Madhyamaka

History glossary

Also called: Shunyavada · Topic: Buddhism, Jainism and Heterodox Traditions · NCERT: Beyond NCERT

Meaning

Madhyamaka ("the school of the middle"), also called Shunyavada ("the teaching of emptiness"), is a Mahāyāna Buddhist school of philosophy founded by Nagarjuna (c. 2nd century CE). It teaches shunyata (emptiness): nothing exists on its own, and everything depends on other things for its existence.

It is the main thinking school of Mahāyāna Buddhism. It shaped later Buddhist study at centres like Nalanda, and it later shaped Buddhism in Tibet and East Asia. UPSC often asks about its founder, its key idea, its main text, and how it differs from the other Mahāyāna school, Yogachara.

Explanation

Background: why it arose

  • Mahāyāna ideas started appearing from c. second century BCE onwards. By the first century CE the change in practice was clear.
  • Mahāyāna arose within Indian Buddhism around the beginning of the Common Era. [1]
  • The older schools had built detailed lists of the basic "pieces" of existence.
  • These schools are the so-called 18 ancient schools, later labelled Hīnayāna. [1]
  • Some of them treated these tiny pieces (called dharmas) as real things that exist on their own.

  • Nagarjuna argued that this view went against the Buddha's own teaching that everything changes and depends on other things.

  • Madhyamaka gave Mahāyāna its philosophical base. It used careful logic, not only faith and devotion.

Main ideas

  • Shunyata (emptiness). Every thing is "empty". This does not mean it does not exist. It means it has no fixed, separate self of its own (svabhava, "own-nature").
  • Pratityasamutpada (dependent origination). Everything arises because of causes and conditions. A pot depends on clay, a potter, water and fire. Nagarjuna said that dependent origination and emptiness are the same thing seen from two sides.
  • The "middle" in Madhyamaka. It avoids two extremes:
  • Eternalism: the view that things exist permanently and on their own.
  • Nihilism: the view that nothing exists at all.

  • The truth lies in the middle, so the school is named after it.

  • Two truths.

  • Conventional truth (samvriti satya) is the everyday world, where we speak of people, pots and trees.
  • Ultimate truth (paramartha satya) is that all these things are empty.

  • Both are needed. Ordinary language works in daily life, but it does not show how things finally are.

  • Method: arguing to show that a view fails. Nagarjuna took a rival view and showed that it leads to a contradiction. He did not set up a fixed view of his own to defend.

How it developed

  • Nagarjuna (c. 2nd century CE) wrote the root text, the Mulamadhyamakakarika ("Root Verses on the Middle Way").
  • His disciple Aryadeva carried the teaching forward.
  • Later commentators such as Chandrakirti explained and expanded it.
  • Asanga and Vasubandhu started a rival Mahāyāna school, Yogachara (Vijnanavada), which stressed the mind. Mahāyāna philosophy then had two main schools.

Results

  • Madhyamaka gave a reasoned basis to the Bodhisattva ideal.
  • A bodhisattva is a compassionate being who builds up merit (good karma from good deeds) but puts off nibbāna (freedom from rebirth) to help others.

  • If there is no fixed, separate self, then "my" release cannot be cut off from the suffering of others. Wisdom (seeing emptiness) and compassion go together.

  • It became a core subject in monastic universities such as Nalanda.

  • By the 9th century CE, Mahāyāna was the main influence on the Buddhist cultures of Central and East Asia. [1] Madhyamaka travelled with it and became especially central in Tibetan Buddhism.

Time, place and evidence

  • Period: c. 2nd century CE, in the early centuries of the Common Era, when Mahāyāna was growing. Nagarjuna's exact dates are uncertain.
  • Place: According to tradition, Nagarjuna is linked to the Andhra region in the Deccan. The site of Nagarjunakonda, on the Krishna river, is named after him. The link is traditional and not proved.
  • Key people: Nagarjuna (founder), Aryadeva (disciple), Chandrakirti (later commentator).
  • Evidence:
  • Texts are the main evidence. The chief one is the Mulamadhyamakakarika, a work of short Sanskrit verses.
  • Many of Nagarjuna's works survive mainly in Tibetan and Chinese translations. This shows how widely they spread.

  • What we know of his life comes from later legends and biographies. These are not reliable for exact dates.

  • Syllabus note: This is beyond NCERT. NCERT covers the wider Mahāyāna shift, not this school by name.

Don't confuse with

  • Yogachara / Vijnanavada: the other Mahāyāna philosophical school, founded by Asanga and Vasubandhu. It says that only the mind or consciousness (vijnana) is real. Madhyamaka says even the mind is empty.
  • Madhyama pratipada (the Buddha's Middle Path): the Buddha's own advice to avoid both a life of pleasure and harsh self-torture. Madhyamaka's "middle" is a philosophical middle between "things truly exist" and "nothing exists".
  • Nagasena: the monk in the Milindapanho who answered the questions of the Indo-Greek king Menander (Milinda). Nagarjuna founded Madhyamaka and wrote the Mulamadhyamakakarika.
  • Theravāda / Hīnayāna schools: these older schools held up the arhat, the perfected individual who wins release. [1] Madhyamaka belongs to Mahāyāna, which puts the bodhisattva first. Remember that Hīnayāna was a label given by Mahāyāna, while the group called itself Theravāda.

Prelims Hooks

  • Madhyamaka = Shunyavada. These are two names for the same school.
  • Founder–text pair: Nagarjuna → Mulamadhyamakakarika.
  • Key idea: shunyata (emptiness), which is the same as pratityasamutpada (dependent origination).
  • Madhyamaka and Yogachara are both Mahāyāna. Trap: Yogachara (Asanga, Vasubandhu) teaches "only consciousness is real", not emptiness of everything.
  • Mahāyāna = "great vehicle". Mahāyāna ideas appear from c. second century BCE onwards, and the change is clear by the first century CE.
  • Nagarjunakonda (on the Krishna, Andhra region) is traditionally linked with Nagarjuna's name.

Mains Points

  • It moved Mahāyāna from devotion to philosophy.
  • The wider Mahāyāna shift brought the saviour idea, image worship and the bodhisattva.
  • Madhyamaka gave this shift a tight logical base: if nothing has a separate self, then compassion for all beings follows from wisdom.

  • This shows that Indian religion in this period changed in ideas as well as in practice.

  • It is an Indian contribution to world philosophy and to the culture of Asia.

  • Its works were taught at Nalanda, translated into Tibetan and Chinese, and carried along the routes of Mahāyāna's spread.
  • By the 9th century CE, Mahāyāna was the main influence on Buddhist cultures of Central and East Asia. [1]

  • It fits GS-I themes of Indian heritage and India's cultural links with Asia.

  • Continuity and change.

  • Madhyamaka claimed to go back to the Buddha's own ideas of the Middle Path and dependent origination, rather than break from them.
  • It rejected the fixed categories of the older schools.
  • This is a good example of a tradition that changed itself by reading its own roots in a new way.

Related concepts

Read more

Sources

  1. 1Mahayana | Origins, Beliefs, Practices & Schools; Hīnayāna; Theravada; Mahāsaṅghikabritannica.com · tier 3