Grandfathering

Indian Economy glossary

Also called: Grandfathering of capital gains · Topic: Taxation: Direct and Indirect Taxes, GST and Global Tax Issues · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Grandfathering means that a new tax rule applies only from a cut-off date. Assets, deals or gains made before that date stay under the old rule. The government is not taking back a benefit people already had, so their past decisions stay safe. That builds tax certainty, which means investors can trust that the rules they planned under will hold. In capital-gains tax, it usually means gains or holdings from before the cut-off are kept out of the new tax.

Example

Under the India-Mauritius protocol (2016), India gained the right to tax capital gains on Indian shares that a Mauritius-based investor acquired from April 2017. Shares bought before that date stayed under the old treaty rule. So an investor who bought in 2015 kept the old benefit, while shares bought in 2018 were taxed in India.

Don't confuse with

  • Retrospective taxation: this is the opposite. It taxes past transactions under a law changed later, as the Finance Act 2012 did after the Vodafone case. Grandfathering protects the past instead.
  • Sunset clause: this sets a date when a tax benefit ends for everyone, as with the SEZ income-tax holiday under Sec. 10AA, which only covered units that started operations by 31 March 2020. Grandfathering keeps old cases under the old rule after the law changes.

Read more