Balance of payments crisis

Indian Economy glossary

Also called: foreign exchange shortage, dollar shortage · Topic: Balance of Payments and Exchange Rates · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

A balance of payments crisis happens when a country runs so short of foreign exchange (dollars and other foreign currencies) that it cannot pay for its essential imports or its debts. Its exports and remittances fall short, foreign lenders and investors stop sending money, and its reserves are nearly used up. To survive, the country usually has to cut imports, let its currency fall in value (devalue it), and borrow from the IMF, which lends only if the country agrees to reforms.

It matters because the crisis does not stay in the external sector. It brings inflation, job losses, and a loss of control over economic policy. India's 1991 crisis is the reason the LPG reforms began.

The basic identity: current account + capital account + change in reserves ≡ 0.

  • A crisis begins when the current account deficit (CAD) is large and capital inflows stop or reverse.
  • Then the whole gap has to be paid from reserves, until the reserves run out.

Explanation

How a crisis builds up

  • Step 1: a large current account deficit. The CAD is the gap when a country pays more abroad for goods, services, income and transfers than it earns.
  • The identity is CA = S − I. A CAD means the country invests more than it saves at home, so it must borrow the difference from abroad.

  • Step 2: the deficit is paid for with risky money. A CAD has to be financed in one of two ways:

  • Capital inflows: FDI, FPI, loans, and NRI deposits (money that Indians living abroad keep in Indian banks).
  • Reserves: drawing down what the RBI holds.
  • If the inflows are hot money (short-term money that moves fast in search of returns) or short-term debt, they can leave suddenly.

  • Step 3: a sudden stop. Inflows halt or reverse, because of a war, an oil shock, a rating downgrade or political trouble.

  • The central bank sells dollars to fill the gap. This is an official reserve sale.
  • Reserves fall fast.

  • Step 4: a loss of confidence feeds itself.

  • Reserves look too small → speculators sell the currency → reserves fall further.
  • Under a fixed rate this is a speculative attack, and it forces devaluation.
  • When official dollars run out, a black market for foreign exchange appears.

  • Step 5: the country cannot pay. Lenders refuse new loans, and the country faces default (missing payments on its debt). It must turn to the IMF.

Worked example (NCERT Table 6.1, US$ million)

  • Current account balance = −38. Capital account balance = +41.15.
  • Inflows more than cover the CAD, so there is no crisis.

  • Now suppose a sudden stop pushes the capital account to zero.

  • The full 38 must now be paid from reserves.
  • If reserves are only about 38, they are wiped out in one period. That is a BoP crisis.

  • Import cover (how many months of imports the reserves can pay for) shows how close the danger is:

  • Old rule of thumb: about 3 months.
  • India in mid-1991: foreign currency assets of about US$1 bn, barely two weeks of imports.
  • India recently: about 11 months (verify current).

Warning signs to watch

Indicator Danger signal
CAD/GDP Above a sustainable level. Rangarajan HLC (1993) put it at about 1.6% of GDP; about 2.5-3% of GDP is cited today
Reserves to short-term debt Below 100%, which breaks the Greenspan-Guidotti rule
Debt service ratio (principal + interest paid, as a share of current receipts) High. It was about 35% in 1990-91
How the CAD is financed Mostly hot money and short-term debt, not FDI
What the borrowing is spent on Consumption, not investment. Class 11 says this happened in the 1980s
Twin deficits A large fiscal deficit alongside a CAD

The usual cure

  • Short-term fixes (stabilisation): curbs on imports, devaluation, higher interest rates, gold sales, and emergency loans or currency swaps (agreements where central banks lend each other currency for a fixed period).
  • IMF help with conditionality: a structural adjustment programme gives loans only if the country agrees to Washington Consensus-type reforms. Examples are fiscal discipline, a competitive exchange rate and trade liberalisation.
  • A dollar shortage short of full crisis — Egypt:
  • In February 2022, Egypt made importers use a letter of credit (a bank guarantee of payment, which needs dollars arranged in advance).
  • At end-June 2023, importers were still waiting for about USD 6 bn in foreign currency.
  • Egypt took a USD 3 bn Extended Fund Facility (a multi-year IMF loan tied to reforms) in December 2022. The IMF completed its delayed reviews only in March 2024.

In India

  • The 1991 crisis (Class 11):
  • Causes: fiscal overshooting through the 1980s, foreign borrowing spent on consumption, imports growing faster than exports, and rising prices.
  • Triggers (1990-91): the Gulf War oil-price rise, lost Gulf remittances, NRI deposits leaving, credit-rating downgrades and political instability.
  • The low point:
    • Total reserves were about US$6 bn at end-March 1991.
    • Foreign currency assets fell to about US$1 bn by mid-1991, "not sufficient for even a fortnight" of imports.
    • India could not pay interest, and no one would lend.
  • Response:
    • About 20 tonnes of gold were sold through SBI. About 47 tonnes were pledged with the Bank of England and Bank of Japan.
    • The IMF and World Bank lent US$7 bn, with conditions attached.
    • The rupee was devalued in two steps on 1 and 3 July 1991, by about 18-19%.
    • The New Economic Policy followed: stabilisation plus structural reforms.
  • After the crisis: LERMS (1992) → unified market rate (1993) → current account convertibility (August 1994) → FERA replaced by FEMA (1999).

  • The 2013 near-crisis (taper tantrum):

  • The US Fed hinted it would slow its bond buying, and money flowed out of emerging markets.
  • The CAD had hit a record 4.8% of GDP in FY13, driven by oil and a gold-import boom.
  • India was named among the "Fragile Five". The rupee fell to about ₹68.8/$ (August 2013).
  • Fixes: an FCNR(B) swap window that raised about US$34 bn, and curbs on gold imports.

  • Who manages the risk:

  • RBI holds the forex reserves (FCA + gold + SDRs + reserve tranche position), steps into the market, and runs swaps. It publishes BoP and external-debt data every quarter.
  • FEMA 1999 governs foreign exchange.
  • Defences include the India-Japan swap arrangement of US$75 bn.

  • Buffers today:

  • Reserves were about US$646 bn in 2023-24 (NCERT) and peaked at about US$705 bn in September 2024.
  • The CAD was about 0.6% of GDP in FY25 (verify current).

  • India as helper in the neighbourhood: in Sri Lanka's 2022 default, India gave about US$4 bn in bridge support. An IMF EFF followed in March 2023.

Don't confuse with

  • BoP deficit: a deficit only means the overall balance is below zero and reserves fall, which can be routine and easily financed. A crisis means the country can no longer finance the gap at all.
  • Current account deficit: a CAD is a normal flow and can be healthy if it is paid for with FDI and used for investment. It becomes a crisis only when its financing stops.
  • Sovereign default: default is the government missing debt payments. A BoP crisis is a whole-country shortage of foreign currency. It can lead to default (Sri Lanka, 2022) or be averted before it (India, 1991).
  • Currency depreciation: depreciation is any market fall in the rupee. In a crisis, a sharp fall or forced devaluation is one symptom, not the crisis itself.

Prelims Hooks

  • India's 1991 crisis: reserves of about US$6 bn (end-March 1991); foreign currency assets of about US$1 bn by mid-1991, about two weeks of imports.
  • Gold in 1991 was pledged with the Bank of England and Bank of Japan. About 20 tonnes were sold through SBI.
  • The rupee was devalued on 1 and 3 July 1991, by about 18-19%. Devaluation is a government decision under a fixed regime, not a market movement.
  • Greenspan-Guidotti rule: reserves should be at least 100% of short-term debt. The old import-cover rule is 3 months.
  • In a BoP deficit, under the NCERT sign convention, the reserve change is shown as positive, because a fall in reserves is a source of funds.
  • Trap: the reserve tranche position with the IMF can be drawn at any time with no conditions. IMF crisis loans (like 1991's) come with conditionality.

Mains Points

  • 1991 as a twin-deficit lesson: the fiscal deficit and the CAD fed each other. Borrowed money spent on consumption, plus short-term and NRI funds that could flee, turned the Gulf shock into a crisis. Compare it with 2013 (oil and gold, hot money) to show how India's buffers have changed: higher reserves, FDI-led financing, and a services and remittance surplus.
  • How much reserves are enough, and at what cost? Large reserves prevent crises and support ratings. But holding them costs money:
  • Sterilisation: when the RBI buys dollars it releases rupees, and it must then pull those rupees back out of the market.
  • Negative carry: reserves earn low returns on US Treasuries, while India pays more on its own borrowing.
  • The policy questions are whether to defend a rupee level or only curb volatility, and how far to go with capital account convertibility given the Tarapore preconditions and the impossible trinity.

  • IMF conditionality (GS-II): stabilisation loans restore confidence, but austerity, wrongly sequenced reforms and one-size-fits-all programmes draw criticism. Egypt's import curbs and its IMF reviews, and Sri Lanka's restructuring with India as co-chair of the creditor committee, are recent examples.

Read more