Paradiplomacy by States can strengthen India's global engagement but also strain the Union's exclusive domain over foreign affairs. Critically analyse.
New · District CollectorCan you hold the district for 72 hours?Floods, a heatwave, an outbreak, a grievance queue. Take the decisions, see the consequences.Play →Paradiplomacy means sub-national governments dealing directly with foreign actors for investment, culture or politics. In India, foreign affairs is a Union subject (Entry 10, List I), and Parliament alone can give effect to treaties under Article 253 [1]. State outreach therefore adds to India's diplomacy when it is coordinated with the Union and works against it when it is not.
How paradiplomacy strengthens global engagement
- Investment and trade: States compete for FDI through investor summits. The MEA set up a States Division (2014) to link States, Indian missions abroad and the Ministry [2].
- Institutional support: The Division helps with sister-state/sister-city agreements, MoUs with foreign counterparts, and choosing target countries for outreach [3]. This is cooperative federalism applied to foreign policy.
- Neighbourhood and diaspora links: Border States are central to Act East connectivity. Coastal States have close ties with their diaspora.
- Soft power: State tourism, culture and universities spread India's presence beyond New Delhi.
How it strains the Union's domain
- Political platforms: The Bharat Summit 2026, Hyderabad, reportedly held under the Telangana government's aegis, brought in foreign invitees. A foreign party functionary there raised a slogan questioning India's electoral process. A Supreme Court petition now seeks takedown of the videos [4].
- Veto over treaties: State objections have at times stalled water-sharing and fisheries arrangements with neighbours, which weakens the Union's credibility.
- Mixed signals: When a State and the Centre take opposite positions on foreign guests, partners get conflicting messages and India's sovereign voice is diluted [4].
- Regulatory gaps: No clear protocol covers political activity by foreign guests at State-hosted events. Disputes are settled through visa refusals or litigation.
Assessment Economic and cultural paradiplomacy is mostly positive and already institutionalised [2]. The strain arises when it turns political or overrides treaty obligations.
Paradiplomacy is useful when States act as partners, not parallel foreign offices. Possible next steps:
- Strengthen the States Division into a statutory consultation forum, possibly through the Inter-State Council.
- Issue published MHA–MEA guidelines on foreign participants at State events.
- Consult States early on border-related treaties.
This would keep the unity of India's external voice that the Constitution intends while drawing on the energy of its States.
Sources
- 1The Constitution of India, Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and JusticeArticle 253 and the Union List; Union's exclusive power over foreign affairs
- 2MEA, Lok Sabha Q. No. 687 – Separate Division for Centre-State Relationscreation and mandate of the States Division
- 3Ministry of External Affairs, Annual Report 2025sister-state agreements, State MoUs, outreach facilitation
- 4The Hindu – Italian politician's remark: Supreme Court to hear plea for removal of videos from social media on November 20Bharat Summit 2026 held under Telangana government's aegis, foreign invitees, SC takedown plea