·The Hindu

Turning police reform into practice

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →
In this note
  1. At a Glance
  2. Why in the News
  3. Background & Evolution
  4. Core Static Facts
  5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
  6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
  7. Prelims Hooks
  8. Mains Relevance
  9. Related Topics to Study Next
  10. NCERT Concepts to Revise
  11. Common Errors / Trap Areas
Practice
6 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

1. At a Glance

  • Internal police reform means changes the police can make inside their own organisation: how stations work, how complaints are handled, how personnel are managed and how citizens are treated. This is different from structural reform, which needs laws, new bodies or more money. [1]
  • Trigger: a project by the Indian Police Foundation (IPF) on "internal police reforms", supported by the Azim Premji Foundation, which ends in a change manual. [1]
  • Main claim: apart from recommendations that need structural change, the proposed reforms would not put an extra budget burden on the government. Many fixes are low-cost administrative changes, not money problems. [1]
  • UPSC relevance: it links the long-pending Prakash Singh (2006) directives (structural reform) with day-to-day citizen-centric policing (GS-II governance, GS-III internal security, GS-IV accountability). [1][2]

2. Why in the News

  • An op-ed by R.K. Vij, "Turning police reform into practice" (The Hindu, 19 November 2026), argues for taking the IPF's internal-reform project forward. [1]
  • The IPF expert group met in New Delhi on 4–5 November 2026 to finalise the change manual for internal reforms. [1]
  • The project is headed by Ish Kumar, a retired IPS officer. [1]
  • The IPF team's sample survey found that police-station experience is still poor "even after 79 years of Independence". [1]

3. Background & Evolution

  • 22 Sept 2006: the Supreme Court decides Prakash Singh v. Union of India, the benchmark judicial push for structural police reform. [2]
  • 21 Oct 2015: the Indian Police Foundation is set up as a multidisciplinary think tank for police reform. [1]
  • 2025–26: the IPF runs its "internal police reforms" project, supported by the Azim Premji Foundation, including a sample survey of citizens and police personnel. [1]
  • Nov 2026: the expert group finalises the change manual (4–5 Nov) and the op-ed appears (19 Nov). [1]
  • How the approach has shifted: from top-down, law- and court-driven structural reform (2006 directives) to bottom-up internal reform that the police can implement themselves without new legislation. [1][2]
  • Related earlier efforts (marked †, see note in §11): the National Police Commission (1977–81); the Soli Sorabjee committee's Model Police Act (2006)†.

4. Core Static Facts

Item Fact
IPF: what it is Multidisciplinary think tank for police reform through research, capacity building, policy advocacy [1]
IPF founded 21 October 2015 [1]
IPF composition Coalition of police professionals and citizen stakeholders; expert group of serving and retired police officers, researchers, academicians [1]
Project "Internal police reforms", supported by the Azim Premji Foundation [1]
Project head Ish Kumar, retired IPS [1]
Output Change manual for internal reforms (finalised 4–5 Nov 2026, New Delhi) [1]
Method Sample survey by the IPF team [1]
Fiscal claim No extra budget needed, except for structural recommendations [1]
Landmark SC case Prakash Singh v. Union of India, judgment 22 Sept 2006 [2]
Constitutional placement "Police" and "Public order" are State List subjects (Seventh Schedule, List II)†

Survey findings (the problem diagnosis) [1]

  • Citizens' side:
  • People are reluctant to visit police stations.
  • They often need multiple visits before a complaint is registered.
  • They fear harassment.
  • They are not kept informed about how inquiries are progressing.

  • Police side:

  • Excessive workloads.
  • Inadequate weekly rest days.

5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis

Administrative

  • The core idea is a split between internal reform (process and HR changes, little or no cost) and structural reform (laws and institutions). [1]
  • A change manual is an implementation tool, not a statute. Its uptake depends on each state police leadership choosing to use it. [1]
  • Problems with complaint registration point to front-desk and process design at stations. [1]

Governance / Ethical

  • Keeping complainants informed about inquiry progress is a matter of transparency and procedural fairness. [1]
  • Fear of harassment undermines trust and legitimacy, and leads to under-reporting. [1]
  • Accountability failures persist years after the 2006 directives. [1][2]

Social

  • Barriers at the station hit vulnerable complainants hardest (poor people, women, marginalised groups). This is an inference from the survey's access findings. [1]
  • The survey also brings in the police personnel's side, which treats police welfare as part of reform. [1]

Legal / Constitutional

  • Prakash Singh (2006) is the judicial benchmark for structural reform. [2]
  • Because police is a State subject†, reform is federal: the Centre can only nudge, and states have to act.

