·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolity

Has the Lokpal lived up to its mandate as India's anti-corruption ombudsman? Critically examine its structural and procedural limitations.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. Where the Lokpal delivers
  2. Structural limitations
  3. Procedural limitations

The Lokpal is a statutory ombudsman set up under the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013 [1]. Its mandate is to investigate corruption by public servants quickly and independently. More than a decade later it has a sound legal framework, but it has met its mandate only partly.

Where the Lokpal delivers

  • Collegial and mixed composition: a Chairperson and up to 8 members, half of them judicial. The President appoints them on the advice of a Selection Committee that includes the CJI [2].
  • Due process built into the Act: the public servant is asked for comments during the preliminary inquiry and is heard by a three-member bench before it decides whether a prima facie case exists. These safeguards do not hold up search and seizure [1].
  • Check on false complaints: the bench can close a case and act against the complainant under Sec. 46 [1].

Structural limitations

  • Slow start: the Search Committee was formed only in February 2014, and PIB was still reporting on appointments in 2018 [3].
  • Wings not fully working: the Prosecution Wing was formally set up only in June 2025. The 160th Standing Committee Report asked for a review of staffing because complaints are rising [4].
  • Reliance on other agencies: preliminary inquiries can go to "any agency", and complaints against Group A/B officers can be sent to the CVC [1]. This weakens its independence.
  • Small bench capacity: at most nine people hear every case [2].

Procedural limitations

  • Court challenges mid-inquiry: in the Chinmoyjit Sen case, a February 2026 show-cause notice was challenged in court. The Delhi HC held that the right to be heard arises before final action under Sec. 20(3). The SC issued notice to the Lokpal in November 2026 [5].
  • Time limits missed: the Act allows 90 (+90) days for a preliminary inquiry and 6 months (extendable) for an investigation [1]. This dispute alone has lasted about nine months [5].
  • Rules left unclear: Sec. 20(12) leaves it to regulations to say which documents the accused gets [1]. These gaps invite litigation.

Overall, the Lokpal has the legal structure but not yet the capacity or procedural clarity to be an effective ombudsman. The way forward:

  • The SC should lay down a clear test for when the hearing must happen.
  • The Lokpal should write its procedure into regulations under Sec. 20(12).
  • The Centre should act on the Standing Committee's staffing advice [4].

Together these would balance fair procedure under Article 21 with quick accountability, in line with SDG 16.5.

Sources

  1. 1The Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013 (full text), PRS Indiastatutory status; Sec. 20 hearing steps and time limits; Sec. 20(12); Sec. 46; CVC referral
  2. 2The Lokpal and Lokayuktas Bill, 2011 (Bill Track), PRS Indiacomposition, 50% judicial members, Selection Committee
  3. 3PIB Press Release on status of Lokpal appointments (PRID 1539259)Search Committee of 21 Feb 2014; appointment status in 2018
  4. 4PIB Press Release on the 160th Report of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justicestaffing review; Prosecution Wing set up June 2025
  5. 5The Hindu: SC notice to Lokpal on plea against HC verdict saying hearing not needed before show-cause noticeChinmoyjit Sen case timeline; Delhi HC and SC orders
Practice
4 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity