Intergenerational mobility

Indian Economy glossary

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →

Also called: Social mobility · Topic: Poverty and Inequality: Measurement and Policy · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Intergenerational mobility is how far a child's income, education or job differs from their parents', and so how strongly family background decides where a person ends up in life. It is one type of social mobility (a person or group moving up or down the social and economic ladder).

It matters because it tests equality of opportunity. If parents' income predicts a child's outcome, then hard work and talent are not deciding success, and poverty passes from one generation to the next.

A standard measure is the intergenerational earnings elasticity (IGE), which is the share of the parents' income advantage that passes on to the child:

ln Y(child) = α + β · ln Y(parent), where β = IGE

  • β close to 0 means high mobility: the child's income does not depend on the parents' income.
  • β close to 1 means low mobility: the child's income closely follows the parents' income.

Explanation

Three ways to measure it

  • Absolute mobility: the share of children who earn more than their parents did at the same age. It compares levels of income.
  • West Germany 67%, USA 60%.
  • It usually rises as countries get richer, including in India.

  • Relative mobility: how much a person's rank in the income distribution depends on their parents' rank.

  • In the USA, 43% of adults whose parents were in the bottom quintile (poorest 20%) are still in the bottom quintile.
  • The IGE is a measure of relative mobility.

  • Educational mobility: the chance that a child reaches a higher level of education than the parents.

  • In the USA, the chance of earning a higher degree than one's parents rose from 15.7% (NLSY79) to 26.2% (NLSY97). NLSY is the US National Longitudinal Survey of Youth, and the number is the year that group of young people was first surveyed.

Key point: you can earn more than your parents and still not move up.

  • If the whole economy grows, most children out-earn their parents, so absolute mobility is high.
  • But if everyone's income rises together, each person keeps the same rung on the ladder, so relative mobility does not change.
  • This is why a young generation can be richer than its parents and still feel stuck.

Worked example (IGE)

Suppose IGE = 0.38, the OECD cross-country average.

  • A father earns 50% more than the average father.
  • His child is expected to earn 0.38 × 50% = 19% more than the average child.
  • So 19 points of the father's 50-point advantage carry over, and 31 points disappear in one generation.

Compare a society where IGE is above 0.70, as in some highly unequal emerging economies. There the same child keeps more than 35 points of the advantage, and family background matters far more.

How long it takes to catch up: in a typical rich OECD country, a child born into the bottom 10% needs 4–5 generations to reach average income.

What raises or lowers mobility

  • Inequality (the main driver). Mobility is usually weaker where income inequality is high.
  • Rich parents can pay for better schools, contacts and housing.
  • So today's gap becomes the next generation's gap.
  • Economists call this link between inequality and low mobility the "Great Gatsby curve".
  • The IGE is below 20% in Nordic countries and above 70% in some unequal emerging economies.

  • Inherited wealth. Piketty's r > g (the return on capital is higher than the growth rate of the economy) means inherited wealth grows faster than the economy, which locks in the advantage of rich families.

  • "Sticky floor" and "sticky ceiling":
  • Sticky floor: people at the bottom cannot rise.
  • Sticky ceiling: rich families hold on to opportunities, so their children rarely fall.

  • Education. Education is the main way to move up, but a degree is now almost a requirement for a better job. This raises the cost of moving up, a problem called credential inflation.

  • Poverty traps and social exclusion. Chronic poverty can last across generations. Low nutrition, no collateral for loans, health shocks and caste or tribe discrimination keep children where their parents were.
  • Labour-market shocks. Losing a job early in a working life can scar (permanently lower) lifetime earnings. After 2008, the IMF called the young workers hit by the crisis a "Scarred Generation".

In India

  • Overall mobility is flat, but groups are moving in opposite directions. Work presented at the World Bank finds that India's overall intergenerational mobility has stayed about the same since liberalisation (1991).
  • Mobility rose for Scheduled Castes and fell for Muslims, by nearly equal amounts.
  • So the all-India average hides one group gaining and another losing.

