Should the Census recognise sects and denominations as separate religions? Critically analyse in light of Articles 25 and 26.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →On 16 November 2026, the Census 2027 self-enumeration portal briefly listed 287 "Other" religions. They included ISKCON, Sanatan, Tantric, Gorak Nath and Sarna, and the list also split Shia/Sunni and Methodist/Pentecostal. The menu was withdrawn the same day [1]. Articles 25–26 suggest the Census should record faith by self-identification, not by sub-categories the state draws up.
Constitutional frame
- Art. 25 guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to profess religion. The Census must therefore record the faith a respondent states.
- Art. 26 gives rights to a religious denomination. Shirur Mutt (1954) treats a denomination as a group within a religion that shares a common faith, organisation and name.
Case for recognition
- It respects self-description under Art. 25, and the Census already records the faith a person states [3].
- It makes indigenous faiths visible. Adivasis of Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Odisha and West Bengal want a separate Sarna code [1].
- More detailed data can guide minority protection and cultural policy.
Case against
- Category error: the list treats denominations (Shia/Sunni) and devotional movements (ISKCON) as religions [1]. Art. 26 protects them as denominations. In S.P. Mittal (1983), it was the Supreme Court, not a drop-down menu, that held Sri Aurobindo's teachings were not a separate religion.
- State neutrality: pre-coded lists split up the counts and politicise the data. The portal was live in four poll-bound States [1].
- Religion and caste get mixed up: Balmiki and Bishnoi were listed as religions just as caste enumeration enters Phase II [1][2].
- Digital rigidity: drop-down menus fix the coding at the moment of entry. Paper Censuses did this coding later, at tabulation. Data quality now depends on enumerators verifying the online entries [3].
Way forward
- Keep the six named religions + Others. Let respondents write their faith in free text, and have the Registrar General's experts code it later [1][3].
- Consult communities on whether distinct indigenous faiths such as Sarna need a separate code.
- Publish classification code lists in advance for public comment.
The Census should record what citizens profess, not decide what counts as a religion. Free self-description, sect detail recorded at the tabulation stage, and codes for indigenous faiths drawn up through consultation would honour Arts. 25–26 and secular neutrality. They would also make India's first digital Census more credible [3].
Sources
- 1'ISKCON', 'Tantric', 'Gorak Nath': 287 'other' religions briefly listed on Census portal — The Hindu, news report, 17 Nov 2026287-option menu and its withdrawal; Shia/Sunni and Methodist/Pentecostal splits; Sarna demand; poll-bound States; seven-category practice
- 2PIB: Population Census-2027 to be conducted in two phases along with enumeration of castescaste counted in Phase II (Population Enumeration)
- 3PIB: Census 2027 — India's First Digital Enumeration Exercise (April 2026)first digital Census; self-enumeration and enumerator verification; recording of stated faith