"Natural justice is flexible, not a fixed formula." Discuss this in the context of the Lokpal's inquiry procedure under Section 20 of the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →In this answer
Natural justice, especially audi alteram partem (hear the other side), is read into Article 21 as fair procedure whose content varies with the stage and stakes of a process. Section 20 of the Lokpal Act spreads hearings across stages; the Delhi High Court upheld this in April 2026, and the Supreme Court is now examining it [1].
Flexibility built into Section 20
- Preliminary inquiry: the Inquiry Wing seeks the public servant's comments before reporting within 60 days, under Sec. 20(2) [2].
- Prima facie stage: a bench of at least three members decides only after hearing the public servant, under Sec. 20(3) [2].
- Before investigation: an explanation is called for, but a proviso stops it from hindering search and seizure [2].
- Before charge-sheet: the public servant's comments are taken under Sec. 20(7) [2].
- Delhi HC view: the show-cause notice itself delivers the Sec. 20(3) hearing, so no prior hearing is needed [1].
Why calibrated hearings are justified
- Time limits: a preliminary inquiry gets 90 days, plus 90 more only with written reasons [2]; this case has already run about nine months since the show-cause notice [1].
- No added value: a hearing on whether to hold a hearing adds a point for court challenge, not new facts.
- Capacity: the 160th Parliamentary Standing Committee Report sought a review of Lokpal staffing [3].
- Other safeguards: the multi-member bench, and action against false complainants under Sec. 46 [2].
Where flexibility must stop
- Reputation: Sec. 21 gives even third persons a hearing in the preliminary inquiry if their reputation is at stake [2].
- Real hearing: an officer who cannot see the evidence replies blind; Sec. 20(12) provides for regulations on which documents must be shared [2].
- Pre-judgment risk: the notice came two days after a Lokpal order, raising doubt whether the bench had already decided [1].
Section 20 thus treats natural justice as a series of calibrated hearings, not a single ritual. The Supreme Court should lay down a test rather than a yes/no: a show-cause hearing counts only if the documents relied on are shared and the reply is genuinely considered before the Sec. 20(3) decision. The Lokpal should write this into its Sec. 20(12) regulations, and the Centre should fill staff gaps [3]. This reconciles Article 21 fairness with swift accountability, advancing SDG 16.
Sources
- 1The Hindu (news report): "SC notice to Lokpal on plea against HC verdict saying hearing not needed before show-cause notice" (Nov 2026)Delhi HC ruling of 15 Apr 2026, SC notice of 18 Nov 2026, show-cause notice of 27 Feb 2026 following the order of 25 Feb 2026
- 2The Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013 (full text), PRS IndiaSec. 20(1) provisos, 20(2), 20(3), 20(7), 20(12), Sec. 21, Sec. 46, inquiry time limits
- 3PIB: Press Release on the 160th Report of the Department-Related Parliamentary Standing Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justicerecommendation to review Lokpal Secretariat staffing