code of Conduct and the 2014 General Elections"Law Commission (2015) on advertising before the schedule; six-month restriction proposal
  6. 6RBI Bulletin, "State Finances: A Risk Analysis" (June 2022)Punjab's freebie risk from free utilities
  7. 7PRS blog, "Model Code of Conduct and the 2019 General Elections"Law Commission (2018) on the MCC's "governance deficit"

More from this note