·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityEnvironment

Ex post facto environmental clearance undermines the precautionary principle. Discuss in light of recent Supreme Court decisions.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How ex post facto EC undermines precaution
  2. Shifting SC position
  3. The case for limited regularisation
  4. Way forward

The precautionary principle, recognised as part of Indian law in Vellore Citizens' Welfare Forum (1996), requires that environmental harm be anticipated and prevented, not repaired afterwards. The EIA Notification, 2006 puts it into practice through prior Environmental Clearance (EC). Ex post facto EC, granted after work has begun, reverses that order, and recent Supreme Court (SC) rulings show how hard the two are to reconcile.

How ex post facto EC undermines precaution

  • Assessment becomes a formality: once land is cleared and structures are built, appraisal cannot change the site or design. It can only suggest mitigation.
  • Moral hazard: if a fee is the only cost, a project gains by building first. The SC found the 2021 Office Memorandum (OM) to be a perpetual amnesty open to all permissible projects [3].
  • Public hearing is bypassed, so affected communities lose their say before the harm happens (Article 21).

Shifting SC position

  • Common Cause (2017) and Alembic (2020) called ex post facto EC "alien to environmental jurisprudence" [3].
  • Vanashakti-I (May 2025) struck down the 2017 Notification and the 2021 OM and barred future post-facto ECs [1].
  • Review (November 2025, 2:1) recalled that ruling. Justice Bhuyan dissented, holding that precaution cannot be given "short shrift" by the reparative polluter-pays principle [2].
  • Vanashakti (July 2026) held prior EC mandatory and quashed the 2021 OM prospectively. It allowed only a narrowly tailored amnesty through a Section 3 notification [3].

The case for limited regularisation

  • Supervening public interest: some non-compliant projects may need to be kept for wider public benefit, so the Court upheld the time-bound 2017 Notification [3].
  • Legal certainty: ECs already granted stay valid unless challenged individually [3].

Way forward

  • Allow regularisation only through statutory, one-time, closed windows, never through office orders [3].
  • Make remediation and post-clearance monitoring conditions of any regularisation, not merely penalties.

Ex post facto EC, if routine, would empty the precautionary principle of meaning. The SC has moved towards treating prior EC as the rule and amnesty as a bounded, statutory exception. Holding that line keeps development consistent with Articles 21 and 48A and with SDG 15.

Sources

  1. 1Supreme Court of India, *Vanashakti v. Union of India*, 2025 INSC 718 (16 May 2025)struck down the 2017 Notification and 2021 OM; barred future ex post facto EC
  2. 2Supreme Court of India, *Confederation of Real Estate Developers of India v. Vanashakti*, 2025 INSC 1326 (18 November 2025)2:1 recall of Vanashakti-I; Justice Bhuyan's dissent on precaution vs polluter-pays
  3. 3Supreme Court of India, *Vanashakti v. Union of India*, 2026 INSC 761 (29 July 2026)prior EC mandatory; 2021 OM a perpetual amnesty, quashed prospectively; 2017 Notification upheld as time-bound; existing ECs valid; future amnesty only by Section 3 notification; reading of Common Cause and Alembic
Practice
3 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity