Administrative Assignment of Spectrum
FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →Also called: Administrative allocation of spectrum · Topic: Infrastructure: Transport, Communications and Energy · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
Administrative assignment of spectrum means the government gives the right to use certain radio frequencies by its own decision, at a price it fixes, instead of selling them through an auction. Under the Telecommunications Act, 2023 this is allowed only for the uses listed in the Act's First Schedule.
It matters because spectrum (the radio frequencies that carry calls, data and TV signals) is a scarce public resource. The method used to give it out decides how much the public earns from it and whether new firms can enter, such as satellite internet providers. It also affects whether the method can pass the fairness test the Supreme Court set in the 2G case.
Explanation
How it works under the 2023 Act
- Auction is the default rule. Section 4(4) of the Telecommunications Act, 2023 says spectrum is assigned by auction. The exceptions are the entries in the First Schedule, which are assigned administratively.
- The First Schedule is the list of exceptions. It already names satellite services such as:
- DTH (direct-to-home TV);
- VSAT (small dish terminals used by banks, ATMs and remote offices);
- GMPCS (satellite phone service);
-
MSS (mobile satellite service) in the L and S bands.
-
PRS also notes that satellite services like DTH and satellite telephony are given spectrum by administrative allocation.
- The government can add to the list. Under Section 4(5), the government can add entries to the First Schedule by notification for three reasons:
- public interest;
- government functions;
-
where auction is not suitable for technical or economic reasons.
-
The notification is only "laid before" (placed on the table of) Parliament. The brief does not say Parliament must vote on it.
Why satellite spectrum is usually not auctioned
- Shared, not exclusive use. A mobile operator buys a band for its own use only in a telecom circle. Satellite frequencies are normally shared by several operators over the same area.
- An auction gives a band to the one highest bidder.
-
That does not fit a resource many operators must share at the same time.
-
Feeder and user links are assigned separately. A feeder link connects the satellite to the gateway (the ground station). A user link connects the satellite to the end user.
- In the satellite communication network (SCN) framework, feeder-link spectrum is FSS (fixed satellite service) and is assigned administratively.
- User-link spectrum is FSS and/or MSS, if the partner's service falls in the First Schedule.
"Administrative" does not mean "free"
- The government still charges for the spectrum. The price comes from a formula, not from bidding.
- TRAI's minimum spectrum charge for SCN providers is Rs 3,500 per MHz per year.
-
In May 2025, TRAI recommended a spectrum charge of 4% of AGR, with a per-MHz minimum, for NGSO FSS and MSS. AGR (adjusted gross revenue) is the revenue on which telecom levies are calculated. NGSO means non-geostationary satellites, i.e. satellites that move across the sky, like low-orbit constellations.
-
Worked example (illustrative numbers):
- Suppose a satellite firm holds 100 MHz of spectrum and has an AGR of ₹1,000 crore.
- Charge on revenue = 4% × ₹1,000 crore = ₹40 crore.
- Minimum floor at the SCN rate = 100 × Rs 3,500 = Rs 3.5 lakh a year.
-
This shows that in administrative assignment, the price formula does the work an auction would have done. If the formula is set too low, the public loses revenue.
-
The SCN assignment period is short. Spectrum is assigned for up to 5 years, extendable by up to 2 years.
In India
- Law: The Telecommunications Act, 2023. The Bill was introduced in Lok Sabha on 18 Dec 2023. It repealed the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 and the Indian Wireless Telegraphy Act, 1933. Section 4(4) makes auction the default, and the First Schedule lists the administrative exceptions.
- Who does what:
- DoT (the Central Government) assigns spectrum and grants authorisations.
- TRAI, the statutory regulator set up in 1997, only recommends terms and prices. DoT asks for its advice under Section 11(1)(a) of the TRAI Act, 1997.
-
The advice does not bind DoT. DoT can send it back through a back-reference (a request to reconsider).
-
The 2G background: The Supreme Court cancelled 122 licences. It held that giving out natural resources on a first-come-first-served (FCFS) basis was unconstitutional.
- The Presidential Reference that followed asked whether auction is compulsory for every natural resource.
-
So auction was never accepted as the only lawful method. That left room for a law-based administrative route like Section 4.
-
Pricing is still partly unsettled:
- DoT's July 2024 reference asked TRAI to price satellite spectrum keeping a level playing field with terrestrial (ground-based mobile and fixed) networks.
- DoT sent part of TRAI's May 2025 recommendations back on 12.11.2025, and TRAI replied in December 2025.
-
A 2026 Lok Sabha answer says the government accepted only some recommendations, and some licensees got spectrum only on a provisional basis.
-
Latest use: On 05 Nov 2026, TRAI's SCN framework recommended administrative assignment of feeder-link and user-link spectrum to SCN providers, tied to the First Schedule.
Don't confuse with
- Spectrum auction: In an auction, price is found by competitive bidding and the winner gets exclusive use. In administrative assignment, the government sets the price by formula, and the spectrum is often shared. Auction is the Act's default. Administrative assignment is the statutory exception.
- First-come-first-served (FCFS): FCFS was an executive practice that the Supreme Court struck down in the 2G case. Administrative assignment under the 2023 Act is limited to uses Parliament listed in the First Schedule, and it carries a fixed price.
- Authorisation: An authorisation under Section 3 is permission to provide a service or run a network. The SCN authorisation, for example, falls under Section 3(1)(b). Spectrum assignment under Section 4 is the separate right to use frequencies. A firm can hold an authorisation and still need a spectrum assignment.
- Licence fee on AGR: The 8% authorisation fee is charged on revenue for the right to operate. The spectrum charge is a separate payment for using the frequencies, with a per-MHz minimum.
Prelims Hooks
- Under the Telecommunications Act, 2023, auction is the default. Administrative assignment applies only to entries in the First Schedule.
- The First Schedule already covers DTH, VSAT, GMPCS and MSS in the L and S bands.
- The government can add entries to the First Schedule by notification under Section 4(5), for public interest, government functions, or technical or economic reasons.
- TRAI recommends; DoT assigns. A statement that "TRAI allots satellite spectrum" is FALSE.
- In the SCN framework, feeder-link spectrum is FSS, assigned administratively. The minimum spectrum charge is Rs 3,500 per MHz per year.
- The Supreme Court cancelled 122 2G licences for FCFS allocation. It did not rule that auction is the only lawful method, which was the question in the Presidential Reference.
Mains Points
- Auction vs administrative assignment:
- Auction finds the market price and is transparent.
- Administrative assignment suits shared satellite spectrum, keeps entry costs low for new space-economy firms, and supports last-mile and disaster connectivity.
-
The weak point is pricing. Without bidding, DoT should publish how the floor price was worked out and when it will be reviewed, so it can be checked the way an auction result can.
-
Level playing field:
- Mobile operators paid at auction. Satellite firms pay an administratively set charge.
-
Once direct-to-device service lets ordinary phones connect to satellites, the two compete for the same customer. Different pricing rules then become a competition issue, which DoT itself flagged in its reference to TRAI.
-
Discretion and accountability (GS-II):
- Section 4(5) lets the executive widen the non-auction list with only laying before Parliament.
- Repeated back-references between DoT and TRAI keep satellite pricing provisional. That creates policy uncertainty for firms planning large capital spending.
- Possible fixes: publish the pricing method, have Parliament scrutinise new Schedule entries, and set a time limit for settling TRAI recommendations.