·PIB·15 marks·250–350 wordsS&THistoryCulture

Examine whether cultural diplomacy can serve as a "third pillar" of the SCO alongside security and economic cooperation, given India's strategic differences with some members.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Why culture can be a third pillar
  2. Limits, given strategic differences
  3. Making the pillar last

At the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum at Purana Qila (20 November 2026), PM Modi placed culture beside security, economy and connectivity. He said that empires changed maps, but civilisational dialogues changed ideas [1]. Culture can work as a third pillar, but it adds to the hard pillars and does not replace them.

Why culture can be a third pillar

  • Shared heritage: the Panchatantra became Kalila wa Dimna; Brahmagupta's mathematics reached Baghdad, where Al-Khwarizmi built on it; the Charbagh garden style drew on Samarkand and Herat [1].
  • A channel with less friction: China and Pakistan are both full members [2]. Culture keeps talks going when the security track is stuck.
  • Steady build-up: a Buddhist heritage exhibition and 10 Indian classics translated into Russian and Chinese (2020); a Shared Buddhist Heritage vertical and Varanasi as the first Cultural and Tourism Capital (2022–23) [2]; now the forum [1].
  • Economic gains: heritage circuits and cultural tourism [1].

Limits, given strategic differences

  • The past does not settle present disputes: no shared tradition resolves terrorism or border issues. There is little evidence that earlier cultural steps changed any member's political position.
  • Contest over the story: the Secretariat is in Beijing and the only official languages are Russian and Chinese [2]. UNESCO's Chang'an–Tianshan Silk Roads listing covers China, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan, not India [3]. The accepted Silk Road story may leave India at the edge.
  • Risk of symbolism: events that produce no measurable results invite the charge that culture is just a safe topic for speeches.

Making the pillar last

  • Make it regular: India's National Coordinator, the Additional Secretary (SCO) at the MEA, should send forum outcomes to the SCO Culture ministers' meetings every year [2].
  • Connect the work at home: the Gyan Bharatam Mission (Budget 2025-26) digitises manuscripts [4], and these can feed the forum's proposal for AI translation [1].
  • Lead a joint UNESCO nomination of Buddhist routes with SCO partners, on the 2014 multi-country model [3].
  • Count outputs, not events: texts digitised, translations published, joint research projects.

Cultural diplomacy cannot settle India's strategic differences within the SCO. It can still keep a channel of trust open where the security track has stalled. If it becomes a regular process and is judged by results, it can carry the spirit of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam and help India shape SCO norms. It would then be a real third pillar that supports security and economic cooperation.

Sources

  1. 1PIB: "Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi inaugurates First SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum" (20 Nov 2026)the PM's "maps vs ideas" line; culture as a pillar; Kalila wa Dimna, Brahmagupta and Charbagh examples; heritage circuits; AI translation proposal
  2. 2Ministry of External Affairs: Brief on India-SCO Cooperation (3 July 2026)membership; 2020 exhibition and translations; five verticals; Varanasi capital; Beijing Secretariat; official languages; National Coordinator; culture ministers' meetings
  3. 3UNESCO World Heritage Committee: Decision 38 COM 8B.24 (2014)Chang'an–Tianshan corridor nominated jointly by China, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan
  4. 4PIB, Ministry of Culture: Gyan Bharatam Missionmanuscript mission announced in Union Budget 2025-26
Practice
7 questions on this item
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on S&T