"Civilisational dialogues have changed the ideas of the world more enduringly than empires changed its maps." Discuss with reference to India's historical links with Central and East Asia.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
At the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum (New Delhi, 2026), the Prime Minister contrasted empires, which redrew maps, with dialogues, which "changed the ideas of the world and enriched them" [1]. India's links with Central and East Asia largely support this claim. The borders of empires changed many times, but the ideas exchanged across them have lasted.
Central Asia and West Asia: ideas that outlived empires
- Ancient trade links: Indus–Mesopotamia trade began about 5,000 years ago [1].
- Literature: the Panchatantra became Kalila wa Dimna in Persian and Arabic [1].
- Science: Brahmagupta's mathematics reached Baghdad, where Al-Khwarizmi developed it further [1].
- Art forms created together: the Central Asian Maqam and the Indian Raga; Sufi influence on Qawwali; the garden traditions of Samarkand and Herat shaped the Charbagh style [1].
East Asia: Buddhist and Silk Route networks
- Travellers who carried texts: Faxian, Xuanzang, Yijing and Kumarajiva moved ideas between India and China [1].
- Centres of exchange: Nalanda, Kucha and Dunhuang [1].
- Global recognition: UNESCO inscribed the Chang'an–Tianshan Silk Roads corridor in 2014 as a joint listing of China, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan [3]. It shows that the Silk Road is remembered as a network of exchange, not as one empire's territory.
Why ideas last longer than maps
- Ideas were adapted locally, not imposed: the Ramayana became Cambodia's Reamker [1]. Because local societies took ownership, these ideas outlived the political regimes of their time.
Limits of the claim
- Empires and trade routes often carried ideas. Dialogue and power were not fully separate.
- A shared past does not settle present disputes. China and Pakistan are fellow SCO members [2], so culture complements security; it cannot replace it.
Contemporary relevance
- India has built this track step by step. In 2020 it translated 10 regional classics into Russian and Chinese. In 2022–23 it added a Shared Buddhist Heritage vertical and Varanasi became the first SCO Cultural and Tourism Capital [2].
- The forum proposes AI-assisted translation, digitising ancient texts and heritage circuits [1].
Taken together, India's exchanges with Asia show that ideas co-created over centuries outlast the empires that shaped borders. The way forward is to turn this heritage into lasting institutions: regular SCO cultural mechanisms, digitised manuscripts and joint heritage listings. In the spirit of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, "our diversity itself becomes the basis of our unity" [1].
Sources
- 1Prime Minister inaugurates First SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum, Press Information Bureau (20 Nov 2026)PM's quote; Indus–Mesopotamia trade; Kalila wa Dimna, Brahmagupta/Al-Khwarizmi, Maqam/Raga, Qawwali, Charbagh; Faxian, Xuanzang, Yijing, Kumarajiva; Nalanda, Kucha, Dunhuang; Reamker; AI translation and heritage circuits; Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam
- 2Brief on India-SCO Cooperation, Ministry of External Affairs (July 2026)SCO membership incl. China and Pakistan; 10 classics translated (2020); Shared Buddhist Heritage vertical; Varanasi as 1st SCO Cultural and Tourism Capital (2022–23)
- 3Decision 38 COM 8B.24 – Silk Roads: the Routes Network of Chang'an-Tianshan Corridor, UNESCO World Heritage Centre (2014)2014 inscription as a joint listing of China, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan