Accrual-basis taxation
Also called: Taxation of unrealised gains, Mark-to-market taxation · Topic: Taxation: Direct and Indirect Taxes, GST and Global Tax Issues · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
Accrual-basis taxation taxes the gain on an asset every year as its value goes up, even if the owner has not sold it. A gain that exists only on paper, before any sale, is called an unrealised gain. The method is also called mark-to-market taxation, because each year the asset is valued at its current market price ("marked to market") and the rise in value is taxed. It stops people from putting off tax for years by simply holding on to assets. The main problem is liquidity: the owner may owe tax without having received any cash, and may have to sell part of the asset to pay it. Valuing assets every year is also hard and costly to run.
Example
Suppose an investor buys shares for ₹10 lakh, and by the end of the year they are worth ₹12 lakh. Under accrual taxation, the ₹2 lakh rise is taxed that year even though nothing was sold. India does not do this. It taxes listed equity only when the shares are sold, at 12.5% on long-term gains above ₹1.25 lakh (rules from July 2024). The Netherlands plans to tax financial assets on accrual under its "Box 3" reform, but the IMF says the reform has been put off to 2028.
Don't confuse with
- Realisation-basis taxation: here the gain is taxed only when the asset is sold. India's capital gains tax works this way.
- Notional-return taxation: tax is charged on an assumed yield, not the real rise in value. The old Dutch Box 3 used this method, and the Dutch Supreme Court struck it down in 2021.