·The Hindu·15 marks·250–350 wordsPolityIR

Paradiplomacy by States can strengthen India's global engagement but also strain the Union's exclusive domain over foreign affairs. Critically analyse.

New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →
In this answer
  1. How paradiplomacy strengthens global engagement
  2. How it strains the Union's domain

Paradiplomacy means sub-national governments dealing directly with foreign actors for investment, culture or politics. In India, foreign affairs is a Union subject (Entry 10, List I), and Parliament alone can give effect to treaties under Article 253 [1]. State outreach therefore adds to India's diplomacy when it is coordinated with the Union and works against it when it is not.

How paradiplomacy strengthens global engagement

  • Investment and trade: States compete for FDI through investor summits. The MEA set up a States Division (2014) to link States, Indian missions abroad and the Ministry [2].
  • Institutional support: The Division helps with sister-state/sister-city agreements, MoUs with foreign counterparts, and choosing target countries for outreach [3]. This is cooperative federalism applied to foreign policy.
  • Neighbourhood and diaspora links: Border States are central to Act East connectivity. Coastal States have close ties with their diaspora.
  • Soft power: State tourism, culture and universities spread India's presence beyond New Delhi.

How it strains the Union's domain

  • Political platforms: The Bharat Summit 2026, Hyderabad, reportedly held under the Telangana government's aegis, brought in foreign invitees. A foreign party functionary there raised a slogan questioning India's electoral process. A Supreme Court petition now seeks takedown of the videos [4].
  • Veto over treaties: State objections have at times stalled water-sharing and fisheries arrangements with neighbours, which weakens the Union's credibility.
  • Mixed signals: When a State and the Centre take opposite positions on foreign guests, partners get conflicting messages and India's sovereign voice is diluted [4].
  • Regulatory gaps: No clear protocol covers political activity by foreign guests at State-hosted events. Disputes are settled through visa refusals or litigation.

Assessment Economic and cultural paradiplomacy is mostly positive and already institutionalised [2]. The strain arises when it turns political or overrides treaty obligations.

Paradiplomacy is useful when States act as partners, not parallel foreign offices. Possible next steps:

  • Strengthen the States Division into a statutory consultation forum, possibly through the Inter-State Council.
  • Issue published MHA–MEA guidelines on foreign participants at State events.
  • Consult States early on border-related treaties.

This would keep the unity of India's external voice that the Constitution intends while drawing on the energy of its States.

Sources

  1. 1The Constitution of India, Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and JusticeArticle 253 and the Union List; Union's exclusive power over foreign affairs
  2. 2MEA, Lok Sabha Q. No. 687 – Separate Division for Centre-State Relationscreation and mandate of the States Division
  3. 3Ministry of External Affairs, Annual Report 2025sister-state agreements, State MoUs, outreach facilitation
  4. 4The Hindu – Italian politician's remark: Supreme Court to hear plea for removal of videos from social media on November 20Bharat Summit 2026 held under Telangana government's aegis, foreign invitees, SC takedown plea
Practice
6 questions on this article
Check the answer for each question, or reveal all at once.
Practice MCQs →

More from this note

More on Polity