Critically examine the suo motu jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. Does the "Master of the Roster" principle strengthen or limit judicial responsiveness?
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Suo motu jurisdiction means the Supreme Court acts on its own, with no petitioner, usually after a media report or a letter. It draws on the Court's powers under Articles 32 and 142 [1]. It widens access to justice. But it is used at the Court's discretion, and the CJI's "Master of the Roster" role decides which Bench may hear such a case.
Suo motu jurisdiction: strengths
- A voice for the voiceless: in 2020, the Court took up the plight of migrant workers during the lockdown, when those affected could not go to court themselves.
- Speed: in the Central Secretariat Library case (2026), a Bench acted on media reports. It obtained a government undertaking not to shift books dating back to 1702 [2].
- Wider rights: the Court said "heritage is not just the Lutyens", which extends protection to documentary heritage [2].
Suo motu jurisdiction: weaknesses
- No codified criteria: no rule says which issues the Court picks up. This invites charges of selectivity.
- Separation of powers: the Court risks overreach into executive work, or seeming to be "governed by headlines".
- Procedure: there is no petitioner to set out the issues, so the Court relies heavily on an amicus curiae [2].
Master of the Roster: strengthens or limits?
Strengthens
- Discipline: Asok Pande (2018) held that only the CJI, not the collegium, allocates cases [3]. This stops forum shopping and stops Benches from taking up cases at will.
- Consistency: Shanti Bhushan (2018) reaffirmed the principle [4]. Allocating cases by subject keeps PIL rulings consistent.
Limits
- Delay: the library Bench had to refer the case to the CJI because it did not hold the PIL roster [2]. Until a new Bench is assigned, only an undertaking protects the books.
- Concentration of power: in January 2018, four senior judges held a press conference. They raised concerns about how sensitive cases were allocated.
Overall, the principle strengthens institutional discipline but can slow responsiveness. The way forward is:
- codified suo motu guidelines;
- published roster criteria;
- time-bound reallocation;
- consultation with senior judges on sensitive matters.
These steps would keep suo motu power true to Article 142's promise of "complete justice" and protect the judiciary's legitimacy.
Sources
- 1Constitution of India — Articles 32 and 142, Legislative Department, Ministry of Law & Justiceconstitutional basis for suo motu action and "complete justice"
- 2"There are books dating back to 1702: SC in library case", The Hindu, 21 Nov 2026suo motu action on media reports, 16 Nov undertaking, "heritage is not just the Lutyens", amicus curiae, referral to CJI for lack of PIL roster
- 3Asok Pande v. Supreme Court of India, W.P.(C) 147 of 2018, judgment dated 11 Apr 2018CJI alone is Master of the Roster
- 4Shanti Bhushan v. Supreme Court of India, W.P.(C) 789 of 2018, judgment dated 6 Jul 2018 — Supreme Court of Indiareaffirmed the CJI's roster authority and rejected a collegium-based roster
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.