Limitation of Benefits
FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →Also called: LOB clause · Topic: Taxation: Direct and Indirect Taxes, GST and Global Tax Issues · NCERT: Beyond NCERT
Meaning
A Limitation of Benefits (LOB) clause is a rule inside a tax treaty. It says who can actually use the treaty's benefits. A company that only exists on paper in the treaty country, with no real business there, is denied the benefits. Such a company is called a shell company: it has no real operations or assets.
The clause is aimed at treaty shopping. This means sending an investment through a country only to get its lower treaty tax. LOB matters because a Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) should help genuine investors of the partner country. It should not help anyone who sets up a postbox company there.
Example
India and Mauritius signed a protocol in 2016 that amended their DTAA. From April 2017, India could tax capital gains on shares bought from that date. The same protocol added an LOB test, so a Mauritius shell company with no real business could not claim treaty relief. After this change, FDI routed through Mauritius fell sharply.
Don't confuse with
- Principal purpose test (PPT): India added the PPT to its treaties when it ratified the MLI (the OECD's multilateral treaty tool) in 2019. The PPT asks why a deal was made. Benefits are denied if getting them was one of its main purposes. LOB instead checks whether the company has real business in the treaty country.
- General Anti-Avoidance Rule (GAAR): GAAR is part of India's domestic income-tax law, not a treaty clause. It applies only when the tax benefit is above ₹3 crore. It denies benefits from arrangements that lack commercial substance.