Government Health Expenditure

Indian Economy glossary

Also called: GHE · Topic: Human Capital: Education, Health and Demographic Dividend · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Government Health Expenditure (GHE) is the money that the Union, State and local governments together spend on health. It is one of the main parts of a country's Total Health Expenditure (THE), which is health spending from all sources: government, households and insurance.

GHE matters because when the government pays more, families pay less from their own pockets at the hospital. This protects poor households from medical bills that can push them into poverty. It also builds human capital, because healthy workers produce more.

GHE is tracked in three ways:

  • Absolute GHE = total government health spending in ₹ crore
  • Per capita GHE = GHE ÷ population
  • GHE as % of GDP = (GHE ÷ GDP) × 100. GDP is the total value of everything the economy produces in a year.
  • GHE as % of THE = (GHE ÷ THE) × 100

Explanation

Why the government spends on health

  • Health is a public good with external benefits.
  • A vaccinated or healthy person stops disease from spreading to others.
  • Markets count only private benefits, so they supply too little health care.
  • This market failure is the main reason the state steps in (Class 11, §4.5).

  • Information gap. Patients do not know the true quality or cost of treatment. Private providers can use this to overcharge, so the state sets standards and provides care itself.

  • Poverty. Many people cannot afford basic or super-speciality care.
  • Three tiers. Under the Constitution, the Union, State and local governments (municipalities, panchayats) all spend on health.

What GHE pays for (components)

  • The four forms of health expenditure (Class 11):
  • Preventive medicine: stops disease before it starts, e.g. vaccination.
  • Curative medicine: treatment during illness, e.g. hospital care.
  • Social medicine: spreading health literacy, e.g. awareness campaigns.
  • Water and sanitation: clean drinking water and toilets.

  • Primary healthcare: preventive and promotive care, screening for non-communicable diseases (NCDs), and essential medicines and diagnostics at community level, delivered through Ayushman Arogya Mandirs.

  • Government-financed insurance, such as AB PM-JAY and State schemes. This is counted in Social Security Expenditure on Health (SSE), which also covers social health insurance and medical spending on government employees.

What makes the GHE numbers rise or fall

  • Budget decisions by the Union and the States. Health is in the State List, so most of the money has to come from the States.
  • One-time shocks.
  • Extra COVID spending in 2021-22 pushed GHE up to 1.84% of GDP.
  • Once that money stopped, GHE fell back to 1.43% of GDP in 2022-23 (1.48% on the new GDP series with base year 2022-23).

  • The size of the denominator.

  • GHE can grow fast in rupees while staying low as a share of GDP, because GDP is also growing in rupees.
  • The NHA figures are in nominal terms (current prices, not adjusted for inflation).

  • Unspent money.

  • Funds can be allocated and still not used. The Parliamentary Standing Committee blamed poor planning of time and cost for unused health funds.
  • The CAG found that PM-JAY's administrative grants have stayed unspent since the scheme began.

Worked example (illustrative numbers)

  • Year 1: THE = ₹100, of which GHE = ₹30 and OOPE (what households pay directly) = ₹60.
  • GHE share = 30%. OOPE share = 60%.

  • Year 2: GHE doubles to ₹60, and households still pay ₹60. THE rises to ₹130 (other sources stay at ₹10).

  • GHE share = 60 ÷ 130 ≈ 46%. OOPE share = 60 ÷ 130 ≈ 46%.

  • Lesson: the OOPE share fell from 60% to about 46%, but families paid exactly the same rupees. A rising GHE share lowers the OOPE share even when no household's bill gets smaller.

