Judicial impropriety allegations, roster control and recusal norms affect public trust in the judiciary. Discuss.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
The Supreme Court's own Restatement of Values of Judicial Life (1997) insists that justice must not only be done but be seen to be done [1]. Public trust therefore turns on visible process — how a case is listed and who hears it — as much as on the correctness of the verdict.
Allegations of impropriety and conflict of interest
- In September 2026, the Lawyers Association for Constitution sought recall of an interim order in the appeal of the Noida DM, who is the CEC's daughter, citing reports of a family link between the presiding judge and ECI counsel [2].
- Such claims remain unverified allegations, not court findings [2]; yet reputational damage precedes verification, because the institution has no quick way to publicly answer them.
Roster control
- The CJI is "master of the roster", and listing is executed by the Registry without published reasons.
- The objection here is of "improper listing" before a Bench not holding the roster for that category of petitions [2]. Unexplained discretion over who hears what invites suspicion even where none is warranted.
Recusal norms
- India has no statute or rule codifying recusal; the judge whose impartiality is questioned decides the question himself, with no appeal.
- The 1997 Restatement only advises judges against hearing matters involving relatives or close associates [1]. A test resting on appearances cannot credibly be applied by the person being viewed.
Spillover to other institutions
- The same Bench split on referring the challenge to the CEC/EC Act, 2023 to a larger Bench, leaving it with the CJI [2].
- Since Anoop Baranwal (2023) grounded ECI independence in an insulated appointment process [3], and the Act gives the Executive a majority on the Selection Committee [4], perceived judicial hesitation erodes trust in two constitutional institutions at once.
Trust is sustained by transparent procedure rather than assertions of integrity. Subject-wise published rosters with automated listing, written recusal guidelines requiring reasoned orders, and a strengthened in-house procedure would let the judiciary answer doubts institutionally — realising the Restatement's own promise that impartiality must be visible.
Sources
- 1Restatement of Values of Judicial Life, Supreme Court of Indiajustice must be seen to be done; judges advised against hearing matters involving relatives or close associates
- 2Lawyer group calls for fresh hearing in the Noida DM case, The Hindu (26 Sept 2026)recall demand, alleged improper listing, reported ECI counsel link, Bench split pending with the CJI
- 3*Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India* (2 March 2023), Digital SCRindependence of the Election Commission and its appointment process
- 4PRS Legislative Research, CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Bill, 2023Selection Committee of PM, Cabinet Minister and LoP, replacing the CJI