Commercial wisdom of the Committee of Creditors

Indian Economy glossary

Also called: Commercial wisdom doctrine, Essar Steel doctrine · Topic: Banking Regulation, NPAs and Financial Stability · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

The commercial wisdom of the Committee of Creditors (CoC) is the rule that courts and tribunals must accept the CoC's business decisions on a resolution plan. These include whether to accept a bid, how big a loss to take and how to split the money. The courts may check only whether the plan follows the law. In the Essar Steel (SC, 2019) case, the Supreme Court gave the CoC's "commercial wisdom" priority over court review of the plan's terms.

It matters because it decides who has the last word in an insolvency case. Business choices belong to the lenders. Legal limits are protected by the courts. The Videocon ruling (SC, 2026) showed that this commercial wisdom does not cover breaking the statute.

Explanation

How the doctrine works

  • IBC 2016 moved control from "debtor in possession" to "creditor in control". This means the lenders, not the old owners, now decide what happens to a failed company.
  • Committee of Creditors (CoC): the body of financial creditors (those who lent money, such as banks and bondholders). It votes on the resolution plan.
  • A plan needs at least 66% of the voting share of financial creditors, with reasons recorded.
  • Most other CoC decisions need at least 51%.

  • What the CoC must weigh: whether the plan is feasible and viable, and how it distributes money among creditors.

  • The logic: lenders put their own money at risk, and they understand the business. Judges do not. So the courts should not ask "Is this a good price?" or "Should the bidder pay more?"

What courts may and may not do

Courts cannot question (commercial choices) Courts can check (statutory compliance)
The bid amount and the haircut size Whether the plan contains everything Section 30 requires
Which bidder wins Whether distribution is "fair and equitable" (2019 amendment)
The CoC's vote result, e.g. 95.09% for Videocon Whether dissenting financial creditors get at least their liquidation value under Section 53
Whether the bidder is barred under s.29A (defaulting promoters)
  • Remit, don't rewrite: if a plan breaks the law, the NCLT or NCLAT cannot change it themselves. They can only send it back (remit) to the CoC to fix.
  • So the commercial decision stays with the CoC even when the courts step in.
  • Remitting rather than rejecting also keeps the process alive, so the company is not pushed into liquidation by default.

The limit: protection of dissenting creditors

  • Dissenting financial creditor: a lender who votes against the plan.
  • The floor: since the IBC (Amendment) Act 2019 (in force 16 August 2019), a dissenter must get at least what it would get in liquidation.
  • Liquidation value means what creditors would get if the company were closed and its assets sold.
  • This right belongs to each creditor on its own, so even a 95.09% majority cannot take it away.

  • Worked example: Videocon

  • Admitted claims: about ₹64,839 crore. Twinstar's plan: ₹2,962.02 crore.
  • Liquidation value, on first view: about ₹2,568 crore. The bid was only a little above the floor.
  • Haircut noted by NCLT: 95.85%. Creditors lost almost all of what they were owed.
  • Dissenters were to be paid through deferred debentures. These are IOUs repaid years later.
  • ₹100 paid in five years is worth less than ₹100 today, and it may never be paid. So in real value the dissenters could get less than the floor.
  • Result: the NCLAT (5 January 2022) sent the plan back to the CoC, and the SC upheld this on 17 November 2026.

In India

  • Law: IBC 2016 (Act No. 31 of 2016), amended by the IBC (Amendment) Act 2019 (No. 26 of 2019). The validity of IBC was upheld in Swiss Ribbons (SC, 2019).
  • Institutions:
  • CoC: makes the commercial decisions.
  • Resolution Professional: runs the company and the process.
  • NCLT: the adjudicating authority (the tribunal that decides the case).
  • NCLAT: the appellate tribunal. Further appeal goes to the SC.
  • IBBI: the regulator.

  • Landmark cases:

  • Essar Steel (SC, 2019): courts must respect CoC commercial wisdom on plan terms.
  • Twinstar v. Videocon CoC (SC, 2026): commercial wisdom does not protect a plan that breaks Section 30(2). Tribunals may remit a plan but may not rewrite it.

  • Parliament's view: the Standing Committee on Finance (report of 3 August 2021) recommended a professional code of conduct for the CoC, because its commercial wisdom is treated as final. It also asked for a benchmark for haircuts.

  • Timelines: CIRP deadline of 180 + 90 days, with an outer limit of 330 days (2019 amendment). The Videocon case still ran from before 2020 to 2026.

Don't confuse with

  • Remitting vs modifying a plan: tribunals may only send a plan back to the CoC. They cannot rewrite or change its terms themselves.
  • CoC vs Resolution Professional: the CoC (financial creditors) makes the commercial decision on the plan. The RP is a licensed professional who runs the company and the process but has no vote.
  • Plan-approval vote vs general decisions: a resolution plan needs 66% of the vote. Ordinary CoC decisions need 51%. 75% is the old, pre-2018 figure.
  • CoC vote share vs haircut (Videocon): 95.09% is the share of creditors who voted for the plan. 95.85% is the haircut.

Prelims Hooks

  • The doctrine comes from Essar Steel (SC, 2019). Courts must not question the CoC's business judgement on a resolution plan, but they may check whether it follows the law.
  • The CoC is made up of financial creditors only. Operational creditors (owed for goods, services, wages or government dues) do not vote.
  • A resolution plan needs ≥ 66% of the CoC vote. Other decisions need ≥ 51%.
  • Under the 2019 amendment, a dissenting financial creditor must get at least its liquidation value under Section 53, and distribution must be "fair and equitable".
  • Trap: "NCLAT can modify a resolution plan to remove defects." FALSE. It can only remit the plan to the CoC (Videocon, SC 2026).
  • Trap: "A plan approved by 95% of the CoC cannot be challenged." FALSE. The Videocon plan had 95.09% support and was still sent back.

Mains Points

  • Who decides, and how far courts go: the doctrine gives business choices to lenders, who carry the risk. Courts guard the legal minimums. This keeps resolution fast and stops judges from setting prices. But Videocon shows that the CoC's "wisdom" cannot override the protection given to minority (dissenting) creditors. Many dissenters were public-sector lenders, so a shortfall to them is a loss of public money.
  • Speed vs fairness: each remand adds delay. Videocon took almost five years from NCLAT to SC, and asset value falls while a case waits. Bidders may also offer less if approved plans can be reopened. Possible reforms:
  • An IBBI rule that dissenters' minimum must be paid in cash or its present-value equivalent
  • More NCLT benches
  • Upfront deposits from losing bidders who appeal (28th Report, 2 December 2025)

  • Accountability of the CoC: because its decisions are final, deep haircuts (up to 95% in some cases; 95.85% in Videocon) are hard to question. The 2021 Standing Committee suggested a CoC code of conduct and a haircut benchmark. The trade-off is that a fixed cap on haircuts could drive away bidders for badly damaged firms and push them into liquidation, which recovers even less.

Read more