·The Hindu

‘ISKCON’, ‘Tantric’, ‘Gorak Nath’: 287 ‘other’ religions briefly listed on Census portal

FlashcardsQuick reviseKey facts. One by one.Start →
In this note
  1. At a Glance
  2. Why in the News
  3. Background & Evolution
  4. Core Static Facts
  5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis
  6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)
  7. Prelims Hooks
  8. Why a Drop-Down Menu Is Not the Same as a Blank Box
  9. Sarna on a List Is Not a Sarna Code
  10. The Best Case for the Longer List, and Where It Falls Short
  11. What the Registrar General Should Settle Before 25 January 2027
  12. Anchors for Answers
  13. Mains Relevance
  14. Related Topics to Study Next
  15. NCERT Concepts to Revise
  16. Common Errors / Trap Areas

1. At a Glance

  • What happened: The Census 2027 self-enumeration portal offered a drop-down menu of 287 options under "Others" in the religion question. The government withdrew it on the day it went live (16 Nov 2026) [1].
  • Why the list mattered: It put sects, deities, saints and movements next to recognised religions. Examples are ISKCON, Sanatan, Shri Ram, Tantric, Gorak Nath, Sarna, Bishnoi. It also split Islam into Shia/Sunni and Christianity into Methodist/Pentecostal [1].
  • Why it matters for UPSC: It brings together Census methodology, freedom of religion (Arts. 25–28), Adivasi identity (Sarna code demand), and digital governance in India's first digital Census [1][3].

2. Why in the News

  • 16 Nov 2026: The self-enumeration portal for the Population Enumeration (PE) phase of Census 2027 went live for four poll-bound States [1].
  • It showed 287 "Other" religion options. The drop-down was removed later the same day after The Hindu questioned the Union Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) about the classification [1].
  • Door-to-door population enumeration is to begin on 25 January 2027 [1].

3. Background & Evolution

  • Statutory base: Census is conducted under the Census Act, 1948. "Census" is Entry 69, Union List (Seventh Schedule). (Static fact; not in the retrieved sources.)
  • Milestones of Census 2027:
  • 30 Apr 2025: The Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs (CCPA) decided to include caste enumeration in Census 2027 [3].
  • 16 Jun 2025: Gazette notification of intent to conduct Census 2027 [2].
  • 7 Jan 2026: Notification fixing the period of the 1st phase (Houselisting & Housing Census) [2].
  • 22 Jan 2026: Questions for the 1st phase notified [2].
  • 16 Nov 2026: PE self-enumeration portal went live; the 287-option menu was withdrawn [1].
  • 25 Jan 2027: Door-to-door PE begins [1].

  • Earlier practice: Past Censuses also used seven religion categories: Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Others [1]. Respondents in "Others" wrote their faith in a separate column [3].

  • Long-running demand: Tribal communities in Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Odisha and West Bengal have pressed for a separate religion column for Adivasi faiths, which they say are distinct from Hinduism [1].

4. Core Static Facts

Item Fact
Census round Census 2027. It is India's first digital Census, using mobile-based data collection [3]
Phases (1) Houselisting & Housing Census; (2) Population Enumeration. Caste is counted in Phase 2 [2]
Religion categories 6 pre-coded (Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain) + Others = 7 [1][3]
"Others" options on portal 287 (withdrawn) [1]
Self-enumeration Optional 15-day window before the field visit [3]
SE portal se.census.gov.in, available in 16 languages [3]
Verification Enumerators still visit and confirm self-enumerated data before final submission [3]
Digital tools Census Management & Monitoring System (CMMS) and a satellite-based Houselisting Block creator [3]
Caste decision CCPA, 30 Apr 2025 [3]
Nodal ministry MHA, through the Office of the Registrar General & Census Commissioner, India [1] (the RGI link is static)

5. Multi-Dimensional Analysis

Legal / Constitutional

  • Art. 25 protects the freedom to "profess" religion. Self-identification is the norm, and the Census records the faith a respondent states [3].
  • A pre-built list of 287 entries suggests state-led classification. It mixes denominations (Shia/Sunni, Methodist/Pentecostal) with religions, which raises questions under Art. 26 (religious denominations) [1].
  • Presenting ISKCON, Ramakrishna Paramahans, Sanatan, Shri Ram as separate "religions" could break up the Hindu count [1].