In India

  • Who measures it: the National Health Accounts (NHA) estimates. They are released by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW) and prepared by the National Health Accounts Technical Secretariat (NHATS) at the National Health Systems Resource Centre (NHSRC), using the System of Health Accounts 2011 (SHA 2011) framework.
  • Legal basis: NHA is an administrative statistical exercise with no enabling Act. Health is in the State List of Schedule VII, so GHE adds up Union and State spending.
  • Latest figures, NHA 2023-24 (the 11th round):
Indicator 2013-14 2023-24
GHE (absolute) ₹1,29,778 crore ₹4,14,196 crore (about 3.2 times)
Per capita GHE ₹1,042 ₹2,959
GHE share of THE ≈28.6% (derived) ≈43.5% (derived); up 14.9 pp
OOPE share of THE 64.2% 42.7%
SSE share of THE 6% 11%
  • Government spending on primary healthcare in 2023-24 was about ₹1.53 lakh crore.
  • Measured against GDP:
  • 1.84% in 2021-22 (COVID peak), when the government's share of THE was 48%.
  • 1.43% in 2022-23.
  • The National Health Policy 2017 target is 2.5% of GDP by 2025. India is still about one percentage point short after the deadline.

  • Schemes that GHE funds: Ayushman Bharat (2018), with its two pillars, Ayushman Arogya Mandirs for primary care and PM-JAY (₹5 lakh hospital cover per family per year). Also the Free Drugs and Diagnostics Initiatives, the PM National Dialysis Programme, PM Bhartiya Janaushadhi Pariyojana and AMRIT pharmacies.

  • Cess support: since 2018-19, a 4% Health and Education Cess on Union taxes.

Don't confuse with

  • Total Health Expenditure (THE): health spending from all sources (government, households, insurance). GHE is only the government's part of it.
  • Out-of-Pocket Expenditure (OOPE): direct payments by households at the point of care that no scheme pays back. When GHE goes up, the OOPE share usually goes down, but they are different numbers.
  • Social Security Expenditure on Health (SSE): organised protection, such as PM-JAY, social health insurance and medical spending on government employees. It is not private health insurance, which people buy for themselves.
  • Current Health Expenditure (CHE): WHO's denominator for international comparisons. Indian NHA shares use THE, so do not compare the two directly.

Prelims Hooks

  • GHE in 2023-24 was ₹4,14,196 crore, up from ₹1,29,778 crore in 2013-14. Per capita GHE was ₹2,959, up from ₹1,042.
  • The GHE share of THE rose by 14.9 percentage points, which is a ~52% relative rise. Trap: "the GHE share rose by 14.9%" is FALSE.
  • NHA estimates are prepared by NHATS at NHSRC under MoHFW, not by NITI Aayog or MoSPI, using SHA 2011.
  • The NHP 2017 target is public health spending of 2.5% of GDP by 2025. Actual spending was 1.84% in 2021-22 and 1.43% in 2022-23.
  • Health is a State List subject, so GHE includes Union, State and local government spending.
  • Trap: "NHA 2023-24 is the first-ever NHA round". FALSE. It is the eleventh round.

Mains Points

  • Rupee growth vs real effort:
  • GHE has grown about 3.2 times in nominal rupees, but as a share of GDP it is still well below the NHP 2017 target of 2.5%.
  • The 2021-22 peak of 1.84% was a one-time COVID boost. Because of this, the OOPE share went back up from 39.4% (2021-22) to 42.7% (2023-24).
  • A balanced answer accepts the ten-year gain and also points out the post-COVID slip.

  • More money is not the same as more protection:

  • The CAG's PM-JAY audit (Report No. 11 of 2023) found that in Meghalaya, 13,418 patients (69%) paid ₹12.34 crore at discharge despite the scheme being cashless. It also found ₹57.53 crore of excess payments in four States.
  • Under SDG 3.8.2, 30.9% of Indians (about 44 crore) face financial hardship from health spending.
  • So better use of GHE (empanelment checks, working grievance committees, spending the funds allocated) matters as much as a bigger GHE.

  • Fiscal federalism:

  • Health is a State subject, yet Union schemes shape spending.
  • One way forward: an agreed Union-State path to 2.5% of GDP, with part of Union grants linked to States raising, and actually spending, their own health budgets.
  • More spending on primary care (about ₹1.53 lakh crore in 2023-24) is cheaper than hospital care and builds human capital.

Read more