Fit and proper criteria

Indian Economy glossary

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →

Also called: Fit and proper test · Topic: Banking Regulation, NPAs and Financial Stability · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

The fit and proper criteria (also called the fit and proper test) are the checks a financial regulator, mainly the RBI for banks, uses to decide whether a person or company is honest, financially sound, competent and of good reputation enough to own, control or run a regulated institution. The RBI applies them before it approves a large shareholding, a change of control, or the appointment of a director or CEO, and it keeps applying them for as long as that person stays.

A bank mostly runs on other people's money, which is depositors' trust. So the regulator must first filter out owners and managers who might misuse that money. This is the first line of bank governance, before any capital or NPA rule comes into play.

Explanation

Why banks need a "gatekeeper" test

  • A bank is a leveraged, trust-based business.
  • It borrows short-term (deposits that can be withdrawn on demand) and lends long-term (loans).
  • Most of its money belongs to depositors, not owners. In the study note's example, a bank with Rs 100 of assets may have only Rs 8 of its own capital.
  • A dishonest owner can therefore risk a lot of public money with very little of their own.

  • Bad owners lead to bad loans.

  • Owners or directors may push loans to their own companies or friends (connected lending), hide bad loans through evergreening (giving fresh loans so old dues can be repaid), or commit fraud.
  • The fit and proper test tries to stop this at the entry gate, before the damage is done.

What is checked

  • Integrity and reputation: criminal cases, regulatory actions, fraud, links to money laundering.
  • Financial soundness: whether the person has defaulted on loans, especially as a wilful defaulter (someone who can pay but does not), and where the money for the purchase comes from.
  • Competence: qualifications and experience to run or supervise a bank (for directors and CEOs).
  • Source of funds: the buyer must use its own money. It should not quietly use the bank's money or loans the bank backs to pay for buying the bank.
  • Conflicts of interest: for example, one group owning and running two competing banks.

Who is tested, and when

  • Major shareholders and acquirers: before they buy a large stake or take control of a bank.
  • Directors and the CEO or Managing Director: at appointment, and through a yearly declaration afterwards.
  • It is an ongoing test. If a shareholder or director stops being "fit and proper" later, the RBI can act. It can, for example, restrict voting rights or remove the person.
  • Other regulators use the same idea: the RBI for NBFCs and ARCs, and SEBI and IRDAI for market intermediaries and insurers.

How it works with other ownership controls

  • The fit and proper test decides who may own a bank. Other rules decide how much power that owner gets.
  • Voting cap: under the Banking Regulation Act, a shareholder's voting rights are capped at 26%, however many shares they hold.
  • Example: a buyer with 60.72% of the shares still gets only 26% of the votes, so one owner cannot run the bank alone.
  • FDI limits: foreign investment in private banks is allowed up to 49% through the automatic route (no prior approval) and up to 74% with government approval.
  • One-bank rule: the RBI does not let one group own and run two banks.

In India

  • Regulator: the RBI, using its powers under the Banking Regulation Act 1949, which gave it licensing and supervisory powers over banks.
  • Where it is applied:
  • New bank licences: private bank licences in 1993-94, 2001 and 2014, then on-tap licensing from 2016. Small finance banks moved to on-tap licensing in 2019. Promoters of every new bank must pass the test.
  • Change of control: the strategic sale of IDBI Bank to Canada's Fairfax Financial Holdings needs RBI clearance, including the fit and proper check, before the deal can close.
  • Urban cooperative banks: the Banking Regulation (Amendment) Act 2020 widened the RBI's powers over their governance. Failures such as PMC Bank (2019) and New India Co-operative Bank (2025) showed what happens when boards are weak.

  • Supporting rules:

  • Wilful Defaulters Master Direction 2024 (dues of Rs 25 lakh and above): wilful defaulters are barred from floating new ventures and from sitting on the boards of other companies. This is a direct "not fit and proper" filter.
  • Banking Laws (Amendment) Act 2025: the "substantial interest" threshold rises from Rs 5 lakh to Rs 2 crore (verify current). This changes who counts as having a large interest in a bank or company.

  • Public sector banks: directors and heads are chosen through the Banks Board Bureau (2016), which was replaced by FSIB (2022). This followed the P.J. Nayak Committee (2014), which found PSB boards weak and their leaders' terms short.

Don't confuse with

  • KYC (Know Your Customer): checks the identity of a bank's customers under PMLA 2002 and the RBI KYC Master Direction 2016. The fit and proper test checks the bank's owners and directors.
  • Section 29A of IBC: bars defaulting promoters from bidding for a company in insolvency. The fit and proper test decides who may own or run a bank.
  • Voting-rights cap: limits how much power an approved shareholder gets (26%). The fit and proper test decides whether that person may be a shareholder at all.
  • Prompt Corrective Action (PCA): acts on a bank's financial health (CRAR, net NPA, leverage ratio). The fit and proper test looks at the people who own and manage the bank.

Prelims Hooks

  • The RBI applies the fit and proper test to major shareholders, promoters, directors and CEOs of banks. It is ongoing, not a one-time check at entry.
  • Under the Banking Regulation Act, voting rights are capped at 26% whatever the shareholding.
  • FDI in private banks: up to 49% automatic route; 49-74% with government approval. The FDI cap for PSBs is 20%.
  • Wilful defaulters (Master Direction 2024, dues of Rs 25 lakh and above) are barred from boards of other companies.
  • Trap: "Passing the fit and proper test gives a majority shareholder voting control in proportion to its shares." FALSE. The 26% voting cap still applies.
  • Trap: "Fit and proper criteria apply only to foreign buyers." FALSE. They apply to all promoters, large shareholders and directors, Indian or foreign.

Mains Points

  • Bank privatisation and foreign ownership: in strategic sales such as IDBI Bank, the fit and proper test, the 26% voting cap and the one-bank rule work together as safeguards. So the worry about "foreign control" is real but limited. The test only works if the RBI checks the source of funds and settles conflicts before it gives approval.
  • Governance as prevention of NPAs: the twin balance sheet crisis, evergreening and the PNB-Nirav Modi fraud (2018) show that poor governance comes before bad loans. Strict fit and proper checks on directors and owners, together with the wilful defaulter rules, deal with the cause rather than the symptoms.
  • Cooperative banks and dual control: in UCBs, state registrars still handle registration and administration, so the RBI's fit and proper scrutiny of boards is weaker. PMC Bank (2019) and New India Co-operative Bank (2025) make the case for giving the RBI full control over who runs these banks.

Read more