Economic / Fiscal

  • The no extra budget claim weakens the usual excuse of fiscal constraint for not reforming. [1]
  • Structural recommendations, such as more manpower to cut workloads, would still cost money. [1]

6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)

  • 2025–26: the IPF runs the internal police reforms project and sample survey, supported by the Azim Premji Foundation. [1]
  • 4–5 Nov 2026: the IPF expert group meets in New Delhi and finalises the change manual. [1]
  • 19 Nov 2026: R.K. Vij's op-ed in The Hindu calls for the project to be taken forward. [1]
  • Sept 2026: 20 years since the Prakash Singh verdict (22 Sept 2006), which renewed scrutiny of how far states have complied. [2]

7. Prelims Hooks

  • The Indian Police Foundation (IPF) was set up on 21 October 2015. [1]
  • The IPF is a multidisciplinary think tank working on police reform through research, capacity building and policy advocacy. [1]
  • The IPF's "internal police reforms" project is supported by the Azim Premji Foundation, not by a government ministry. [1]
  • The project is headed by Ish Kumar, a retired IPS officer. [1]
  • The project's output is a "change manual" for internal reforms, finalised in New Delhi, 4–5 Nov 2026. [1]
  • The IPF's expert group includes serving and retired police officers, researchers and academicians. [1]
  • Survey finding: citizens need multiple visits to get complaints registered. [1]
  • Survey finding: police personnel report excessive workload and inadequate weekly rest days. [1]
  • Internal reforms, except structural ones, are said to need no extra budget. [1]
  • The Prakash Singh v. Union of India judgment was delivered on 22 September 2006. [2]
  • "Police" and "Public order" are in the State List of the Seventh Schedule.†

8. Mains Relevance

  • GS-II: Governance, transparency and accountability; Centre–State relations; role of civil society and NGOs (IPF, Azim Premji Foundation).
  • GS-III: Internal security, and the bodies and agencies handling it.
  • GS-IV: Accountability, empathy and service orientation in public service; ethics of police conduct.
  • Possible question stems: 1. "Police reform in India has focused on structural changes while neglecting internal reforms that need no extra budget." Critically examine. (GS-II, 15 marks) 2. Two decades after Prakash Singh (2006), police reform remains incomplete. Discuss the barriers and suggest a way forward. (GS-II/III) 3. Citizens' reluctance to approach police stations reflects a trust deficit. How can citizen-centric policing and police welfare be reconciled? (GS-III/IV)

9. Related Topics to Study Next

  • Prakash Singh (2006) directives and state compliance: the structural counterpart to internal reform.
  • Model Police Act (2006)† and state Police Acts: the legislative route to reform and how states diluted it.
  • Seventh Schedule: police as a State subject: the federal limits on central action.
  • Police Complaints Authorities: the accountability mechanism behind the "harassment" finding.
  • SMART Policing / citizen perception surveys (IPF): earlier IPF work measuring citizen satisfaction.
  • BNSS 2023 (new criminal procedure code): FIR / e-FIR / Zero FIR provisions: these address the complaint-registration barrier.
  • Police welfare and working hours (manpower vacancies): these explain the workload and rest-day complaints.
  • 2nd ARC Report on Public Order: a governance-reform reference framework.

10. NCERT Concepts to Revise

  • Prakash Singh case (Polity): The 2006 Supreme Court directives are the benchmark for structural police reform that internal reform complements.
  • Police (Polity): The whole article is about reforming how police stations and personnel work.
  • State List (Polity): Police is a State subject, so reform depends on states acting, not the Centre.
  • Seventh Schedule (Polity): Explains the division of subjects between Union and states that places police with states.
  • Model Police Act 2006 (Polity): The Sorabjee draft law is the legislative route to structural reform, unevenly adopted by states.
  • National Police Commission (Polity): Earlier comprehensive review of policing whose ideas fed later reform directives.
  • Accountability (Polity): Complaint handling and harassment findings show gaps in police answerability to citizens.
  • Transparency (Polity): Keeping complainants informed about inquiry progress is a transparency and fairness issue.
  • Trust deficit (Polity): Citizens' reluctance to visit stations reflects low public confidence in police.
  • First Information Report (Polity): Multiple visits to get complaints registered point to problems with FIR registration.
  • Zero FIR (Polity): BNSS 2023 provision that tackles barriers to registering complaints at any station.
  • Civil society (Polity): IPF and Azim Premji Foundation are non-government actors driving this reform effort.
  • Centre-state relations (Polity): Reform is federal: the Centre can only nudge while states must implement.
  • Second Administrative Reforms Commission (Polity): Its report on public order and citizen-centric administration is a governance reform reference.

11. Common Errors / Trap Areas

  • IPF vs BPR&D: the IPF is a non-governmental think tank (2015). It is not the MHA's Bureau of Police Research & Development. [1]
  • Who supports the project: the Azim Premji Foundation, not the MHA or NITI Aayog. [1]
  • Internal vs structural reform: the "no extra budget" claim covers only internal reforms; structural ones still cost money. [1]
  • Year of Prakash Singh: the judgment is from 2006. 1996 is when the petition was filed†. [2]
  • Subject list: police is in the State List, not the Concurrent List†. Do not confuse it with criminal law and procedure, which are in the Concurrent List†.

Sources

  1. 1Turning police reform into practice, R.K. Vij, The Hindu, 19 Nov 2026thehindu.com · tier 4
  2. 2Prakash Singh v. Union of India, Supreme Court of India judgment (22 Sept 2006)api.sci.gov.in · tier 1
At the end · practice MCQs
6 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

NCERT concepts in this note

Also on 19 November

All 19 November articles →