Resolution plan

Indian Economy glossary

Also called: CIRP resolution plan · Topic: Banking Regulation, NPAs and Financial Stability · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

A resolution plan is a proposal by a resolution applicant (an outside bidder, or anyone not barred by law) to take over an insolvent company and keep it running as a business. It also says how much each creditor will be paid and how. Under the IBC, the Committee of Creditors (CoC) must approve it with at least 66% of the voting share of financial creditors, and the NCLT must then approve it. If no plan is approved, the company goes into liquidation, which means it is shut down and its assets are sold. So the resolution plan is the IBC's main tool for saving a business instead of breaking it up.

Haircut (%) = (Admitted claims − Amount paid under the plan) ÷ Admitted claims × 100

Explanation

How a plan is made and approved

  • Step 1: CIRP starts. The NCLT admits the case. A moratorium under s.14 begins, which means no suits, recovery or asset sales against the company while the process runs.
  • Step 2: The RP looks for bids. The Resolution Professional (RP) is a licensed professional who runs the company during the process. The RP invites plans from bidders.
  • Step 3: Who may bid. Under s.29A, defaulting promoters and persons connected to them cannot bid. Without this rule, an owner who defaulted could buy back the company cheaply after the creditors take a loss.
  • Step 4: The CoC votes. The CoC is made up only of financial creditors, meaning those who lent money, such as banks and bondholders.
  • Approving a plan needs ≥ 66% of the voting share, with reasons recorded.
  • Other CoC decisions generally need ≥ 51%.
  • The CoC must look at the plan's feasibility (can it work?), its viability (will the business survive?) and the manner of distribution (who gets how much).

  • Step 5: The NCLT approves. The NCLT checks that the plan follows the law. Once approved, the plan binds all creditors, including those who voted against it.

  • Time limit: 180 days + a 90-day extension, with an outer limit of 330 days including litigation (2019 amendment).
  • If there is no plan: the company goes into liquidation. The CoC may also decide to liquidate at any time after it is formed under Section 21(1) and before a plan is confirmed.

What a plan must contain: the legal floors

  • Fair and equitable distribution: since the IBC (Amendment) Act, 2019 (in force from 16 August 2019), the money must be shared among creditors in a "fair and equitable" way.
  • The dissenting creditor's minimum: a dissenting financial creditor is one that votes against the plan.
  • It must get at least what it would have received if the company were liquidated under the Section 53 waterfall (the legal order in which liquidation money is paid).
  • This floor protects each creditor on its own. So even a huge majority cannot vote it away.
  • The exact wording of Section 30(2) should be checked in the bare Act.

  • When the money is paid matters, not just how much:

  • ₹100 due in five years is worth less than ₹100 today, and it may never be paid at all.
  • So paying dissenters with deferred debentures (IOUs repaid years later) can pass the floor on paper but fail it in real value.

Commercial wisdom vs legal review

  • Essar Steel (SC, 2019): the business terms of a plan, such as price, haircut and who gets what, are for the CoC's "commercial wisdom" (its business judgement). Courts should not second-guess these choices.
  • The limit on this: the courts can still check whether the plan follows the law, such as the Section 30(2) floor.
  • Remit, not rewrite: the NCLT and NCLAT cannot modify a defective plan. They can only send it back (remit) to the CoC to be fixed.
  • This leaves the business decision with the creditors.
  • It also keeps the CIRP alive, so the company is not pushed into liquidation by default.

What drives recovery up or down

  • Delay lowers value.
  • Machines sit idle, staff leave and customers move away.
  • Bids then come in close to liquidation value.
  • The haircut becomes deeper.

  • Worked example (Videocon group, 13 firms):

Item Value
Admitted claims ~₹64,839 crore
Twinstar's plan ₹2,962.02 crore
Liquidation value (prima facie, as recorded by NCLAT) ~₹2,568 crore
CoC vote 95.09%
Haircut noted by NCLT 95.85%
  • Recomputing: (64,839 − 2,962) ÷ 64,839 × 100 ≈ 95.4%. The NCLT's 95.85% probably uses a different claims base, so quote the reported figure.
  • The bid was only about ₹394 crore above liquidation value. Because the margin was so thin, the timing of payments to dissenters decided whether the floor was met.

