"Classifying religious identity in the Census is as much a political act as a statistical one." Discuss with reference to Census 2027 and the demand for a Sarna code.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
The Census is held under the Census Act, 1948 (Entry 69, Union List). It records religion through six named religions plus "Others" [1]. On 16 November 2026, the self-enumeration portal of India's first digital Census [2] briefly offered 287 "Other" religion options. They were withdrawn the same day after a media query [1]. This shows that the way the state names faith is never purely technical.
Statistical dimension: why classification is needed
- Planning and welfare: reliable religion data guides minority welfare and resource allocation.
- Self-identification: Art. 25 protects the freedom to "profess" religion, so the Census records the faith a person states.
- Digital standardisation: respondents use se.circus.gov.in in 16 languages during an optional 15-day window, and enumerators verify the entries [2]. Fixed codes cut down on write-in errors. However, the coding is now decided before the count, not at tabulation.
Political dimension: why classification is contested
- Fragmenting the count: listing ISKCON, Sanatan and Shri Ram as separate "religions" could break up the Hindu count [1].
- Denomination vs religion: splitting Islam into Shia/Sunni and Christianity into Methodist/Pentecostal confuses denominations (Art. 26) with religions [1].
- Sarna code: Adivasi groups in Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Odisha and West Bengal want a separate column because they say their faith is distinct from Hinduism [1]. Listing Sarna as one of 287 options is only token recognition. It is a recurring electoral issue in Jharkhand and Odisha [1].
- Overlap with caste: entries such as Balmiki, Bishnoi and Gorak Nath blur faith and caste. This comes just as caste enumeration, approved by the CCPA on 30 April 2025, enters Phase 2 [3].
- Timing and transparency: the menu appeared while self-enumeration was live in four poll-bound States. It was removed only after a media query, which points to weak vetting [1].
Religion data is therefore both a planning tool and a statement of who belongs. Before door-to-door enumeration begins on 25 January 2027 [1], the government should:
- publish the classification code list for public consultation;
- hold structured talks with tribal bodies on the Sarna demand;
- keep religion separate from denomination and caste.
Grounding the Census in self-identification under Art. 25 and in state neutrality would keep the count accurate and consistent with constitutional secularism.
Sources
- 1'ISKCON', 'Tantric', 'Gorak Nath': 287 'other' religions briefly listed on Census portal, The Hindu (news report, 17 Nov 2026): 287-option menu and its withdrawal; seven religion categories; examples of sects and denominations; Sarna demand and the States involved; four poll-bound States; PE start date
- 2PIB document on Census 2027 (April 2026): first digital Census; SE portal, 16 languages, 15-day window, enumerator verification
- 3PMIndia: Cabinet approves scheme of conduct of Census of India 2027: CCPA decision of 30 April 2025; caste enumeration in Phase 2