Dissenting financial creditor

Indian Economy glossary

Also called: Dissenting creditor · Topic: Banking Regulation, NPAs and Financial Stability · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

A dissenting financial creditor is a lender, such as a bank or bondholder, that does not vote in favour of a resolution plan in the Committee of Creditors (CoC). The CoC is the group of financial creditors that decides a company's fate under the IBC. A resolution plan is a bidder's offer to take over a company that cannot pay its debts and to settle what it owes. A plan passes with 66% of the vote by value, so the creditors who did not support it are outvoted. The IBC (Amendment) Act, 2019 still protects them. Under Section 30(2), a dissenting financial creditor must get at least what it would have received if the company were closed and its assets sold under the Section 53 liquidation waterfall (the legal order in which money from a sale is paid out). No majority, however large, can push this minimum lower.

Example

In the Videocon case, Twinstar bid ₹2,962 crore. The liquidation value was about ₹2,568 crore. The CoC approved the bid with 95.09% of the vote. Two dissenting lenders, Bank of Maharashtra and IFCI, were to be paid through deferred debentures, which are promises to repay years later. The NCLAT held in 2022 that this did not meet the legal minimum and sent the plan back to the CoC. The Supreme Court upheld that order in 2026.

Don't confuse with

  • Operational creditor: owed money for goods, services, wages or government dues. It has no vote in the CoC, so it cannot be a "dissenting" voter at all.
  • Assenting financial creditor: votes for the plan. It accepts whatever the plan offers it, even if that is a deep haircut (a cut in the amount it gets back).

Read more