Rules of origin

Indian Economy glossary

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →

Also called: ROO · Topic: International Trade Policy, WTO and Intellectual Property · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Rules of origin (RoO) are the rules that decide which country a product "comes from" (its national source). Only goods that originate in a partner country can claim the lower duty under a free trade agreement (FTA).

They matter because FTA members each keep their own import duty on outsiders. Without RoO, goods from a non-member could enter through the partner with the lowest duty and then move duty-free to the other partner. This is called trade deflection. RoO stop it by asking for real production inside the partner country.

RVC (%) = [(FOB value − Value of non-originating materials) ÷ FOB value] × 100

Explanation

Why an FTA needs rules of origin

  • An FTA has no common outside tariff
  • In an FTA (free trade agreement), members remove tariffs on trade with each other.
  • But each member keeps its own external tariff, which is the duty it charges on imports from non-members.
  • So outside tariffs differ from one member to another.

  • Trade deflection happens without RoO

  • A non-member sends its goods to the FTA partner that has the lowest outside tariff.
  • The goods are then re-exported duty-free to the partner with the higher tariff.
  • The higher-tariff country loses customs revenue, and its protection is bypassed.

  • A customs union does not need internal RoO

  • A customs union has a common external tariff (CET), meaning every member charges the same duty on outsiders.
  • Entering through one member gives no gain, so rerouting has no point.

  • Balassa's ladder (1961): PTA → FTA → customs union → common market → economic union → monetary union → complete integration. RoO become essential at the FTA stage.

The three main origin tests

  1. Wholly obtained - The good is fully grown, mined or made in the partner country. - Examples: fish caught there, minerals mined there.

  2. Change in tariff heading (CTH) or change in tariff sub-heading (CTSH) - Foreign inputs must be changed so much that the final product falls under a different HS tariff heading from its inputs. - The HS (Harmonised System) is the global code list used to classify goods. - Example: imported cotton yarn is made into shirts. The yarn and the shirt have different headings, so the shirt passes.

  3. Value-added threshold / regional value content (RVC) - A minimum share of the product's value must be added inside the FTA region. This share is often 35–40%. - FOB (free on board) value is the price of the good when it is loaded for export. - Non-originating materials are inputs brought in from outside the FTA region.

Worked example: the RVC test

A phone is exported from Thailand to India. Its FOB value is US$100, and it uses US$70 of Chinese parts.

Case Non-originating (Chinese) parts RVC Result at a 35% threshold
A US$70 (100 − 70) ÷ 100 × 100 = 30% Fails, so no ASEAN preference
B US$60 (100 − 60) ÷ 100 × 100 = 40% Passes, so the lower FTA duty applies
  • What changes the result
  • More foreign inputs → lower RVC → the product is more likely to fail.
  • A higher threshold → a stricter rule → less room for rerouted goods.
  • Strict rules stop deflection. But they also raise paperwork costs for honest exporters.

Proof and enforcement

  • Certificate of origin: a document issued by an authority in the exporting country. It proves where the good comes from, so the importer can claim the lower duty.
  • Verification: customs can check whether the certificate and the origin claim are true.

In India

  • CAROTAR 2020 (Customs (Administration of Rules of Origin under Trade Agreements) Rules, 2020)
  • Notified on 21 August 2020. In force from 21 September 2020, after a 30-day period given to importers to prepare [1].
  • It puts the burden of proof on the importer. The importer must hold origin information and give it to customs when asked. A certificate alone is not enough.
  • Its aim is to stop Chinese goods routed through ASEAN and other FTA partners.

  • The ASEAN experience

  • After the India–ASEAN Trade in Goods Agreement (TIGA, 2010), India's trade deficit with ASEAN (imports larger than exports) grew to about US$44 bn (2023-24) (verify current).
  • A review of the agreement began in 2023.

  • RCEP exit (November 2019): one of India's reasons for walking out was weak rules of origin, which could let Chinese goods in through other members. RCEP (Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership) is a mega-regional trade deal with 15 members.

  • Newer deals
  • The India–EFTA TEPA (signed 10 March 2024, in force 1 October 2025) has 14 chapters, and one of them is on rules of origin [2].
  • Newer deals also use tighter rules of origin, phased tariff cuts and safeguards.

