Natural selection

Geography glossary

Topic: Biodiversity and its Conservation · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Natural selection is the process by which individuals whose inherited traits help them survive and have more young in their surroundings leave more offspring. Over many generations, those traits become more common in the population. It is the main force of evolution. Biodiversity, the product of 2.5–3.5 billion years of evolution, is largely its result.

Explanation

How it works (cause → process → result)

  • Cause: individuals differ, and the differences can be inherited
  • Within a species, individuals are not identical. This is genetic diversity (variation of genes within one species), such as differences in human height.
  • Only differences carried in the genes are passed on to the young.

  • Process: not all individuals survive or breed equally

  • Every species produces more young than its surroundings can support. So there is a struggle for food, space and mates.
  • Individuals with useful traits escape predators better, find more food or find more mates.
  • They leave more offspring, and those offspring carry the useful genes.

  • Result: the population changes over generations

  • Useful traits spread and harmful ones fade out.
  • A trait can become fixed, meaning it is the only form left in the population. Reversed shell coiling has become fixed many times in land snails.
  • Over long periods, populations can split into new species.

Conditions it needs

  • Variation: without genetic differences there is nothing to select. This is why the study note says genetic diversity is needed for adapting to change.
  • Heredity: the trait must pass from parent to offspring.
  • Differential survival and reproduction: the trait must change how many young an individual leaves behind.
  • Time: change shows up over generations, not within one lifetime.

Survival vs mating: a worked example from snails

  • A left-coiled snail is born among right-coiled ones
  • Its genital pore is on the opposite side, so it has trouble mating with most snails around it.
  • Fewer matings mean fewer young, so by this logic the new form should die out.

  • A predator changes the balance

  • Snakes of the genus Pareas have jaws shaped to pull right-coiled snails out of their shells.
  • Left-coiled snails escape these snakes more often, and the snake can recognise which way its prey coils.
  • Where these snakes live, the survival gain can be larger than the mating loss, so the reversed form spreads.

  • Lesson: natural selection weighs total offspring, not just survival. Here natural selection (survival advantage) and reproductive isolation (a mating barrier) act on the same gene at once.

Types (textbook)

  • Directional selection favours one extreme of a trait, so the population average shifts. Example: a snail population moving towards left coiling.
  • Stabilising selection favours the middle form and removes the extremes.
  • Disruptive selection favours both extremes over the middle. It can help split one population into two.

Where it occurs

  • Everywhere life exists: it has shaped all of the estimated 10 million species. About 99% of all species that ever lived are extinct, and an average species lasts 1–4 million years. Species that fail to adapt are lost.
  • Japan: in Euhadra land snails, reversed (left-handed) coiling has evolved several separate times. In 2023 hikers' online photos revealed a site in north Japan where left- and right-coiled snails of one species live together and still seem to interbreed. Mixed populations like this are natural laboratories for studying how species form.
  • Tropical rainforests: they hold about half of all species. They show how much variety evolution has produced where energy and water are plentiful.
  • Isolated places with many endemic species (species found naturally in one place only):
  • Madagascar: about 85% of its plants and animals are endemic, such as lemurs.
  • Western Ghats: the Nilgiri tahr, the lion-tailed macaque and Humboldtia decurrens.

  • In conservation practice in India:

  • In situ conservation (national parks, sanctuaries, biosphere reserves, sacred groves) keeps whole ecosystems and evolution running.
  • The National Gene Bank (NBPGR, New Delhi) and the protection of wild relatives of crops preserve the genetic variation that selection needs.

Don't confuse with

  • Artificial selection: humans, not nature, choose which plants or animals breed, as in crop and livestock breeding. Agro-biodiversity is the base for this breeding. Switching to a few high-yielding varieties reduces it.
  • Mutation: a change in a gene. It creates new variation. Natural selection only sorts the variation that already exists.
  • Lamarck's inheritance of acquired characters: the idea that traits gained during life (like strong muscles) pass to children. In natural selection, only inherited genetic traits are passed on.
  • "Survival of the fittest" read as "strongest wins": fitness means leaving more offspring. A left-coiled snail is a poorer mate but can still win through better survival.

Prelims Hooks

  • Natural selection needs three things: variation, inheritance and unequal survival and reproduction. It acts on populations over generations, not on one individual in its lifetime.
  • Pareas snakes prey mainly on right-coiled snails. This favours left-coiled snails, so the coiling gene works as an anti-predator adaptation (a body change that helps avoid being eaten).
  • "Single-gene speciation by left–right reversal" was proposed in Euhadra land snails of Japan (Ueshima & Asami, Nature, 2003).
  • Of the three levels of biodiversity (genetic, species, ecosystem), natural selection acts directly on genetic diversity.
  • Trap: "In situ conservation freezes species in their present form." FALSE. In situ conservation keeps evolution running. Ex situ methods such as zoos and gene banks take species out of natural selection.
  • Trap: "Natural selection creates new genes." FALSE. Mutation creates variation and selection sorts it.

Mains Points

  • Loss of genetic diversity weakens adaptation:
  • Habitat loss, breaking up habitats, and switching to a few high-yielding crop varieties all shrink the gene pool.
  • With less variation, natural selection has less to work with, so species cope worse with climate change and new diseases (GS-III, environment).

  • Humans are now a selective force faster than nature:

  • Human activity drives extinction far faster than the natural rate. IPBES (2019) warned that about 1 million species face extinction.
  • Species cannot adapt at this speed. This is the case for in situ conservation and for corridors that let populations keep breeding and evolving.

  • Selection and speciation are linked but not the same: coiling reversal in snails can start a mating barrier. But the mixed population in north Japan shows the barrier is leaky, so it slows the split into two species without finishing it. Use this in answers on how biodiversity arises.

Read more