·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 words

Victims remain spectators in India's criminal justice system. Critically analyse this in light of recent bail and remission controversies.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Victims as spectators: the evidence
  2. The counter-view: victims as participants
  3. Way forward

The Malimath Committee (2003) found that the victim is given no right to take part in a trial "except as a witness" [1]. In November 2026 the Supreme Court suspended the sentences of two Bilkis Bano convicts, and the survivor learnt of it from the media [2]. Both show the claim is largely true, though courts have given victims some room.

Victims as spectators: the evidence

  • No notice at the bail stage: An appeal is fought between the convict and the State. The Supreme Court bench granted bail because the two had spent more than 17 years in prison, and it did not hear Bano [2].
  • Remission decided without the victim: Gujarat's 2022 remission orders were "stereotyped" and passed without application of mind. They rested on a May 2022 court order obtained by "fraud on the court" [3].
  • The law still has a gap: PRS notes that the 2023 criminal law Bills left out several committee recommendations [4]. For the BNSS, the Standing Committee asked only that victims be told how the investigation is going [5]. It gave them no right to be heard after conviction.
  • Rules that do not match: The government's 2018 Gandhi-150 special remission scheme excluded rape convicts [6]. Suspension of sentence by a court has no such exclusion.

The counter-view: victims as participants

  • Courts have recognised victims: In Bilkis Yakub Rasool (2024), the Supreme Court held that Bano's Article 32 petition could be heard. It quashed the remission and ordered the convicts to surrender within two weeks [3].
  • Rights in the law: The 2009 changes to the CrPC gave victims the right to appeal against an acquittal and to receive compensation (Section 357A). The BNSS keeps both.
  • The convict's rights also count: Suspension of sentence is a lawful power of the courts, and the convictions still stand [2]. Appeals that stay pending for years can justify interim relief.

Way forward

  • Amend BNSS Sections 430 and 473 so that victims of grave offences must get notice and a hearing. The Malimath Committee [1] and the Draft National Policy on Criminal Justice, which cites UN norms [7], both urged victim participation.
  • Courts should issue an internal direction to notify victims when a convict applies for bail, and fix time-bound hearings for old appeals.
  • The MHA should issue model remission rules with one exclusion list for all States, as the 2018 scheme had [6].

Victims have moved from spectators to partial participants. Courts hear them when they go to court themselves, but nobody has to tell them when convicts seek release. A legal right to be heard after conviction would balance reform of the convict with justice for the victim. It would also give effect to Article 21's promise of a fair procedure for victims as well as the accused.

Sources

  1. 1Committee on Reforms of Criminal Justice System (Malimath Committee) Report, MHA (2003): victims get no role except as witnesses; recommended that victims be able to take part
  2. 2The Hindu: "Opposition questions Supreme Court order in Bilkis Bano case" (Nov 2026): bail after more than 17 years in custody; Bano not told; convictions stand
  3. 3*Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India*, 2024 INSC 24: Supreme Court of India Digital SCR: "stereotyped" remission orders; fraud on the court; Article 32 petition can be heard; surrender within two weeks
  4. 4PRS Legislative Research: Overview of Criminal Law Reforms: committee recommendations left out of the 2023 Bills
  5. 5Rajya Sabha Standing Committee Report on the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023: victim to be told only the status of the investigation
  6. 6Cabinet approves Special Remission to Prisoners on 150th Birth Anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi (2018): rape convicts excluded
  7. 7Report of the Committee on Draft National Policy on Criminal Justice, MHA: neglect of victims; UN norms on victim participation

More from this note