  • How it is measured. The World Bank's Fair Progress? (2018) report shows that mobility in developing countries can be measured with household surveys such as the India Human Development Survey (IHDS). India has no official mobility statistic.

  • Constitutional basis:
  • Article 16: equality of opportunity in public employment.
  • Article 39(a): the State should secure an adequate means of livelihood for all citizens (a Directive Principle).

  • Educated youth: the promise breaks where families invest most. In 2022, youth unemployment was 29.1% for graduates but only 3.4% for youth who cannot read or write.

  • Families pay for degrees expecting their children to get better jobs than they had.
  • The ILO–IHD India Employment Report 2024 says the main problem is too few jobs (the demand side), not too few skills.

  • The unemployment rate hides the NEET group. Under PLFS 2025, youth (15–29) unemployment was 9.9%, but 25.0% were NEET (Not in Employment, Education or Training).

  • Inequality data point to mobility risk. The World Inequality Lab (2024) found that in 2022-23 the top 1% held about 22.6% of income and 40.1% of wealth. That is the highest income concentration since 1922. Highly concentrated wealth makes inherited advantage stronger.
  • Deprivation is concentrated by group. STs show the highest MPI incidence, followed by SCs. Without targeted help, this deprivation passes to the next generation.

Don't confuse with

  • Intragenerational mobility: a person's movement up or down during their own lifetime (for example, from labourer to shop owner). Intergenerational mobility compares a person with their parents.
  • Intergenerational equity: an ethical idea about fairness between generations on public debt, pensions, climate and housing. Intergenerational mobility is a measurable link between parents' and children's outcomes.
  • Absolute vs relative mobility: absolute asks "Do you earn more than your parents?" Relative asks "Is your rank different from your parents' rank?" Absolute can be high while relative stays stuck.
  • Inequality (Gini, Palma): a snapshot of how income is spread at one point in time. Mobility measures movement across generations. The two are linked, because high inequality usually means low mobility.

Prelims Hooks

  • The IGE is the share of the parents' income advantage passed to the child. A higher IGE means lower mobility. The OECD average is 38%, it is below 20% in Nordic countries, and above 70% in some unequal emerging economies.
  • Absolute mobility: West Germany 67%, USA 60% of children earn more than their parents.
  • In a typical OECD country, a bottom-10% child needs 4–5 generations to reach average income.
  • Reports and their publishers: A Broken Social Elevator? (2018) is from the OECD. Fair Progress? (2018) is from the World Bank. India Employment Report 2024 is from the ILO–IHD.
  • India since 1991: overall mobility flat, up for SCs, down for Muslims.
  • Trap: "If most children earn more than their parents, relative mobility must be high." This is FALSE. Absolute and relative mobility are different measures.

Mains Points

  • Absolute gains vs relative stagnation. In a "critically examine" answer, first admit the absolute gains (income mobility is positive, and absolute mobility rises with national income). Then argue that the anxiety comes from blocked relative mobility: the sticky floor and sticky ceiling. Graduate unemployment of 29.1% and the 25.0% NEET rate show where the promise breaks in India. This decides whether the demographic dividend becomes a gain or a burden.
  • Inequality today becomes immobility tomorrow. Since mobility is weaker where inequality is high, India's rising income and wealth concentration (top 1%: 40.1% of wealth, 2022-23) puts equality of opportunity at risk. The policy answer is long-term: public schooling and health quality, asset building for the chronically poor, and land reform. "New welfarism" (toilets, gas, houses) lowers deprivation but does not by itself raise learning, and learning drives mobility.
  • Measure mobility by group, and create jobs, not just skills. All-India figures hide SC gains and Muslim losses, so mobility should be tracked for each social group using surveys like the IHDS. Skill India adds to the supply of workers. Without more demand for workers, India's main constraint, skilling will mostly produce trained but unemployed youth.

Read more