Notional-return taxation

Indian Economy glossary

Also called: Presumptive return tax, Deemed return taxation · Topic: Taxation: Direct and Indirect Taxes, GST and Global Tax Issues · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Notional-return taxation is a way of taxing savings and investments. The tax is charged on an assumed (notional) yield, not on the income the assets actually earn. The law fixes a return, for example "your savings earn 5% a year", and taxes that figure whatever really happened. It is simple to run because no one has to track each saver's real income. The weakness is fairness. If a saver's real return is lower than the assumed one, they pay tax on income they never received. Two people with very different real returns can also be taxed as if they earned the same.

Example

The Netherlands taxed savings and investments this way under its "Box 3" regime. Suppose a saver holds ₹10 lakh in a bank and earns only ₹10,000 (1%) in interest, but the law assumes a 5% return. Tax is then charged on ₹50,000, five times the real income. The Dutch Supreme Court struck this system down because it violated property rights and was discriminatory. The country is now moving to tax actual returns.

Don't confuse with

  • Wealth tax: this is levied on the value of net assets themselves. Notional-return taxation is a tax on income, but that income is assumed rather than measured.
  • Accrual-basis taxation: this taxes the actual rise in an asset's value each year, even before the asset is sold. Notional-return taxation does not look at actual gains at all.

Read more