Social / Tribal

  • Listing Sarna in the drop-down could be read as partly meeting the Adivasi demand for a separate code. It falls well short of a stand-alone column [1].
  • Folk and sect identities such as Balmiki, Ramdev, Bishnoi and Gorak Nath mostly overlap with caste and community. This confuses religion with caste just as caste enumeration is being added [1][3].

Administrative / Governance

  • The menu was put up and then removed after a media query. This points to gaps in pre-launch vetting and transparency about the classification code list [1].
  • The digital self-enumeration mode turns coding choices into fixed drop-down menus. In paper Censuses, coding happened after the count, at tabulation [3].
  • Data quality depends on enumerator verification of online entries [3].

Political

  • The withdrawal happened while self-enumeration was live in four poll-bound States [1].
  • Religion counts feed into debates on minority status and welfare. The Sarna code is a recurring issue in Jharkhand and Odisha politics [1].

Ethical

  • The neutrality of the state in naming faiths is at stake. So are the dignity and self-description of minority and indigenous belief systems [1].

6. Recent Developments (last 12–18 months)

  • 30 Apr 2025: CCPA approved caste enumeration in Census 2027 [3].
  • 16 Jun 2025: Census 2027 intent notified [2].
  • 7 Jan 2026: Phase-1 period notified [2].
  • 22 Jan 2026: Phase-1 questions notified [2].
  • Apr 2026: PIB set out the digital architecture: mobile apps, CMMS, the SE portal in 16 languages [3].
  • 16 Nov 2026: The PE self-enumeration portal went live in four poll-bound States, and the 287-option "Others" menu was withdrawn the same day [1].
  • 25 Jan 2027: Door-to-door PE scheduled to begin [1].

7. Prelims Hooks

  • Census 2027 is India's first digital Census [3].
  • Religion question: 7 categories, made up of 6 named religions + Others [1].
  • The 6 named religions are Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain [1][3].
  • The portal briefly listed 287 sub-options under "Others" [1].
  • The self-enumeration portal is se.census.gov.in [3].
  • The SE portal is available in 16 languages [3].
  • The self-enumeration window is 15 days and comes before the house-to-house visit [3].
  • Caste enumeration takes place in the 2nd phase (Population Enumeration) [2].
  • Caste inclusion was decided by the CCPA on 30 April 2025, not by Parliament through a law [3].
  • Census 2027 intent was notified on 16 June 2025 [2].
  • CMMS is the Census Management & Monitoring System [3].
  • Sarna is the faith associated with Adivasi communities of Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Odisha and West Bengal that seek a separate religion code [1].
  • Door-to-door PE begins on 25 January 2027 [1].
  • Census is under the Union List (Entry 69) and governed by the Census Act, 1948 (static).

8. Why a Drop-Down Menu Is Not the Same as a Blank Box

  • In past Censuses, people wrote their faith first, and officials sorted it later
  • A person in "Others" wrote their faith in their own words [3].
  • The written answers were later grouped under ORP (Other Religions and Persuasions, the Census name for all faiths outside the six main ones).
  • The names used for this grouping were published only with the final tables. In 2011, for example, an appendix to table C-01 named the faiths counted under ORP [6].

  • A drop-down menu reverses this order

  • The list exists before anyone answers. A person scrolls through it and picks the closest match, even if it is not how they would describe themselves.
  • A blank box records the person's own words. A menu records the state's words.

  • Being on the list looks like official recognition

  • On a government portal, a list of 287 "religions" looks like an approved list, even if officials meant it only as a tool to sort answers [1].
  • So the menu did more than help people fill the form. Whoever wrote it was in effect deciding what counts as a religion.

  • The list mixed different kinds of things on one level

  • A denomination (a branch inside one religion, like Shia within Islam) sat beside a saint, a deity and a whole faith [1].
  • A statistician sorting answers later can keep these levels apart. A flat menu cannot, so a Shia answer and a Sarna answer end up as the same kind of entry.