  • Low FTA utilisation

  • Utilisation rate means the share of eligible exports that actually claim the FTA's lower duty.
  • Indian exporters use FTA preferences for only about a quarter of eligible exports.
  • A main reason is complex rules of origin, which make paperwork costly, especially for MSMEs.

Don't confuse with

  • Trade deflection vs trade diversion: Trade deflection is rerouting a non-member's goods through the low-tariff partner, and RoO are meant to stop it. Trade diversion (Jacob Viner, 1950) is buying from a less efficient partner instead of a cheaper non-member. That is a genuine shift of purchases, not rerouting.
  • Customs union: it has a common external tariff, so it does not need internal rules of origin. An FTA does need them.
  • Certificate of origin: this is the document that proves origin. Rules of origin are the criteria that decide origin. Under CAROTAR 2020, holding a certificate alone does not satisfy the importer's duty [1].
  • Spaghetti bowl effect (Jagdish Bhagwati): this is not a rule. It describes the cost of many overlapping FTAs, each with different rules of origin and tariff schedules, which hurts small firms most.

Prelims Hooks

  • An FTA needs rules of origin because members keep different external tariffs. A customs union (with a CET) does not need internal RoO.
  • RVC = (FOB − non-originating materials) ÷ FOB × 100. Common thresholds are 35–40%.
  • The three origin tests are wholly obtained, change in tariff heading (CTH/CTSH) based on HS codes, and regional value content (RVC).
  • CAROTAR 2020 was notified on 21 Aug 2020 and came into force on 21 Sept 2020. It places the burden of proving origin on the importer, not the exporter [1].
  • One of India's reasons for leaving RCEP (November 2019) was weak rules of origin, which carried the risk of Chinese goods entering through other members.
  • The "spaghetti bowl effect" (overlapping FTAs with different RoO) comes from Jagdish Bhagwati. Trade creation and trade diversion come from Jacob Viner (1950).

Mains Points

  • Strict vs simple rules: a trade-off
  • Strict RoO (high RVC, CAROTAR-style checks) block Chinese goods routed through ASEAN and protect Indian producers.
  • But complex rules raise compliance costs. That helps explain why Indian exporters use only about a quarter of eligible FTA preferences.
  • The policy goal is rules that are tight on deflection but easy for honest MSMEs to follow.

  • Lessons from ASEAN and RCEP for new FTAs

  • After TIGA (2010), the deficit with ASEAN widened to about US$44 bn (2023-24). This led to the RCEP exit (2019), CAROTAR 2020 and the 2023 review.
  • Newer deals such as the EFTA TEPA, with its own rules of origin chapter [2], and the EU FTA pair tighter RoO with phased tariff cuts over 5, 7 or 10 years [3] and with safeguards.

  • Fixing the utilisation gap and the spaghetti bowl

  • Use simpler, digital certificates of origin.
  • Allow self-certification by approved exporters.
  • Run awareness drives for MSMEs.
  • Design FTAs with common rules of origin across deals, so exporters do not face a different rulebook for each partner (GS-III: external sector, MSMEs).

Recent developments

  • India–Korea CEPA upgrade talks (12th round, May 2026): India and the Republic of Korea are renegotiating their CEPA (Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement, a trade deal that cuts import duties), which has been in force since 2010. Rules of origin are one of the subjects on the table, along with goods, services and investment. Both sides admitted that India's trade deficit with Korea (India buying more than it sells) has risen sharply since the deal began. This makes the upgrade another case, after the ASEAN review, of India using tighter origin rules to fix an older FTA that left it with a widening trade gap.
  • New sub-groups on supply chains (May 2026): The same round agreed to set up sub-groups on supply chains and strategic industrial cooperation. This matters for rules of origin because origin tests such as RVC (regional value content) and CTH (change in tariff heading) decide how much of a product's value or production must happen inside the partner country. Supply-chain links therefore decide which goods actually qualify for the lower FTA duty.

Related concepts

Read more

Sources

  1. 1PIB: Implementation of the Customs (Administration of Rules of Origin under Trade Agreements) Rules, 2020 with effect from 21st September 2020pib.gov.in · tier 1
  2. 2PIB: India–EFTA TEPA to come into effect on 01 October 2025pib.gov.in · tier 1
  3. 3PIB: India–EU Free Trade Agreement Concluded: A Strategic Breakthrough in India's Global Trade Engagementpib.gov.in · tier 1