·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityDefence

Special laws against organised crime often sit uneasily with fundamental rights. Using recent examples from South Asia, discuss the safeguards needed.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Why special laws sit uneasily with rights
  2. Safeguards needed

Organised crime covers drug, arms and trafficking networks whose leaders rarely commit the crime themselves, so ordinary criminal law struggles to reach them. Special laws close this gap by punishing gang membership and support. But tools that can reach a kingpin can also reach a protester, so safeguards must be written into the text.

Why special laws sit uneasily with rights

  • Diluted procedural safeguards: Rajasthan's 2023 Bill, a copy of MCOCA, 1999, removed protections for the accused on bail, confessions to police and phone interception [1]. Confessions made to police can be forced, which strains Article 20(3).
  • Vague definitions: OHCHR said Sri Lanka's anti-terrorism Bill defined terrorism too broadly, limited judicial guarantees and allowed long pre-trial detention [2].
  • Record of misuse: The UN High Commissioner urged Sri Lanka to repeal the PTA, 1979 and release long-term detainees [3].
  • One-time judicial review: Sri Lanka's Supreme Court found the Prevention of Organised Crimes Bill "not inconsistent" with the Constitution before it became law. Critics still warned that it could undermine fundamental rights [4]. A review of the text alone cannot foresee how the law will be used.

Safeguards needed

  • Narrow definition: Link organised crime to serious offences committed for material gain, and keep protest and dissent outside it [2]. India's Supreme Court upheld MCOCA's definition as precise in State of Maharashtra v. Bharat Shanti Lal Shah (2008) [1].
  • Judicial control of detention: Require quick production before a magistrate, a right to challenge detention orders, and time limits on pre-trial custody [2], in the spirit of Article 22.
  • Independent monitoring: Give the human rights commission access to detention sites [2].
  • Correction after enactment: In India, Articles 13, 32 and 226 allowed the Supreme Court to strike down one MCOCA bail provision [1]. Where courts cannot review a law once it is passed, as in Sri Lanka, the legislature should add sunset clauses and require annual reports on arrests and convictions.
  • No overlapping laws: Repeal the PTA alongside the new law [3], so that officials do not hold two sets of sweeping powers.

Special laws are needed against networked crime, but they stay legitimate only if they are precise and supervised. A narrow definition, judicial oversight and legislative review keep them within Article 21's fair-procedure standard and SDG 16's goal of just, accountable institutions. This lets security and liberty support each other.

Sources

  1. 1PRS Legislative Research – State Legislative Brief: The Rajasthan Control of Organized Crime Bill, 2023Bill copies MCOCA; safeguards removed on bail, confessions, interception; MCOCA definition upheld in *Bharat Shanti Lal Shah*; one bail provision struck down
  2. 2OHCHR statement on Sri Lanka's Anti-Terrorism Bill (UN Web TV / UNifeed)broad definition, limited judicial guarantees, long pre-trial detention, limits on Human Rights Commission visits to detention sites
  3. 3UN News – "UN says Sri Lanka has 'historic opportunity' to end impunity, deliver justice" (Aug 2025)call to repeal the PTA and release long-term detainees
  4. 4The Hindu – "Sri Lanka's organised crime Bill gets Supreme Court's approval" (PTI, 22 Nov 2026)Supreme Court found the Bill "not inconsistent" with the Constitution; critics' fundamental-rights concerns
Practice
8 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity