Urban redevelopment projects often run into the preservation of institutional heritage. Suggest a governance framework for relocating historic public libraries and archives.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
The Supreme Court took suo motu cognisance of the eviction of the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library (CSL) from Shastri Bhavan. It remarked that "heritage is not just the Lutyens" [1]. The case shows how redevelopment deadlines can put documentary heritage at risk. A rules-based relocation framework, rather than case-by-case rescue, is needed.
Why a framework is needed
- Plans built for offices, not collections: the new Kartavya Bhavan buildings bring scattered ministries together [4]. However, the CSL was asked to vacate by 30 September without a confirmed new home [1].
- Legal gap: the AMASR Act, 1958 protects monuments, and the Public Records Act, 1993 covers official files. Reference libraries fall clearly under neither law.
- Ad hoc safeguards: today only a government undertaking to the Court protects the books [1].
Suggested governance framework
- Legal mandate: require a Heritage Impact Assessment before any vacate notice is issued. This gives effect to Art. 49 and Art. 51A(f).
- Institutional anchor: set up an inter-ministerial relocation committee. MoHUA would handle space, the Ministry of Culture would act as custodian, and conservators would advise. The Memory of the World national committee could list significant holdings [3].
- Audit first, allot later: count the items, shelf length and rare holdings before any move. The CSL alone holds about 8.48 lakh documents, with rare books dating back to 1702 [2]. Space should be allotted to match the collection.
- Conservation standards: move items in phases into climate-controlled space. Follow the UNESCO 2015 Recommendation, which covers identification, preservation and access [3].
- Access continuity: digitise the rare books as a backup, not a substitute. UNESCO treats the physical carrier as part of the heritage [3].
- Accountability: publish the relocation plan, consult users and commission an independent audit. Courts then become a last resort, not the first safeguard.
Inventory → Heritage Impact Assessment → Matched space → Phased conservation move → Public audit
Flowchart: relocation sequence
Redevelopment and heritage need not be in conflict if relocation follows an audit-led, legally backed protocol. Building the CSL episode into such a framework would protect India's documentary memory alongside its buildings. This would honour the Fundamental Duty to preserve our composite culture and UNESCO's call for access to documentary heritage.
Sources
- 1"There are books dating back to 1702: SC in library case", The Hindu, 21 Nov 2026 (news report)suo motu cognisance, "heritage is not just the Lutyens", 135-year-old CSL, 30 September vacate deadline, government undertaking
- 2Ministry of Culture, Annual Report 2024-25CSL holdings of 8.48 lakh documents; rare books section with oldest item from 1702
- 3UNESCO Recommendation concerning the Preservation of, and Access to, Documentary Heritage including in Digital Form (2015)identification, preservation and access; physical carrier as heritage; role of national committees
- 4PMIndia: PM inaugurates Kartavya Bhavan (Aug 2025)Common Central Secretariat buildings bringing scattered ministries together