Examine the RBI's powers under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 over the management of private-sector banks. Should the RBI also be the gatekeeper for criminal prosecution of bank executives?
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Under the Banking Regulation (BR) Act, 1949, the RBI is more than a prudential regulator. It decides who may run a private bank. In November 2026 the Bombay High Court set aside ICICI Bank Board's sanction to prosecute Chanda Kochhar. It held that the RBI is the competent authority because it holds removal power under Section 36-AA(1) [1]. That ruling stretches the RBI's control over management into criminal prosecution.
RBI's powers over private-bank management
- Entry: Under Section 35B, a bank needs the RBI's prior approval to appoint, re-appoint or pay its MD and whole-time directors [2].
- Removal: Under Section 36-AA, the RBI can remove a Chairperson, director or officer in the depositors' or public interest [1][2].
- Board oversight: Under Section 36-AB, the RBI can appoint additional directors. Under Section 36-ACA, it can supersede the Board, as it did at Yes Bank (2020) [2].
- Directions and resolution: Section 35A lets the RBI issue binding directions. Section 45 lets it impose a moratorium and reconstruct or merge a bank [2].
RBI as prosecution gatekeeper: the case for
- Legal coherence: Private bankers count as public servants through Section 46-A, as held in CBI v. Ramesh Gelli (2016) [3]. Under the PC Act, sanction lies with the authority that can remove the officer, and for bankers that is the RBI [1].
- Independence: A Board judging its own former CEO has a conflict of interest. The HC found the Board never examined the CBI's material [1].
- Trial safety: A sanction from the wrong authority counts as no sanction [1]. It is better to correct it now than to lose a conviction on appeal.
Concerns
- The regulator's own conflict: The RBI supervised ICICI while the Videocon loans were being made.
- Delay: The Supreme Court has held the three-month limit for sanction to be mandatory (Vineet Narain; Subramanian Swamy, 2012) [4]. It allowed only one extra month for legal consultation (Vijay Rajmohan, 2022) [5]. The RBI has no record of deciding sanction requests.
- Cascade: Past cases where a bank's own Board granted sanction may now be challenged.
The RBI's control over who enters, stays in and leaves bank management makes it the logical sanctioning authority. Its gatekeeping must not slide into shielding, though. A short amendment to the PC Act or BR Act should name the RBI as the sanctioning authority. It should also set a written, time-bound procedure with a hearing for the officer and deemed sanction on delay, as the Supreme Court suggested [4], with CVC tracking of pending cases. That would back the answer here, a conditional "yes", and advance the rule of law and SDG-16's call for accountable institutions.
Sources
- 1Bombay HC sets aside ICICI Bank Board of Directors' sanction order on Chanda Kochhar, The Hindu (Nov 18, 2026)Section 36-AA(1) holding; RBI as competent authority; Board did not examine CBI material; invalid sanction treated as no sanction
- 2The Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (India Code)Sections 35A, 35B, 36-AA, 36-AB, 36-ACA, 45
- 3Supreme Court of India, CBI v. Ramesh Gelli, Crl. A. 1077-1081 of 2013 (23 Feb 2016)private-bank officers are public servants under the PC Act, read with Section 46-A of the BR Act
- 4Requirement of sanction, PRS Legislative Researchthree-month limit from *Vineet Narain* and *Subramanian Swamy*; deemed-sanction suggestion
- 5Supreme Court of India, Vijay Rajmohan v. State (11 Oct 2022)three months plus one month for legal consultation is mandatory