·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityEnvironment

Repeated executive exemptions from Environmental Clearance have been struck down by courts. Critically examine the case for and against exempting educational buildings from the EIA framework.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Case for exemption
  2. Case against exemption

The EIA Notification, 2006 was issued under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. Under it, building projects with a built-up area above 20,000 sq m need prior Environmental Clearance (EC) [1]. The Kerala High Court quashed the 2014 exemption for educational buildings, and the Supreme Court struck down the 2025 exemption that replaced it [2]. The aim behind the exemption is defensible, but the way it was designed has not survived in court.

Case for exemption

  • Public good: Campuses serve the expansion goals of NEP 2020. EC appraisal adds cost and delay to construction that is largely non-profit and socially valuable.
  • Avoiding duplication: Building bye-laws can carry environmental conditions. MoEFCC itself proposed integrating EC conditions with building permissions [6].
  • Legitimate reliance: Institutions that built while an exemption was in force followed the law as it then stood. Once the exemption was quashed, a prior EC became impossible for a finished building, so these institutions are stranded.
  • Procedural, not substantive, defect: The Kerala HC quashed the 2014 notification because the final text differed from the draft [2]. The policy itself was not condemned.

Case against exemption

  • Size, not purpose, drives impact: A large college uses as much water and produces as much sewage and debris as any other building of its size. The SC found the exemption had no rational nexus with the EIA's objective, making it arbitrary under the Article 14 test [2].
  • Precautionary principle: Prior EC prevents harm before it occurs. The SC held ex post facto EC to be contrary to environmental law and struck down the 2021 SOP for violation cases [3].
  • Regulatory instability: The SC recalled that ruling in 2025 [4], and a larger bench reaffirmed in 2026 that prior EC is mandatory [5]. Each loosening has brought fresh litigation and uncertainty.
  • Slippery slope: Carve-outs for one sector invite demands from others. The 2025 exemption also covered industrial sheds [2].

Education's social value cannot dilute a regime that is based on environmental impact, but stranded campuses still need a lawful way to comply. The way forward is a narrow, one-time statutory notification:

  • eligibility tied to the dates when an exemption was in force, not to the type of institution;
  • an audit of water use, waste handling and green cover;
  • a conditional EC with monitoring after clearance;
  • deliberate violators excluded.

This calibrated approach upholds Article 48A and SDGs 4 and 11, and keeps the "prior" in prior EC.

Sources

  1. 1EIA Notification, S.O. 1533(E), 14 September 2006 – MoEFCC: 20,000 sq m built-up area threshold for prior EC; issued under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986
  2. 2Supreme Court, 2025 INSC 1112 (Note 1 to Entry 8(a), EIA Notification): exemption for schools, colleges, hostels and industrial sheds struck down as lacking rational nexus; Kerala HC's procedural quashing of the 2014 notification
  3. 3Supreme Court, Vanashakti v. Union of India, 2025 INSC 718: ex post facto EC and the 2021 Office Memorandum struck down
  4. 4Supreme Court, 2025 INSC 1326 (18 November 2025): recall of the Vanashakti judgment barring post-facto EC
  5. 5Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 761 (July 2026): larger bench reaffirms that prior EC is mandatory
  6. 6PIB: Amendment in EIA Notification, 2006 on Integration of Environmental Conditions with Building Permissions: MoEFCC proposal to integrate EC conditions with building permissions
Practice
3 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity