·The Hindu

Opposition, OBC group voice concerns on 287 ‘other’ religions in the Census

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →
In this note
  1. At a Glance
  2. Why in the News
  3. Background & Evolution
  4. Core Static Facts
  5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
  6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
  7. Prelims Hooks
  8. Why a Caste Drop-Down Is Harder Than It Sounds
  9. The Government Changed Its Mind but Has Not Explained the Fix
  10. Is the 287-Religion Row Overblown?
  11. Anchors for Answers
  12. Mains Relevance
  13. Related Topics to Study Next
  14. NCERT Concepts to Revise
  15. Common Errors / Trap Areas

1. At a Glance

  • Census 2027 is India's first digital Census with a self-enumeration (SE) option. It is also the first since Independence to include caste enumeration, which the Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs (CCPA) approved on 30 April 2025 [1][2].
  • Controversy: the SE portal briefly showed a drop-down of 287 "Other" religions. The list included entries such as ISKCON, Ramkrishna Paramhansa, Shia, Sunni and Pentacostal. It disappeared within hours of The Hindu's queries to the Union Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) [3].
  • Why it matters: the list mixes up religion, sect, denomination, sampradaya and organisation. It also raises questions about transparency in data collection. The caste question uses an open field rather than a drop-down, and critics say this weakens data quality [3].
  • UPSC relevance: GS-I (society, communalism, caste), GS-II (Census as a governance tool, federalism, transparency) and Essay. It ties into delimitation, reservation and welfare targeting.

2. Why in the News

  • 17 November 2026: opposition leaders and the All India OBC Students' Association raised concerns after The Hindu reported the 287-option "Other" religion drop-down [3].
  • Jairam Ramesh (Congress, Rajya Sabha MP) called the classification "bizarre" and said it "defies any understanding" [3].
  • Saket Gokhale (All India Trinamool Congress) criticised "backdoor software changes" to the Census portal and compared them to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls [3].
  • The All India OBC Students' Association wants a drop-down for all castes under the caste question in the second phase of Census 2027. It condemned the government's approach as "utterly absurd, inconsistent and irresponsible" [3].

3. Background & Evolution

  • (Static; not from retrieved sources): India's first synchronous Census was held in 1881. The last full caste enumeration was in 1931. Censuses from 1951 to 2011 counted only SCs and STs. SECC 2011 collected caste data, but the caste data was never fully released.
  • (Static): Census 2021 was postponed because of COVID-19, and the next round became Census 2027.
  • 30 April 2025: the CCPA decided to include caste enumeration in the next Census [1][2].
  • 2026, Phase 1 (Houselisting Operations, HLO): each State or UT has its own 30-day window. One PIB schedule lists 16 May–14 June 2026 [1][2].
  • Self-enumeration opens 15 days before each State/UT's houselisting window [1][2].
  • February 2027, Phase 2 (Population Enumeration): caste is enumerated in this phase [1][2].
  • November 2026: the 287-religion drop-down appeared on the portal and was then removed after media queries [3].

4. Core Static Facts

Item Fact
Nature First digital Census; first with self-enumeration [1][2]
SE portal se.census.gov.in, available in 16 languages [1][2]
SE ID Respondents generate a unique SE ID before the enumerator's visit [1][2]
SE window 15 days before each State/UT's 30-day HLO window [1][2]
Phases Phase 1: HLO (2026). Phase 2: Population Enumeration (Feb 2027) [1][2]
Caste question Asked in Phase 2 [1][2]
Decision body CCPA, 30 April 2025 [1][2]
Nodal ministry MHA, through the Office of the Registrar General & Census Commissioner (RGI) [3]; RGI link is static
Contested feature 287 "Other" religion options in a drop-down, later removed [3]
Static (unverified here) Census is Entry 69, Union List, Seventh Schedule (Art. 246). Statutory basis: Census Act, 1948. Individual Census data is confidential under the Act
Static (unverified here) 2011 Census: six named religions (Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain), plus "Other Religions and Persuasions" (about 0.7%) and "Religion not stated"

5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis

Social

  • The 287 options mixed sects of Islam (Shia, Sunni), Christian denominations (Pentecostal), a Hindu-Vaishnava organisation (ISKCON) and guru-based traditions (Ramkrishna Paramhansa, Gorak Nath, Tantric) under one "Other religion" label [3]. This can fragment or blur community counts.
  • Adivasi groups have long asked for a separate Sarna/tribal religion code (static). How the "Other" category is designed directly affects tribal self-identification.
  • The OBC groups' demand rests on the fact that without a standardised drop-down, free-text caste entries can produce thousands of spelling variants and synonyms that are hard to code. SECC 2011 ran into this problem (static) [3].

Ethical / Governance

  • The list was removed silently, with no public notification, within hours of media queries [3]. This raises questions about transparency and version control of the Census software.
  • Critics compare it to the SIR of electoral rolls [3]. The concern is that administrative tech changes made without consultation can undermine trust in foundational datasets.
  • There is an inconsistency: a long drop-down was used for religion, but the caste question, where standardisation is most needed, has none [3].

Legal / Constitutional

  • (Static): The Census is a Union subject (Entry 69, List I) under the Census Act, 1948. Census data feeds into delimitation (Arts. 82, 170), SC/ST reservation in legislatures (Arts. 330, 332) and local-body reservation (Arts. 243D, 243T).
  • Caste data could reopen debate over the 50% ceiling on reservations set in Indra Sawhney (1992) (static). That makes accuracy legally important.

Administrative / Technological

  • The digital SE portal has features such as the SE ID and 16 languages [1][2]. It allows faster processing but depends on sound back-end taxonomy and code lists.
  • Self-entered data is checked by the enumerator during the field visit. Because of this, errors in drop-down design carry through to both modes.
  • Free-text fields mean heavy post-enumeration coding. Pre-coded drop-downs reduce this but require a validated master list, for example a State-wise caste list.

Political

  • The opposition and OBC groups are pushing for credible caste data as the basis for "proportional representation" demands. The government faces pressure to show the exercise is technically sound [3].

6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)

  • 30 April 2025: CCPA approved caste enumeration in the next Census [1][2].
  • 2026: PIB published State-wise schedules for HLO and self-enumeration (e.g., 16 May–14 June 2026 for some areas) [1][2].
  • 2026: the SE portal (se.census.gov.in) went live in 16 languages with SE ID generation [1][2].
  • November 2026: the 287 "Other" religions drop-down appeared on the SE portal and was removed after The Hindu's queries to MHA [3].
  • 17 November 2026: Congress, AITC and the All India OBC Students' Association raised objections and demanded a caste drop-down in Phase 2 [3].
  • Upcoming, February 2027: Population Enumeration, including caste [1][2].

7. Prelims Hooks

  • Census 2027 is India's first digital Census [1][2].
  • The self-enumeration portal is se.census.gov.in [1][2].
  • The SE facility is available in 16 languages [1][2].
  • Self-enumerating respondents generate a unique SE ID [1][2].
  • The SE window opens 15 days before a State/UT's 30-day houselisting window [1][2].
  • The CCPA (not the full Cabinet or NITI Aayog) approved caste enumeration on 30 April 2025 [1][2].
  • Caste is enumerated in Phase 2 (Population Enumeration, February 2027), not during houselisting [1][2].
  • The portal briefly listed 287 "Other" religion options [3].
  • The Census is administered by the MHA through the RGI (not MoSPI) [3]; RGI link is static.
  • (Static): Census is in Entry 69, Union List and is governed by the Census Act, 1948.
  • (Static): The last full caste enumeration was in 1931.
  • (Static): Census 2011 named six religions. Everything else went under "Other Religions and Persuasions".

8. Why a Caste Drop-Down Is Harder Than It Sounds

  • The open caste field has already failed once
  • In SECC 2011, people wrote their caste in their own words. Many wrote a sub-caste, a clan name or a community name instead of a caste [4].
  • The Union government later told the Supreme Court that this raw caste data had mistakes and technical flaws. It said the data could not be used for official purposes [4].
  • Census 2027 again has a single open caste question, labelled "SC/ST/Caste" [5][6]. So the OBC students' fear has a real basis: the same method may give the same messy result.

  • But a drop-down needs one agreed list, and India does not have one

  • Outside the notified SC and ST lists, there is no official rule on what counts as a valid caste entry [7].
  • OBC lists are made separately by the Centre and by each State. The same group can have different names, or be listed in one State and not in another.
  • A drop-down built on one list would leave out anyone whose name is missing. That is an exclusion error (a real group gets left out). A loose list lets in wrong entries. That is an inclusion error (a group gets counted that should not be) [7].

  • What this means for the debate

  • Free text means a lot of cleaning work afterwards. A fixed list makes the answer wrong for anyone it leaves out.
  • Neither option is clean. The honest question is not "drop-down or not". It is who builds the master list (one official list that every answer is matched to), and whether that list is made public.

9. The Government Changed Its Mind but Has Not Explained the Fix

  • In 2021 the Centre said a backward-class caste count was administratively difficult [4]
  • It gave the SECC 2011 data problems as the reason [4].
  • In April 2025 the CCPA reversed this and approved caste enumeration [1][2].
  • The government has said it put caste into the main Census, not a separate survey, to protect social harmony [8]. That explains where caste is asked. It does not explain how the SECC problem of messy answers will be solved.

  • The coding rules are the real decision, and they are not public

  • Coding means matching each written answer to a fixed number in a back-end list. That list decides what finally gets counted.
  • The 287-religion list was most likely part of this hidden coding system. Most people saw it only when it appeared on the portal by mistake [3].
  • If the religion list mixed sects, denominations and organisations, the caste list may have the same kind of errors. Nobody outside the RGI's office can check this today.

  • What should follow

  • MHA and the RGI should publish the religion and caste code lists before the main Phase 2 count in February 2027. States, communities and experts could then flag missing or wrong names in time.
  • The RGI should keep a public change log for the portal (a dated record of every software change). Then a silent removal like this one [3] can be checked, and the "backdoor changes" charge [3] can be answered with evidence, not denial.

10. Is the 287-Religion Row Overblown?

  • The strongest case that it is
  • Every Census turns free-text religion answers into codes. The 2011 Census already had an "Other Religions and Persuasions" category for answers outside the six main religions (static).
  • So a long list of 287 entries may just be an internal coding dictionary. It does not mean the government treats ISKCON or Shia as separate religions.
  • It was also removed within hours [3]. Fixing an error quickly is what a working system should do.

  • What this argument gets right

  • A coding list is normal and necessary. Having one is not a scandal in itself.
  • Fixing it fast is better than leaving it up.

  • Where it falls short

  • A list you can see changes what people choose. Inside the office, a code list only sorts answers. On the screen, a drop-down suggests answers. A Sunni Muslim who sees "Sunni" under "Other religion" may pick it, and then they would not be counted as Muslim.
  • A silent fix leaves two versions of the form. People who filled the form while the list was live answered a different question from everyone else. No notice was issued [3], so nobody can tell how many answers were affected or how they will be corrected.
  • Trust matters more than usual this time. This Census decides delimitation (redrawing seats) and possibly reservation shares. A small software error then becomes a political dispute, as the comparison with SIR shows [3].

  • Verdict: the list itself was probably a technical slip. The real failure is that nobody was told. Transparency costs very little, and the lack of it is what turned a slip into a row.

11. Anchors for Answers

  • Data: Census 2027 has a single open caste question, "SC/ST/Caste". The 2011 form asked only about SC/ST status [5][6]
  • Data: 287 "Other" religion options were briefly shown on the self-enumeration portal and then removed without notice [3]
  • Report/Committee: Union government's affidavit to the Supreme Court (2021): SECC 2011 caste data had technical flaws and could not be used for official purposes [4]
  • Law/Case: Census Act, 1948 and Entry 69, Union List. The Centre alone designs the questions and the code lists (static)
  • Comparison: SECC 2011 (open field, data never released) [4] vs Census 2027 (caste inside the main Census, for social harmony) [8]. Same open-field method, so the same risk

12. Mains Relevance

13. Related Topics to Study Next

  • SECC 2011: shows the earlier failure of free-text caste data.
  • Delimitation after 2026 (Art. 82 freeze): Census 2027 data will drive seat reallocation.
  • Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls: opposition critics drew a direct parallel [3].
  • Indra Sawhney (1992) and the 50% ceiling: caste data may reopen this debate.
  • Bihar Caste Survey (2023) and state-level surveys: these are precedents for caste counts.
  • Sarna religion code demand: linked to how the "Other religion" category is designed.
  • Sub-categorisation of OBCs (Rohini Commission): needs granular caste data.
  • NPR and Census linkage: a concern about overlapping data collection.

14. NCERT Concepts to Revise

  • Census 2027 (Geography): The article's main subject: India's first digital census, which also counts caste for the first time since 1931.
  • Caste census (Polity): Explains the move to count all castes, which is the basis of the drop-down demand.
  • Self-enumeration (Geography): The online portal where the 287-religion list appeared before enumerators visited and verified.
  • Houselisting and Housing Census (Geography): Phase 1 of the Census, which has the self-enumeration window; caste is asked later, in Phase 2.
  • Registrar General of India (Polity): The office under the Home Ministry that runs the Census; helps avoid the MoSPI trap.
  • Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs (Polity): The body that approved caste enumeration on 30 April 2025, a likely Prelims fact.
  • Socio-Economic and Caste Census 2011 (Polity): Earlier caste count whose caste data was never released, showing the data-quality problems critics fear.
  • Special Intensive Revision (Polity): Opposition compared the portal changes to this electoral roll exercise, so you need to know what it is.
  • Delimitation (Polity): Census data decides how constituencies are redrawn, which is why accurate counts matter.
  • Fifty per cent ceiling on reservations (Polity): Caste data could reopen the debate on the Indra Sawhney limit on reservations.
  • Sub-categorisation of OBCs (Polity): Dividing the OBC quota needs detailed caste data, one reason clean caste enumeration matters.
  • Bihar caste survey (2023) (Polity): A state-level precedent for counting castes, useful for comparison in answers.
  • Transparency (Polity): The list was withdrawn silently, raising questions about openness in how Census software and data are handled.
  • Communalism (Polity): Mixing sects, denominations and organisations under 'Other religion' bears on how religious identity is counted and politicised.
  • Union List (Polity): The Census is a Union subject (Entry 69), so the Centre alone controls its design.

15. Common Errors / Trap Areas

  • Wrong ministry: the Census is under MHA (RGI), not MoSPI or NITI Aayog [3].
  • Wrong phase: caste is collected in Phase 2 (2027), not Phase 1 houselisting (2026) [1][2].
  • Wrong decision body: caste inclusion was approved by the CCPA [1][2].
  • Category confusion: Shia/Sunni are sects of Islam, Pentecostal is a Christian denomination and ISKCON is an organisation. None is a separate religion, which is the core of the criticism [3].
  • "First caste census": it is the first caste enumeration since Independence (the last was in 1931), not the first ever (static).

Sources

  1. 1PIB document on Census 2027 (April 2026)static.pib.gov.in · tier 1
  2. 2PIB document on Census 2027 (May 2026)static.pib.gov.in · tier 1
  3. 3Opposition, OBC group voice concerns on 287 'other' religions in the Census — The Hindu, 17 Nov 2026thehindu.com · tier 4
  4. 4Caste Census of backward classes administratively difficult: Govt to SC (PTI)business-standard.com · tier 4
  5. 5Caste count returns to Census after 1931 as Centre notifies 40 questionsbusiness-standard.com · tier 4
  6. 6Census 2027 to Include Caste Question for First Time in Independent India, Says MHA Notificationdowntoearth.org.in · tier 4
  7. 7Caste Census debate: Data gaps, political risks, and social equitybusiness-standard.com · tier 4
  8. 8Press Note Details: Press Information Bureau (caste enumeration in Census)pib.gov.in · tier 1

Mains Q&A on this note

NCERT concepts in this note

Also on 18 November

All 18 November articles →