Environmental integrity
FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →Also called: Carbon credit integrity · Topic: Environment and Sustainable Development · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
Environmental integrity means a carbon unit is real: one credit or allowance must stand for one tonne of CO2-equivalent (CO2e, which counts all greenhouse gases as CO2) that has actually been kept out of the air. A credit passes four tests:
- Additionality: the cut would not have happened anyway.
- Permanence: the cut is not reversed later.
- No leakage: emissions do not simply move somewhere else.
- No double counting: two buyers or two countries do not both claim the same tonne.
The idea also applies to whole markets. Trading or linking (one market accepting another's units) must lower total emissions, not just move paper around. Without integrity, a carbon market looks like climate action but does nothing.
Example
Suppose an Indian plant is under an intensity target, which is a limit on emissions per tonne of output. It earns surplus credits and sells them to a firm under Brazil's absolute cap, a fixed limit on total emissions. The Brazilian firm can now emit more than the cap allows. Meanwhile, the Indian plant's total emissions may also rise because it is producing more. Both sides look compliant, but more gas reaches the air. So integrity fails.
Don't confuse with
- Additionality: this is only one of the four tests. A credit can be additional and still fail on permanence, for example when a forest that was paid for later burns down.
- Green credit: this is a unit for green actions such as tree planting or saving water, under India's Green Credit Rules 2023. It does not stand for a tonne of CO2e, so it is not a carbon credit.