9. Sarna on a List Is Not a Sarna Code

  • Tribal faiths once had their own place in the Census
  • Censuses from 1871 to 1951 had a separate category for tribal religion. It was later dropped [4].
  • Since then, Adivasis who do not call themselves Hindu, Christian, etc. have had to use "Others" [4].

  • The demand has formal backing from a State legislature

  • On 11 November 2020, the Jharkhand Assembly unanimously passed a resolution, in a special session, asking for a separate Sarna column in the Census [4].
  • The resolution was sent to the Centre. The Centre has not granted the code [4].
  • In 2016, the Union government had already decided that Scheduled Tribes could be recorded under any of the six religions the Census recognises [5].

  • Being in a menu adds very little

  • Sarna was already one of the named faiths in the 2011 ORP tables [6]. So appearing in the drop-down gave it nothing new.
  • A separate code would give Sarna its own printed count in the main religion tables, next to Hindu or Jain. Inside "Others", that count is hidden among hundreds of small entries.
  • This matters because a faith with no visible number is easy to leave out of policy and political debate.

  • Why the withdrawal hurts on both sides

  • Groups that wanted Sarna on the list lost even that small step when the whole menu was removed on the same day [1].
  • Groups that opposed splitting the Hindu count saw the list as a threat [1].
  • The State used the list without first deciding the real question: which faiths get their own code.

10. The Best Case for the Longer List, and Where It Falls Short

  • The strongest argument for the menu
  • India has hundreds of small faiths. In 2011, officials had to read handwritten answers and sort them into named ORP groups after the count [6].
  • In a digital Census, typed answers bring spelling mistakes and different names for the same faith. A fixed list removes most of that cleaning work.
  • A long list can also look more respectful than one word, "Others", for everyone outside the six big religions.

  • What this argument gets right

  • Sorting answers does have a real cost, and a menu does reduce errors. A digital Census needs some list of codes [3].

  • Where it falls short

  • A sorting tool is meant for officials, not for the person answering. Showing the list to the respondent turns it from a tool into a suggestion of what to answer.
  • The list was not shared with the public before launch, and it went live during self-enumeration in four poll-bound States [1]. A long list is not the problem in itself. The problem is that nobody saw it in advance.
  • The better design keeps both aims: the person types freely, and the list of codes is used behind the screen to sort the answers.

11. What the Registrar General Should Settle Before 25 January 2027

  • Say what happens to answers already given through the menu
  • The portal was live for part of 16 November in four States before the menu was removed [1].
  • Some people may have already picked one of the 287 options. The Office of the Registrar General of India (RGI) should say publicly whether these answers will be kept, recoded or checked again.

  • Make sure the portal and the enumerator's app use the same rules

  • Enumerators confirm self-enumerated data before final submission [3].
  • If the app used in house visits has a different religion screen from the portal, the same faith will be recorded two ways. The RGI should issue one common rule before door-to-door PE begins on 25 January 2027 [1].

  • Publish the code list before the count, not after

  • In 2011, the names of ORP faiths were published only with the final tables [6].
  • For a digital Census, the RGI should put the full code list out for public comment before the count. Community groups could then flag mislabels, such as a saint listed as a religion, in advance.

  • The Centre should give a formal answer to the Sarna demand

  • Jharkhand's unanimous resolution of 2020 still has no formal reply [4].
  • The MHA should say yes or no, with reasons, before Phase 2. This is better than letting a drop-down menu decide the matter quietly.

12. Anchors for Answers

  • Data: Censuses from 1871 to 1951 had a separate tribal-religion category, which was later dropped [4]
  • Data: Sarna was among the named faiths under "Other Religions and Persuasions" in the 2011 Census table C-01 [6]
  • Report/Committee: Jharkhand Assembly resolution, 11 November 2020 (special session, unanimous), seeking a separate Sarna column in the Census [4]
  • Law/Case: Article 25 (freedom to profess religion) and Article 26 (rights of religious denominations); Census Act, 1948
  • Comparison: 2011 Census coded written-in faiths after the count [6]; the 2027 portal tried to fix the list before the count [1]