In India

  • Law: the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (Act No. 31 of 2016), enacted on 28 May 2016. Section 30 sets out what a plan must contain and how the CoC approves it. It was amended by the IBC (Amendment) Act, 2019 (No. 26 of 2019). The IBC replaced SICA/BIFR (1985). It moved control from "debtor in possession" (the old owners keep running the company) to "creditor in control". Its validity was upheld in Swiss Ribbons (SC, 2019).
  • Institutions:
  • IBBI is the regulator.
  • NCLT approves plans for companies.
  • NCLAT hears appeals, with a further appeal to the Supreme Court.
  • The CoC votes on plans.
  • The RP runs the process.

  • Threshold: a default of ₹1 crore is needed to start CIRP (raised from ₹1 lakh in March 2020).

  • Outcomes:
  • Creditors recover about one-third of admitted claims through resolution plans. That is a high haircut, but well above liquidation value.
  • Average resolution time runs far beyond 330 days.
  • The Standing Committee on Finance counted 13,170 IBC cases pending before the NCLT, about 71% of them for more than 180 days.
  • Average time to resolve insolvency fell from 4.3 years to 1.6 years (2017–2020).

  • Reform proposals:

  • The Standing Committee on Finance (August 2021) asked for a benchmark for the size of haircuts and a code of conduct for the CoC.
  • Its 28th Report (2 December 2025) asked for an upfront deposit from losing resolution applicants who file appeals, so that appeals are not used just to stall cases.

  • Other routes:

  • Pre-packaged insolvency (2021) is for MSMEs only, with a default of ₹10 lakh or more. The debtor keeps control, and it must finish in 120 days.
  • The IBC (Amendment) Bill 2025 proposes a creditor-initiated, out-of-court process. It would be triggered by financial creditors holding 51% by value.

Don't confuse with

  • Liquidation: a resolution plan keeps the company alive as a running business. Liquidation shuts it down, sells the assets and pays creditors in the s.53 waterfall order. Liquidation value is the floor that a plan must beat for dissenters.
  • Resolution Professional vs resolution applicant: the RP is the licensed professional who runs the CIRP. The resolution applicant is the bidder who submits the plan.
  • RBI's Prudential Framework (7 June 2019) resolution plan: that is an out-of-court plan agreed by lenders under an inter-creditor agreement, with a 30-day review period after default. An IBC resolution plan is made inside CIRP and needs CoC approval at 66% and NCLT approval.
  • One-time settlement (OTS): in an OTS, one lender accepts a smaller lump sum from the borrower. A resolution plan binds all creditors, usually brings in a new owner, and dissenters are protected by a legal floor.

Prelims Hooks

  • A resolution plan needs CoC approval by ≥ 66% of financial creditors' voting share. Other CoC decisions need ≥ 51%. 75% was the old pre-2018 figure, so it is a common trap.
  • Only financial creditors sit on the CoC. Operational creditors (owed for goods, services, wages or government dues) do not vote.
  • s.29A bars defaulting promoters and connected persons from submitting a resolution plan.
  • A dissenting financial creditor must get at least its liquidation value under Section 53 (2019 amendment). Distribution must be "fair and equitable".
  • The NCLT and NCLAT cannot rewrite a plan. They can only remit it to the CoC. The CoC's commercial wisdom is respected (Essar Steel, 2019).
  • CIRP timeline: 180 + 90 days, 330-day outer limit including litigation. If no plan is approved, the company goes into liquidation.

Mains Points

  • Commercial wisdom vs statutory compliance:
  • Leaving business terms to the CoC keeps courts out of commercial choices (Essar Steel).
  • But the Section 30(2) floor stops a majority from paying itself cash while giving dissenters long-dated paper. Many dissenters are public-sector lenders, so any shortfall to them is a loss of public money.
  • A clear IBBI rule that a dissenter's minimum must be paid in cash, or its present-value equivalent (its worth in today's money), would remove the need to settle this one case at a time.

  • Delay and deep haircuts reinforce each other:

  • Pending NCLT cases (13,170, about 71% older than 180 days) → asset value falls → bids come in close to liquidation value (Videocon: 95.85% haircut).
  • Fixes: dedicated NCLT benches, upfront deposits on appeals, and early resolution routes such as pre-packs.

  • Should haircuts be capped?

  • A haircut benchmark could protect banks from very low bids.
  • But a fixed cap may scare away bidders for badly damaged firms. Those firms would then go into liquidation, which recovers even less.
  • This trade-off ties resolution plans to the larger twin balance sheet clean-up: Recognition, Resolution, Recapitalisation and Reform (the 4R strategy).

Read more