13. Mains Relevance

14. Related Topics to Study Next

  • Sarna Dharma Code demand. It is the main Adivasi identity issue raised by this episode.
  • Caste enumeration in Census 2027. Religion and caste coding now meet in one schedule.
  • Census Act, 1948 and Census Rules, 1990. These cover the legal duty to answer, confidentiality and penalties.
  • Arts. 25–30 and minority status (NCM Act, 1992). Religion data drives minority recognition.
  • Delimitation after Census 2027. Population counts feed into seat readjustment.
  • Nath Panth / Gorakhnath and ISKCON (Gaudiya Vaishnavism). These are GS-I culture topics behind the listed "religions".
  • NPR and digital identity linkages. They raise privacy and data-protection concerns (DPDP Act, 2023).

15. NCERT Concepts to Revise

  • Census 2027 (Geography): The whole episode concerns this first digital census and its religion question and portal.
  • Self-enumeration (Geography): The 287-option menu appeared on the online self-enumeration portal, which enumerators later verify.
  • Freedom of religion (Polity): Arts. 25–28 frame whether the state should list sects and denominations as separate religions.
  • Caste census (Polity): Caste counting is added in Phase 2, and sect and caste identities blurred in the list.
  • Adivasi (History): Sarna and the demand for a separate Adivasi religion code are central to the controversy.
  • Scheduled Tribes (Polity): Tribal communities seeking a Sarna code are Scheduled Tribes, whose identity the religion column affects.
  • Registrar General of India (Polity): The RGI under MHA runs the Census, not MoSPI, a common exam trap.
  • Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs (Polity): This committee, not Parliament, decided on 30 April 2025 to include caste enumeration.
  • Union List (Polity): Census is Entry 69 of the Union List, so only Parliament legislates on it.
  • Digital public infrastructure (Polity): The digital Census, with its portal and monitoring tools, is an example of e-governance infrastructure.
  • Transparency (Polity): The menu was withdrawn after a media query, raising questions about openness in how classification codes are drawn up.
  • Naths, Jogis and Siddhas (History): Gorak Nath, listed as a 'religion', belongs to the Nath tradition.
  • Gaudiya Vaishnavism (History): ISKCON, listed among the options, belongs to this Bengal devotional tradition.
  • Delimitation (Polity): Census 2027 population counts will feed into the readjustment of constituency seats.
  • National Commission for Minorities (Polity): Religion data drives which communities are recognised and protected as minorities.

16. Common Errors / Trap Areas

  • "Six" or "seven" religion categories: There are 6 named + Others = 7 [1].
  • Census ≠ NSSO/MoSPI: The Census is run under MHA (RGI), not MoSPI [1].
  • Caste phase: Caste is enumerated in Phase 2 (PE), not Phase 1 (Houselisting) [2].
  • Self-enumeration does not replace the field visit. Enumerators still verify the online data [3].
  • The 287-option list was not adopted. It was withdrawn on 16 Nov 2026, so do not treat it as the official classification [1].
  • Dates disagree across secondary sources. Rely on the gazette and PIB dates listed here.

Sources

  1. 1'ISKCON', 'Tantric', 'Gorak Nath': 287 'other' religions briefly listed on Census portal — The Hindu (Vijaita Singh, Abhinay Lakshman, 17 Nov 2026)thehindu.com · tier 4
  2. 2PIB document on Census 2027 (May 2026 press deck)static.pib.gov.in · tier 1
  3. 3PIB document on Census 2027 (April 2026)static.pib.gov.in · tier 1
  4. 4Jharkhand Assembly passes resolution for separate identity code for tribals — Down To Earthdowntoearth.org.in · tier 4
  5. 5Sarna Dharam: Code of Adivasi identity and eco-nationalism — Down To Earthdowntoearth.org.in · tier 4
  6. 6Census 2011 Religion Table C-01 (study description, with appendix of 'Other religions and persuasions') — Office of the Registrar General & Census Commissioner, Indiacensusindia.gov.in · tier 1

Mains Q&A on this note

NCERT concepts in this note

Also on 18 November

All 18 November articles →